Rated 4.17 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review As for the Total...
As for the Total Temptation™ Washable Mascara, I'm such a fan!
What the product claims to do: Total Temptation™ Washable Mascara builds lashes for full and soft volume. Build on bold volume to create irresistibly soft, separated, and dense lashes coat after coat. Features a creamy and whipped formula infused with coconut extract.
-The product didn't clump. I hate when mascara's clump and my eyelashes end up sticking together.
-The packaging is bomb! How cute?!
-The mascara comes in the shade blackest black. I love dark mascara
-My lashes had instant volume, but they weren't crazy hard and stiff looking.
None as of yet :)
Most Helpful Critical Review I received this...
I received this mascara, along with a few other goodies from Influenster, and being totally honest, it's not my favorite. I'd read a ton of reviews on this saying that it was amazing, and it may be holy grail status for some, but it just wasn't a perfect fit for me. That being said, it's not a horrible product by any means. For me, this is a great lengthening mascara. I have long lashes to begin with, but this definitely helped to add even more length. But, in terms of volume, this just didn't cut it for me. I found that this mascara was more likely to clump up on me, and didn't really make my lashes look any fuller.
Reviewed by 1799 customers I would buy this again
Bailey from Kokomo, Indiana
Love the bottle design
Not perfect but very good
CS from MD
This mascara is great, I compare it to L'Oréal lash paradise and I'd say it's pretty close. I like the smell and feel of this formula, it's very lightweight and washes off easily. Lashes look lifted and voluminous, also gives a nice natural curl. Only thing that's slightly lacking is length, it's not quite as good as lash paradise but still pretty nice. Also the brush is nice but takes a little getting used to, can feel slightly scratchy if you get too close to your eyes so be careful. Overall a great mascara! I'm glad I bought it but I'll probably go back to the L'Oréal one eventually.
hessy from usa
i absolutely love this mascara it's a bit clumpy but adds so much volume to my stumpy and short lashes!! 10/10 would recommend!!!!
Worst mascara ever
Ash from St. Louis, MO
I have been looking for a more affordable drug store mascara, and this is not what I was expecting. I like brushes similar to this one, however there was less than half the amount of bristles as pictured. The mascara was terribly clumpy and my lashes looked like I had nothing on after two coats. Highly disappointed.
I have never had issues untill now
Laura from Columbus
I have always used this mascara with no issues I bought it brand new and it was like someone had used it before the wand looked run down and the mascara was hard to put on like it was old and clumpy !
Great mascara, doesn't clump with length
Diane from Canton Georgia
Great everyday mascara
This is a miracle worker
Rebeca from Wichita, is
It adds a lot of length to my short lashes & super easy to wash off & remove when I need to. I love it!!!!
Steph from Trussville, Al
I love this mascara! It makes my lashes look fuller and longer with just one coat! It's a great drugstore mascara... better than the lash paradise. I think it's a good dupe for the Lancome Monsieur Big mascara
Don't buy it
Kate from USA
super clumpy and not flattering
Amy J from Youngstown Ohio
This is a nice, soft mascara. Provides fullness without clumping or stickiness. No irritation and feathery wear. Very affordable.
Best mascara i have had
Tashaelisee from UK
Generally love this mascara and i always get compliments on my eyelashes. Have been using it for over a year and dont think il ever use another one.
ana from Racine
Made my eyelashes look amazing
Total temptaion waterproof
FaithF from undisclosed
Just bought this as a new alternative to my usual other brand. So disappointed- brush was covered in mascara. Clump is an understatement !!! just flakes offday. Comes off in shower too so don't think very waterproof at all. Worst mascara I have ever bought!!! If I could give it a zero I would
Lala from Los ángeles
I like overall the mascara
I will definitely repurchase
Skincare Mel from Wichita
This mascara is good from the first swipe. It looks great even if I don't curl my lashes. It gives great volume and doesn't flake!
You get what you pay for
CL from New York
These reviews are really intense, this mascara is a wet formula. Therefore it can easily clump, and the wand will pick up a lot when pulled out. Just as similar to the beloved TF better than s*x or Marc Jacobs Velvet Noir. I recommend scraping the edges of your wand inside of the tube to get of the excess mascara before applying in addition, when you apply use loose powder to set under your eyes to prevent fallout from the mascara, as you wipe away the powder any fallout will go away. This did not run for me, as I always set my face. I was actually surprised by this mascara and enjoyed it more than lash paradise.
LeiLei from Tn
I am extremely particular and a good mascara is hard to find. I absolutely love it, and it doesn't bother my contact lenses like most mascaras do. Tens across the board hunni
FMT from Arizona
This is my first time trying this product. I do not care for it. It clumps up, I really do not care for the wand nor the formula.
I would never use anything else!
Make-up lover from Marlton NJ
No need to spend a fortune on mascara!
Gives you length
Jas from Los Angeles
I like how much length it gave my eyelashes and how natural it looked. I didn't like how it took some time to fully dry and the wand picks up a lot of product that can get on your eyelid if not being very careful.
Murumai from FL
I bought this at a different place, but its the same product so i thought i should review it. This mascara is amazing for every day use. I dont use mascara too often bc i dont like taking it off, but it looks good for going out or going to school and such. i definitely recommend this is youre starting out or you're looking for an every day look.
KCmom from Merced, CA
Super easy application, brush didn't carry too much mascara & clump up my lashes. I LOVE how it gave length & volume without looking fake.
I hit 40 my once long lashes started thinning. Thank you Maybelline for giving them back to me!
Great lash has always been my go to & it was my moms also. Please keep this great product around just as long. I'm so glad I tried it.
Too much product on wand.
Lupe from Utah
Too much product comes out when taking the wand out. Makes lashes very clumpy. Would work great combined with other mascaras. Was hoping one mascara would do the trick. This is only to add thickness to your lashes.
I would not buy this product again
Anna from Fort Smith, AR
The packaging is very appealing, but the actual formula was not great. I have to add multiple coats to get the look that I want.
NickiName from Colorado
This is a lovely shade of cocoa and goes on very smooth, but I had huge dark smudges under my eyes by noon. I'll stick with my CG Flourish.