Rated 3.39 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Amazing product for the price.
Does not clump and stays put. My eyes water often because of allergies and the mascara stays put and does not clump together.
Most Helpful Critical Review Almay Waterproof Mascara
This mascara has an odor that stays with you all day, it's a turn off for me. It does have a nice brush that is narrow at the tip making it nice for reaching inner lashes. Would not buy again.
Reviewed by 109 customers works fine but weird smell
Sophie from New York
The mascara is waterproof and looks pretty natural - not over the top which is what I wanted, but the mascara has a very weird smell that does not go away. At first I thought my brushes were dirty and giving off the weird smell but I then noticed it was the mascara. After I use it I smell the odor for the entire rest of the day until I take it off. Not worth it dispite how it looks on.
Magenta from Mars, wi
Good for old ladies. Mascara stays on lashes, doesn't migrate all over the bags around the eyes
I wouldn't waste my money on this item
Paterna from Highland, IN
Not a fan of mascaras that cause clumpy lashes, I prefer one that separates & defines them.
Nice but clumpy
Annie from California
Good for long lashes but has a clumpy effect and dries out quickly.
Smudges like crazy
Rose B. from Sacramento, CA
I like how this mascara makes my lashes look - full and long, but not freaky long. Unfortunately it smudges and gives me raccoon eyes by lunchtime. If you want 2-3 hours of good lashes, then buy this. Otherwise look elsewhere!
Tried to like this BUT
Vmarvin from Bergen County, NJ, USA
I tried to like this based on a recommendation but I threw it in the garbage after almost 10 uses. I got raccoon eyes EVERY time I used it after a couple of hours! It does add length but Maybelline Colossal Volume Waterproof mascara adds more volume than this. Maybelline Cossal Volume Waterproof masacara also smudges by the end of the day but this is worst. I do not recommend this Almay mascara.
Tammi from Vacherie, la
Don't waste your money, half way thru the day you smears bad
Sunshine from Stow, Ohio
The smaller brushes is very nice but mascara doesn't stay on, you'll get raccoon eyes very quickly with smears and flakes .
Not so waterproof
Water Girl from Juno FL
Tends to come off when I'm in the boat and causes raccoon eyes.
D from Bay area, ca
Was looking for a waterproof brand that provided additional benefits including thickening. I wear Almays ont time multi benefit and dont have anybissuss, sobi figured thier thickening version should work in a similar manner. This version last 5 minutes and it stung like crazy. Guess I'll switch back. No biggie.
Love this mascara!
Bashful from Lake Wylie , SC
Goes on smoothly, no clumps. And no raccoon eyes! Have tried many brands and this is the first that doesn't melt by the end of the day. But even though it's called one coat, I need to apply 2-3 coats to get the fullness I want.
Jill from Waterford MI
Great price and great product. I don't care for the hard plastic applicator that many of the other mascara has.
I bought this on accident:/
Helpful Friend from Colorado
I bought this mascara by accident, thinking that it was a primer mascara and not just a basic mascara. The packaging really through me off. Anyway, the product is good. It's extremely basic, the brush is basic. If you like more natural lashes with not a lot of volume then this is great for you.
Lady of Jewels from St Joseph, MO
Smudged and irritated eyes. Not waterproof as stated.
product junkie from Phoenix, AZ
I usually use the non-waterproof version but I would look like a raccoon by mid morning so I figured I would try this waterproof version. What a difference, no raccoon eyes.
no, it was not water proof as per package and it clumps
Lin from cape coral
Did not live up to claims
Non irritating for chronic dry eyes
Dry Eye from Florida
This is the first mascara i've used that doesn't irritate my eyes after 30 minutes. I have long straight lashes and it definitely lengthens my lashes but does not hold a curl. Would looks fine for everyday but for going out I would probably choose a more dramatic mascara (If I can find one that's also non irritating)
NRV from Garland, TX
I have used Almay waterproof mascara for years. I like it because it is hypoallergenic and is dermatological tested as my eyes are sensitive. Plus since it is waterproof I can wear it anywhere, swimming, going out, etc and it does not smudge.
sammy417 from Washington Crossing, PA
Really love this mascara! I have had trouble finding a mascara that applies evenly and coats all lashes with one coat. This one does the job, and I have tried many! Would definitely recommend.
best mascara out there. Tried others, always return to it
De from River Forest il
New package style, hopefully same formula
I would not buy again
Heather from Suwanee
Makes lashes very clumpy
I love this product.
Jan from Mesa, Az
It does not irritate my eyes. I wear contacts. It also is easy to remove with out much effort. I just love it!!!
Best on eyes with problems.
Patty G from Grosse Ile, MI
I WOULD BUY PRODUCT AGAIN
NO NAME from SAN DIEGO, CA
i USE IT EVERYDAY. i LIKE IT BECAUSE IT IS WATERPROOF. I CAN WEAR IT TO MY WATER EXERCISE CLASSES
Only mascara I wear
Southern momma from Tulsa Ok
I have sentive eyes and wear contacts. This is the only mascara I can wear right now.