Rated 3.57 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Amazing eyeliner
The Thats the Point eyeliner is an awesome product! It creates amazing eyes with minimal effort! I appreciate the fact that it goes on flawless given my limited skills, and doesn't smudge or wear off. The product is priced well and the results are beautiful! Im in love!
Most Helpful Critical Review Giving it one more try
I had high hopes for this product. I consistently do a winged look and I don't have time to try to perfect my wings before work. This product definitely made it a lot easier to get my winged look as well as be symmetrical (one of my biggest problems) However, the ink in this lasted a week. I am trying to give it the benefit of the doubt because I've used NYX liner before and it lasts months and months. I'm hoping this was just a defective one-off product.
Reviewed by 434 customers Kinda thick and dries out quick
Lauren from Michigan
First of all, I did not expect this product to be thick like a crayola marker. It makes it a bit awkward to hold, especially if you're holding it on a slant to do winged liner. I've also found that the felt tip dries out quickly and you have to press down a bit for the product to come out.
That being said, I do like the fine point and how rich the pigment is. I just wish the tip didn't dry out this fast.
alyssamariiee1 from arizona
I used this one time and it was dried out. Totally dry. I am so disappointed.
This eyeliner 100% surprised me
Hailey from Salt Lake City
I am a huge fan of this eyeliner! I went out on a limb to try this instead of my usual STILA or Kat Vondee tattoo liner and I was not disappointed. It's a bit bigger container than I'm used to, but I think it makes it easier to glide on your lids and create a pretty shape and wing!
Dry and hard to work with
Anna9678 from NC
Compared to most liquid liners I found this one to be lacking. It's very dry which makes for a hard application and it smudges all over. It easily flakes off as well. After it's dry if you need to fix mistakes it's quite hard as it smudges
Eyeliner that doesn't smudge !
anonymous from California
I've tried so many eyeliners and this is hands down the best one! It is so easy to draw a cat eye look too!
My One And Only
Meredith from Boston
I'm obsessed with the Super Edgy liner and I'm not sure what I would do if it ever went away. It's the easiest liquid liner to apply - I haven't found anything better. It holds like a marker which shocks onlookers, but I swear by it. My only wish is that it came in brown.
Love it forever till the end!!!!!!
Kata from Wisconsin
This is it and I'm sold! The tip is shorter which means you have more control! Every one is looking for control for Time Management when it comes to your eyes!!! Please make this in BROWN and in every color!!!!!!!!!!
Not a substitute for Epic Ink
Flebbo from Tempe
Bought this eyeliner as my local store had sold out of Epic Ink. Do not buy this. It's very dry, not very pigmented, and rubbed off on my eyelids.
I would definitely buy this again.
Rhea from Southaven, Mississippi
I love being able to make thick eyeliner looks effortlessly. If you want to be very precise, I would say get the smaller version.
A terrible start to trying liquid eyeliners again
Nat from Illinois
The "Put a Wing on It" liner worked for half of one eye, then it was like a dried out marker. My eyelids hurt from scraping the thing trying to get some color out. I'm returning it tomorrow.
That's the point eyeliners
Indal from Vallejo Ca
I would like to purchase a Brown if at all possible.
Not long lasting
Des from Los Angeles
I had high hopes for this product, because I use NYX eyeliners all the time. The tip shape is what attracted me to buying the liner, but it drags a bit so for me it didn't get the looks I wanted. When it comes to lasting power, I found that the liquid and actual pencil lasted hours longer than this product.
anna from SoCal
The point of the eyeliner would be useful if product would come out,, it seems as though product only comes out if you put excessive force. Do not buy this.
Pretty scary at first, but once you get it:BOMB
Ronniesv from El Salvador
Used the marker point type and it makes me get even and perfect wings every time. Only thing is that it might come a little sheer, but not too bad. Not waterproof, but it stays all day long on my very oily lids
Not User friendly
M from carlisle PA
It is not working for me.
Anabel29 from Santa Monica, CA
Nyx products usually aren't bad in my opinion, however this eyeliner was kind of a joke. The first time I used it hardly any liner came out (I had to wet the tip and then more came out). Even worse, once applied the liner starts looking very dry on the skin and you can't layer it without it looking clumped and cracked.
Love love love❤️
victoriialovesmakeup from New Mexico
I love using the Hella fine liner to outline and draw looks❤️
I highly recommend
K mitch from Indiana
I previously used a more expensive eyeliner, but I received a sample of this brand and tried it, since then I ditched my previous liner for this one. It's very affordable and equal quality to the more expensive brand I used before.
Waste of money
Bebe from Green Bay, WI
Super dry; barely goes on. The title explains itself
Worst eyeliner ever
Marie O from Ladera Ranch, California
Sorry... I actually hate leaving bad reviews but this eyeliner is plain terrible. The ink does not come out and the tip just scratches the eye. I am so mad I spent money on this.
ms.conqueror from Georgia
Product barely comes out. And when it does it comes out super light and ashy. Reminds me if a dried out coloring marker. Get something else bc this product is a waste of money
not the best
nessa from hollywood
this eyeliner is super expensive for its quality. i bought it earlier today and tried it, when i did, i let it dry on my bare eye, no eyeshadow and it smudged like crazy of i were to even slightly rub my eye. would not buy again or even recommend.
Typical Tiff from Honolulu, HI
Overall, the product does the job. The applicator is large and easy to handle. The precision tip is good, however it does pick up some of the eyeshadow when I go over it. I'm not too impressed by the formula because it would apply very thinly, so I would have to go over the same spot multiple times to get it at my desired shade of black. I gave this product 3 stars because it does what it's supposed to, it's affordable, but I wouldn't buy it again.
Fat wings mcgoo from New Yawk
It's just a little too thin for me! I like me some fat wings!
Does the job
Amy33 from Norfolk, VA
It works well. Was super black like I wanted, I just wish it was waterproof