Rated 4.12 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review FINALLY!!!
Well I finally found it!! The perfect eyeliner for my color eyes. I am 64 and felt I needed to start wearing liner to accent my eyes more (never did before). I have blue-grey eyes and had great difficulty in finding the right shade. Black.........no, brown...........no, navy..........no, grey.............no, nothing seemed to enhance the color of my eyes, until now. After 2-3 years of experimenting with different colors, I finally found the perfect shade. I bought Auto-De-Blu on the fact that it was advertised as a grey/blue shade. I received it today and when I opened the package I thought, "here we go again! Too dark!" But I was wrong, it is perfect. Not too dark or too light, definitely noticeable but not overwhelming. I LOVE IT!!
Most Helpful Critical Review Stick Broke!
After having this for about a month 1/2, the stick broke! :-( Not the "color" but the actual pencil part broke to where I can't use it, so it was money wasted. The part that turns became detached, but there wasn't a break or anything, nor had it been dropped.
Reviewed by 226 customers Earthline , come back!
Nicole from North Carolina
I don't understand why MAC doesn't listen to their customers. I along w/ many others clearly love this color. It is NOT dupable, and I don't want to be told how to replicate it by mixing eyeshadow over another color. This isn't a crazy seasonal color, it's a staple color for many who are looking for that perfect soft eyeliner. PLEASE MAC, really reconsider bringing EARTHLINE back. THIS SHADE IS UNIQUE to MAC, or better said, it WAS...
Vedra from Atlanta
Please bring back the color Earthline - there is no other color like it!!!
I buy this product all the time AWESOME!!!!
Partygirl from Michigan
I have been wearing MAC Products forever!! I LOVE THEM!!!
Bama from Haslet, TX
Have used this product for a long time. Love it.
My go to.
Cherylnick from Philadelphia
Lightly apply for everyday, but apply more when going to a party or out. It's versatile!
I am very happy with this eyeliner!
Valerie from Minnesota
Easy to control....doesn't drag.
Dani from Chicago
I thought I had tried this eyeliner from a friend--maybe it was a different one and I was confused but I liked it so I bought one for myself a few months later--the pigmentation is not as high as I expected (wasn't the deepest black out there) and it faded/smudged really quickly. Returning it during COVID is a hassle so I'll keep it but I won't use it for my waterline, which is why I got it in the first place. Super bummed!
eyeliner from Massachusetts
Nice product and long lasting.
Great for that water line
ladyboothby from Washington
I love using this liner for my upper and lower water line. It stays put until I remove it.
Perfect with Green Eyes
SunnyGirl87 from LA
I like the product, prefer eye liner I do not have to sharpen. Love an eye liner that is a mechanical pencil. I need to use it more to have a good idea about longevity/lasting color.
Used this product before
Becky from Hartford,AL
Angel from Grifton NC
I love this product
FLrealtor from Orlando florida
I LOVED your Modern Twist Kajal Liner. I had it in all colors. I bought Technakohl and it is not the same. Why did you get rid of Modern Twist?
Lynn from TN
Not sure what has happened...have used this eye liner for many years and loved it, but this last order (of two pencils) was disappointing. The tip of the liner broke off the first several times I used it. This will definitely shorten the "life" of the liner! Don't know if quality control is not quite what it used to be or if this was just a defective product. And, I know the current situation is probably causing fulfillment issues, but it took much longer to receive the order than expected.
High smudging liner
MO from Nevada City, CA
This is the worst liner I have ever used so I really give it a ZERO on rating. It quickly smudges on my lower eye and I don't even have oily skin. I really wish you would bring back the Modern Twist Kajal Liner. It was fabulous, with easy application and all day wear without smudging.
BB from Maryland
I love this liner...works well for the smudgy look with a Q-tip as your tool. Alot of times if I don't want to do mascara for work to have a more casual look...I use the liner, smudge it and use the lash curler.
Sin from Phoenix
So far the best liner it goes on smooth n smear when u want it too ... love it
Bring back EARTHLINE!
Gracie from Los Angeles
I've tried all your other liners to replace my go to eyeliner, Earthline, which you discontinued. None of them work for me. I was recommended to use eyeliner, Phone Number and it does not even come close. Please bring Earthline back!!
Cathy from Pasadena, CA
After La Prairie discontinued eyeliner, I searched for a replacement. Being a fan of your Pasadena store, I purchased this... & other colors... however... one would not work, another was broken... after having tried & loved it!
In buying multiples as the virus was taking hold... I now havw no recourse & no customer service w store closed.
Love the Purple Dash
Mary from Grand Rapids, MI
I've tried several eyeliners and was feeling adventurous one day. There was a MAC event going on in the store, so I tried purple dash. I loved how easily it went on without tugging. So pretty.
SI from FL
I was hoping...
asianeyes from Montville, NJ
I would hoping this would be my quick go to eye liner when I didn't have the time to use a liquid and make fancy wings but unfortunately not. If you have asian eyes like me with no double eyelid (monolid) finding an eyeliner that does not smudge after a few hours is hard. I wore this one day and within hours (esp after laughing)... I was embarrassed to find when I went to the bathroom, I literally had black dripping down my face.
Dried out and broken
DC from Minnesota
The last time I ordered this, a huge chunk fell out as soon as I took the cap off. I reordered and it's been "On the way" for over a week now. I have loved this product for a long time, but I think it's time to spend my money on something more reliable.
ashflan83 from las vegas, nv
I love this eyeliner. The blue is just subtle enough for my liking, also goes on smooth and easy. this is the second time ive purchased, and plan purchasing again.
Love the color
Yma975 from Rochester, MI
Love the color and ease of use