Rated 4.2 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review I was in a car accident and my eyeliner didn't budge
This product is truly amazing. June 28th I was pulled over in my car calling for roadside assistance when a distracted driver hit me going 55mph. I was taken via ambulance to the ER where I remained for 8 hours. My mascara was running down my face from crying and all other products had been wiped off in the transfer to the hospital. But not my tattoo eyeliner. I am posting a pick to show you, this product lasts and looks amazing through anything. Never buying any other liner again
Most Helpful Critical Review Confused?
I had heard a lot of really great things about this liner so I was super excited to try it out. It worked awesomely the first day and stayed on forever, but only a few days after buying it things started to go wrong. Now, only two weeks after buying this the liner goes on grey and patchy, and I've had to fill it in with black shadow to make it presentable. I've tried everything (like shaking it or cleaning or wetting the brush), but nothing worked. I'm really confused because everyone else seems to have no issues, so maybe I just got a dud? I Don't know, but this liner seems like a waste to me. I might trying to buy another one later to see if it was a fluke or something.
Reviewed by 2357 customers Dry! Old product?
Kaleigh from Lansing, MI
I was excited to be able to buy this liner again since Kat stepped down from the company (I personally don't support her), but was extremely disappointed when I used this product today and it was dry as a bone. I couldn't even get both eyes done until I had to use a different eyeliner entirely. I also am concerned why my product still had the name Kat Von D on it when they changed the name to KVD Vegan Beauty 11 months ago. To me, that means that this product is old. I have never had an eyeliner work this badly out of the box before.
Ashley from Virginia
I'm always on the lookout for a long lasting eyeliner. This one did not live up to the reviews. It was more grey than black when it went on (I shook it for a while before using) and it rubs off so easy. It just isn't worth the money
Becca from Friendswood Tx
Best eyeliner ever and I have tried many other brands. The black color just make my eyes well defined and thats without wearing mascara.
Love love love this!
Lizzygirl from Rio Rancho, NM
I wear it daily! Love the control and the softness of the applicator.
Very dissapointed Customer
Jessica from Albuqueruqe, NM
This is my second time trying this eyeliner, the first one I bought, had very little liquid. I actually thought I received a used one. I couldn't return due to that right now for health reasons I can only do pick up so I purchased a second one and again nothing comes out. I shake, squeeze and the tip is dry as can be. I am not sure if its just these brown ones because I have ordered black ones in the past and never had a problem but these past two brown ones have been dry, no liquid/ink comes out of pen. Again, I am unable to return and I will not be purchasing this product again. I usually like KVD products but this has been horrible! I just wasted my money. What a disappointment!
Goes on easily, stays on all day
Carly from Grand Rapids, MI
I know KVD has been controversial for some of her personal beliefs, and it held me back from trying her products for a long time. I gotta say, the eyeliner is fabulous and despite her questionable decisions I will surely be buying this again.
Not the same as it used to be
Emeli from Philadelphia
I swore by this liner for a long time. I loved that it was a brush tip versus felt (felt tips catch the edge of my eyelid) and it would give you a clean, bold line every time. I had one that lasted me for nearly a year! The formula has changed and the quality has gone down since I last purchased this (before it came to Ulta). The tip dries out very quickly, the lines aren't nearly as bold or pigmented, and after a few tries I just finally tossed this in the trash. Such a shame.
eviliner from santa cruz
Had heard good things & was excited to try this, but I picked one up from ulta & it was completely dry, as if barely any product was in it in the first place. Like the tip seemed like it had never even touched product, and only a tiny amount of dry product came off near the base when I tried to swatch it. Took it back to exchange it for another one which was exactly the same. Confused & annoyed
Brown color completely dried out
Chiquis from McAllen,TX
I've used the black color in the mini size and its always been highly pigmented so i decided to try out the brown color in the full size and it was completely dried out which now that I'm reading the reviews others have had the same issue so I'm going to go return asap
Megan from Springfield, MO
I have sweared by this eyeliner for years, now it's not worth the material it's packaged in. Bought a brand new tube, the formula was so dried out I couldn't even do both my eyelids and could barely do one. I tried cleaning it, shook it for 5 minutes and the product is all dried out. The one eyelid I barely got done was sticky and was not waterproof at all. After 5 minutes it was sticking to my eyelid and running. This used to be great, but the formula has changed and now it doesn't work. I returned and exchanged for a different product.
The best ever!!!
Divine Love from Escondido, CA
Best eyeliner ever!!!
Not like any tattoo I have
Bdettey from Connecticut
simply doesn't give a good solid saturated line, Benefit is still better at staying all day
i will buy product again. Very good
MSU BULLYGAL from MEMPHIS,TN
This is the first eyeliner that I have ever owned that stayed on all day. Great Product
Cmart from Garland
Glides on smooth and lasts all day!
Not like it used to be
Big lady from Seattle
Used to be a great product and now it's terrible. I bought a brand new liner and it didn't work, it was bone dry out of the package. Different formula doesn't perform like it used to
Not waterproof and goes on blotchy
None from Atlanta
Eyeliner. Worst I have tried. Must store with applicator tip down so it keeps liquid from drying up. Not waterproof and applied blotchy do you have to go over areas to fill in blank spots.
Good while it lasted
Klo from N
It has an amazing tip and it is great but dried out really quick
Kitty from Chicago
I have been using KVD's products for years, including the eyeliner. I needed a new pen and when I opened it at home to try it, nothing would come out! I shook it and let it sit upside down and nothing would come out of the pen. After I went and exchanged it, the same thing happened. I'm crazy disappointed after being so loyal to this brand for over 5 years.
QWERTY from Anywhere
Bought one, it was dry when I took it out of the box. The second one was also dry when I took it out of the box. No amount of shaking helped. Extremely disappointed in this product.
ShaylaL87 from Charleston, WV
I didn't even get to try this, when I bought it, it was dry and nothing was even coming off it. I did return to store and they said they've had this issue with it lately Max I have heard it was pretty awesome. May try again and order offline next time.
The best. And I've tried them all
Marissa from Long Island
Love this product, doesn't skip or tug my eyelids like many liners do, doesn't transfer into my crease on my slightly hooded eyes. 10/10 would recommend
Long wear and amazing
kris from Lincoln NE
I love this Product.
Not the Same
Brendis from Idaho Falls, ID
This was my Holy Grail for years, until recently. I've bought two in the past year and a half and they both dried out quickly, seemed to have less product and didn't apply as smoothly as before. Thankfully there's a dupe that I'm now using and it works just like the original Tattoo Liner - same brush tip, double the product and ~$7!
ARocky from Gilbert, AZ
Brand new and didn't work. I tried shaking and pressing on the tip and never got to try this product because it didn't work. I purchased this at the recommendation of a worker at Ulta while searching for an eyeliner that holds up to oily skin. I also had seen other positive reviews for the product. I ended up returning this eyeliner and started using Lancome Artliner which passed the oily skin all-day test.
Not good from undisclosed
Very drying and smudges the tip of liner is to thin