Rated 4.36 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Love this palette
I was a die hard motives eyeshadow fan but recently they changed their formula. I went into Ulta looking for a new palette that was highly pigmented and blends well. I had vary high expectations and this palette nailed it then went above and beyond. The combination of mattes and shimmers are perfect, all colors compliment each other. There was a little fallout the first time I used it but I was able to adjust to it and now I have no fallout and just flawless eye-shadow.
Most Helpful Critical Review Beautiful Colors (but horrible formula)
I did my makeup and the light colors blended like a dream, but for the deep colors once you wanted to give more definition or just add a bit more product your eyeshadow would just disappear. brakes my heart I returned my pallet make sure you keep in eye on your eyeshadow by the end of the day and you will notice more discoloration on your eyelid. hope this helps I feel nobody is giving honest review online anymore. and I feel that tarte changed its formula.
Reviewed by 333 customers Good product
Kenzi from Jacksonville fl
I really like this palette. I love the colors. After getting it and using it I realized I probably wouldn't use a few colors just bc I'm pale and it wouldnt look completely right on me and I'm new to doing my eyeshadow but I'm fairly good at using like 3-4 colors for a look. They're all really pretty. I think my only con would be that there is a lot of fall out, which is annoying but I do my makeup after my eyes anyways so it really isn't a big hassle.
one of my favorites
REW from DC
it's a great palette.
my only issue would be that it as dark and light colors but no medium tone but that could just because I have the complexion of Casper the ghost.
I would not buy this product again
Amanda from Saint Marys GA
I picked this product up from my Ulta after loving the tarte in bloom pallet and as soon as I opened it their was eyeshadow dust everywhere very messy and my experience so far with the quality hasn't been very good it performs as if it's old.
Not sure where so much hate came from
Sarah from Cincinnati, OH
I really have to wonder what brushes people are using that made them so mad at this pallet. It's not as great as in bloom, but it's not dramatically worse either. I like it. It's great with my green eyes and red hair, so I use it daily.
Perfect for everyday
L from Indiana
Best palette I own! Love the way it looks and the way the eyeshadows blend. So soft.
Great everyday pallete!
Mia from Concord
I'm actually kind of shocked reading some of the reviews, I love this pallete! It's a perfect everyday pallete and I used to take it with me traveling all the time! I have no issues with the eyeshadow blending at all, my go to eyeshadow primer is the morphe primer. All the colors are perfect to create a day of night look.
I love this palette
Emily from United States
I fell in love with this product. There is little to no fallout, and I don't use a primer or setting spray. The color blend nicely and look so pretty together. You can easily go for a natural or more dramatic look.
I had such high hopes
Valerie from Oklahoma
I had such high hopes for this product but it definitely failed. The colors crease horribly & fade even after wearing for an hour. I've been using the same Becca eyeshadow pot for years now & I guess it's back to that now.
Maybe purchase this if you find it on sale but I definitely wouldn't pay more than drugstore prices for this.
Crissy from USA
The colors are beautiful and perfect for someone like me that doesn't experiment much. While I never purchased my own, this was always my go to in my friends collection because of how great the colors were.
Amber from Texas
Love the eyeshadow palette! It's exactly the colors I was looking for, for more natural look. The only con is that the card it came with to show you different looks and how to accomplish that specific look didn't come come out looking like the picture. But that's not a big deal.
Worst eyeshadow palette ever used!
Unsatisfied customer from Miami
I bought this quite some time ago and never got around to writing a review until now. As the title suggests, this is the worst eyeshadow palette I've ever used. While the colors are beautiful and appeals to me for an easy day look to night time, the quality isn't on par with the price. The shadows are smooth upon touching, however when applied it's quite difficult since it's so smooth. I have to pack in on quite a bit and even then it doesn't last long at all. I decided to give it another chance today and lo and behold, nothing has changed. I tried using different brushes, using fingers, etc. however it came to no avail. The moment I blended the shadows on my eyelids, it practically disappeared and it also applied patchy too when I tried to layer. I had to use my other eyeshadow palettes to compensate for the lack of staying powder and color. I've tried even dollar store eyeshadow (from back when I was younger & couldn't afford much) that actually works better than this, which is saying something. I don't understand why this is so highly rated (perhaps these reviews are fake or paid ads by influencers). There are better products out there that offer the same if not at least similar color range out there with higher quality formula for less or a much better value for your money, like Morphe for example. Hopefully they don't delete my review or push it down so people can beware before buying this product.
wle12 from Virginia
I was looking for a new eyeshadow palette with bronze colors and found this. I really like the product - it applies well and there are a good variety of colors. However, some shades are a little bright or too orange for my taste, but still overall a great palette.
wle12 from Virginia
This is definitely the best concealer I've ever tried. Blends really well and has excellent coverage. Would 100% recommend this product if you're looking to try a new concealer!
Chalky, cracked, not typical for Tarte + Shady Ulta deal
KP Dee from Eureka
This product was really dry, the shadows were already cracked on the edges when I got it and there was product dust all over the mirror and mixed with the other shades. I got it because Ulta had a deal for a tinted moisturizer with it and I thought why not, sounds like a great deal. When it came in the mail, not only was the product really not worth the money but the tinted moisturizer was literally smaller than my thumb. Nowhere on the website did it state that it was going to be like a quarter teaspoon of product. I mean, I get it... but it was really shady. I looked at the site and it is advertised as though its going to be full-size or at least a mini but this was like... MINI MINI bro. The receipt said "sample size" but yeah.. did not state that on the site. It felt very bait and switch.
Pretty palette, but not the same on the eye
Ali from Denver
I love the packaging and the smell is nice but not overwhelming. I feel like the swatches look really nice but the deeper shadows and shimmers don't show up as well on the eye. The lighter matte shades tend to lean pretty orange on the eye as well, even though they look lighter or more brown in the pan. I enjoy the warm neutral tone of this palette but it seems like I have the same eye-look every time I use it because the pigmentation fades on the eye :( overall it's a nice palette however I'm disappointed in the lack of versatility because of the pigmentation issues.
Pallet came with chipped paint.
Jordan from Cincinnati Ohio
It is very pigmented but the packaging of the pallets was chipped. Expected more for the money
Great eyeshadow palette with beautiful shades!
Melanie from New York, NY
I brought this in for my mom for mother's day and she loved it. The shimmer shades apply smoothly no clumps. The matte shades are not powderish, they apply smoothly on your eyes if you have an eye primer on. The shades overall are great colors for mature skin! The palette does have a big mirror so that's a plus for me!
Probably the best pallet I own
Kenzie from Sumter sc
I have too many pallets to count but the only one I reach for is the toasted tartlet pallet. I bought 2 more as back up. Not crazy about my other tarte pallets.
Kirstin from Idaho
So much fallout and barely any pigment, not to mention the colors come out orange then brown which is kinda upsetting, I probably won't buy tarts again because this isn't the first time I've been disappointed by their products. I really wanted a natural/ neutral tone of colors, what's most disappointing is how much fallout there is.
Orange vs. Pink
PickyRicky from Frederick, MD
I usually only order makeup online if I've used it in the past. However, with COVID-19, in-store shopping wasn't possible. The reviews were positive, so I decided to take a risk. I LOVE the way the palette smells and am happy with the ease of applying and blending the shadow, but in my opinion, the colors online are not truly representative of the colors in the palette. While I knew the palette contained browns, the colors online looked more pink than orange. I'm adding a photo so other customers can compare (curious to know if anyone else agrees). Since returning anything during the pandemic is difficult, I'll suck it up and use them. Don't get me wrong...the colors are attractive...just different than expected.
Kristin from Ohio
Has amazing pigment and the shadows are buttery smooth!
I love this palatte
Claudia from CA
I really loved all the shades. And they really do blend wonderful together
Lisap from Florida
Toasted is a really easy way to do orange and neutrals, it is really wearable and pretty on green or brown eyes. It also smells like marshmallows.
I love it
Sky from MS
No fall out very blendable for someone who wears a lot of brown colors I think this is a good palette
Best Tartelette Palette!
Lici Lu from Louisiana
I own all 3 of these palettes: Tartelette, Tartelette 2 In Bloom and Tartelette Toasted. The Toasted palette is AMAZING. One of the best palettes I own- it's buttery soft (but not too soft that it doesn't pick up on your brush and apply well!) it's super blendable and stays on all day. I was SHOCKED when I first used it and now it's my go to!