Product Reviews Rated 3.68 out of 5 stars
282 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Highly pigmented I was looking for a replacement for my old felt tip eyeliner and this isn't quite it, though it's quite good. The tapered tip lets you draw a fine line and gives you decent control, and it's easy to fill in a more dramatic line.
However, it is very, very pigmented and that can be an issue for getting it off or if you make a mistake. When I tried using eye makeup remover on it it smeared all over my face! It takes forever to get all the color off because it is so pigmented. But, overall it's a true blue-black fast drying precise eyeliner for not a lot of money.
Most Helpful Critical Review Not that good.... I love essence but I am extremely disappointed in this product. It gives little pigment and is hard to apply on top of eyeshadow makeup.
Trust me, the water proof one is way better!
Reviewed by 282 customers Worst eyeliner I've ever tried 1
Kait from Hartford, CT
Worst eyeliner I've ever tried. I don't usually write reviews but this was so bad I had to. This eyeliner wipes away like a dry erase marker. It is semi transparent and required a lot of layers to look black. I opened my eye to see how it looked and it transferred to my upper lid. Horrible.
no 3
skitso from ms
was not very pigmented
Great color 4
Sky from US
It's a pretty nice color, good price. The cap doesn't have that nice secure "click" most liquid pens have when closing it, so that makes me wonder if it will stay wet for long, but for now I love it.
pigment where?????? 1
Kels from Gastonia, NC
I'm highly disappointed after reading the reviews i thought this would be good to try. It has almost no pigment. Its very watery and I am very unsatisfied with this purchase. I bought the shade "deep black". Deep black where??? Its a very light watery gray. I swatched it over and over trying to see if the pigment would ever come. It did not.
Nah 3
Anh from Texas
I wouldn't recommend this eyeliner unless you want to feel like you're using a dried up marker on your face lol.
Perfect Eyeliner! 5
G.H. from Southern California
I usually buy Essence lip liners and love those so much, so when I needed a new eyeliner, I saw this and thought I'd give it a try. Honestly, I'm quite impressed. It works well and in all honesty, I like it more than some of the more expensive eyeliners I bought in the past. I would totally buy this again in the future.
Eh 3
Niya from Somewhere
Mine came broken. The thick pen side had completely snapped off causing it to dry out. The pen is okay. Sometimes it's really pigmented, other times it's really dry. But, the liner comes off very easily so that's good.
Great for the price 4
Em B. from Florida
Comes out a little light so I usually shake the pen a bit before using it but the tip is the perfect size for a precise wing and it's not bad considering the price.
I would not buy again it was dry and didn't work 1
Rosebud from Maple grove mn
I was looking forward to trying it but it was dried out
Eh 2
AzGoddess from AZ
I've never used a fine tip eyeliner before. It's called dark black but came out more brown. And the tip seemed flimsy. I thought it would be more firm.
I don't know what happened 2
janelove956 from Texas
I used this for three days and it was working well but then it just completely dried out and it was closed properly so I have no idea what happened or why there was such a sudden change 🤷🏻♀️
Precision lines 5
Steph from Flagstaff, AZ
No matter how you like to apply your eyeliner (subtle or dramatic), you want to know it's going to last all day. The felt tip pen is helpful to create the perfect look and applying smoothly onto eyelids without tugging or skipping.
Meh 3
Megs from Texas
It's really light you need multiple coats. But very easy to use
Would buy again. 4
Heather from Caldwell ID
Works as well as other eyeliners that cost double the price.
This is a great product 5
Melissa from Ardmore, OK
I love the liquid liner
Love it 5
Jasmine from Alabama
I love it
Honestly awful 1
Not happy from Chillicothe, Oh
So, I figured "why not" Kay Von D's is pricey so I was looking for a dupe. This is definitely not it!
No payout at all. Like I've drawn on myself with pencil and could see it better than the "eyeliner" that came out. Yes, I shook it and tried to pump it (it doesn't have a cap pump) NOTHING helped it. Waste of money.
Great! 5
Crisha from Kailua
It's really good! It's my first time using an eyeliner and i had a good experience with it.
Yes, I would buy this again. 3
Tara from Michigan
It's a good affordable priced eyeliner. I got deep black. The only thing that I don't like about it, is that it doesn't go on very dark. I have to do quite a few coats to make it dark enough. Other than that, it stays on...doesn't bleed and glides on easy.
Perfect fit 5
Em from Virginia
I use this product after I do my eye makeup and it doesn't smear or anything! Wonderful!
Best eyeliner 5
Haddy from Pahrump
Anytime wear. Goes in perfect. No skipping, easy to control. Beautiful wear.
no 3
Reese from Grosse Pointe, MIointe, MI
The color is not opaque, I have to layer it to get it dark enough, but it rubs off when i layer it. As well as it doesnt work over shadows makes the marker dry out
Doesn't work 1
Rrenee from Temecula
Impossible to use because no ink comes out the tip. It may be cheap but it doesn't work.
NO PIGMENT! 1
Punkypinup from Vallejo
literally had to go over my eyeliner 10 times for it to look semi-pigmented. The tip is great- would work amazingly for winged eyeliner.. if it was actually BLACK! Get what you pay for i guess .
No! 1
S.marie from Bx
I bought this liner because it was cheap...but never again. I like that it's black and it's easy to make a straight line but no pigment!!! If you really want it to show you will need to go over it like 2 or 3 times smh.
