Product Reviews Rated 3.78 out of 5 stars
105 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Super Pigmented This was the first J.Cat Beauty product I have ever used & I must say that the colors are super pigmented especially the shimmer shades. I use my finger to apply the shimmer shades to my eyelid & they apply so smoothly like silk.
All the colors blend very nicely. Will definitely repurchase more of there eyes shadow pallets in the future.
Most Helpful Critical Review My absolute favorite I have several eyeshadow palettes but this one is by far my favorite! The colors are amazing and pigmented. The only reason for three stars is because mine came damaged, some shadows had scuffs in them and one completely shattered so the case was covered in gold glitter as soon as I removed it from the box. Also it's super hard to open and the inside casing that holds the shadows is a cheap plastic so I am careful with it. But was seriously worth the buy, because the product itself is great quality.
P.S. I also bought this for my friend who is of dark complexion and she loves it as well! So it can be for all skin tones (:
Reviewed by 105 customers Broken, just like my expectations 3
Neil from Clarksdale, MS
When I received it yesterday, it was secure in the non-damaged package, and when I opened it, it was damaged in the bubblewrap
It was completely busted and I had to throw it away 1
Mika from SD
I was unable to even try this product. All eyeshadow was broken. I had bought 2 and both were is same condition.
Broken like my excitement 1
Jessey from Frankfort ky
I Ordered this pallet for my wedding next week.. when I received it it was shattered and went everywhere when I opened the box. I reached out to customer service, which they responded in a timely manner. He was very helpful and sent me another one. Only for the replacement pallet to also be shattered like my excitement.. so don't bother buying this
Broken and disappointed 1
Jessey from Lawrenceburg ky
I wanted to use this pallet for my wedding and just opened my package and HAD to write this review straight away. It came with over half of them broken and everywhere.. I have eyeshadow all over the place from opening the box. I'm highly disappointed
Gorgeous Palette but... 4
Sarah from Northwest Indiana
I have been wanting a palette with colors like this for a while so when I discovered it I had to try it out. I've been trying it out for a few week and I have to say it's wonderful for the price. It blends well and it's pigmented. My issues are that when I received it I noticed the colors were different from the photos, I was expecting them to be darker and some of them just look different in general. I found looks to use them with but it wasn't what I was expecting. Also when I received the product there were specks of the colors all over the inside of the palette. I'm not sure if this is caused by the shipping or the packaging of the product itself but it's worth noting.
Love this palette! 5
Donna from Mishawaka, IN
I love this palette; colors are very pigmented, and easy to blend. Very beautiful color all day.
Don't buy 1
Aaliyah from United States
Can't broken
Never buy again this product 1
RC from Tamarac Florida
Super bad palette
Don't buy 1
Aaliyah from North haven
Comes broken and shattered.
Incorrect colors in photo 3
Beth91 from Illinois
Bought this pallete specifically for the matte shades featured in this photo. The colors are completely different in person. They are all varying shades of neutrals/brown, instead of the pretty mauve & pinkish colors I was going for. And pallete came broke, very disappointed.
Good for smoky look 4
Shellbelle_33 from Cleveland
I feel the colors look a little different in person but overall I still like it.
Love this 5
Clip from PA
This is one of my favorite pallets because it has the shimmer shades and then a matching matte shade. Making a look is so much easier.
not purples 3
yogirl from yakima
it's not purple it's more of a mauvy browns the picture is off but the matalic shades are beautiful
So pigmented! 5
Yessss from Bel air md
I love this pallet! I didn't get it from Ulta but it's one of my favorites
One of my favorites 5
Es_gee from California
Very pigmented, blends easily, and easy work with!
9/24 colors were cracked 4
Becca b from ct
When 40% of the colors are cracked, we got a problem. Called customer service and they sent me a new one AND LET ME KEEP THE BROKEN ONE
Be aware of Shipping to Home 4
NaturalMani from Rockhill, SC
Very beautiful shades, I had it shipped to my home and one had shattered everywhere causing it to go on the other eyeshadows. If you plan to get it online and having it ship to your location just be aware there can be a possibility of having to reorder if your palette( if it's shattered). Other than that I would recommend, it's such a beautiful palette with very pigment colors. 10/10 I would recommend. Also recommend buying in person. So I give it 4.5/5 stars
Cute but arrived SHATTERED 2
Becca B from Connecticut
All of the matte shades are GORGEOUS and perfectly in tact but the shimmery ones were shattered... will be reordering but I'm annoyed about it.
AMAZING 5
jessie from no
i use this palette almost everyday the shimmer are crazy pigmented and the mattes are so soft and blendable. I definitely want to try more from J.Cat
Packaging gone wrong but great eyeshadow 2
Diana from Texas
I bought two pallets from J. Cat and both of them have the same issue. The case is just destroyed and all the shadows are broken. Not completely enough product was left for me to play around but I reluctant to purchase again seeing that I'm the only one with the issue and it is an only online order.
Liked the palette so much that I ordered 4 others by J Cat 4
Gaffy from Los Angeles
This was the first J. Cat product that I have ever ordered. Wasn't expecting much from a $9 palette, as I've found that the more colors that you get in a palette, the lower the quality is. Didn't find that with this palette with the exception of the case lacking a mirror, as well as being in a cheap lightweight, plastic case.
I don't know if they changed the formulas or not, but my eyeshadows are slightly creamy than powdery like in some of these pictures.
The shimmery ones aren't excessively shimmery which I like. I don't need or want a million light shades of gold, pinks, and ivories. No fallout whatsoever because like I said, they have more of a creamy texture than of a powdery one.
I didn't think it would be possible to find a high quality, low end brand of eye shadow palettes (aside from Makeup Revolution which I like, but do think is a bit overrated) until I ordered this from Ulta. I did see a J Cat palette (Santa Monica) at my local Burlington yesterday for $1 less but chose to buy from Ulta due to not having swatches.
Great color pay off 4
Sarah from Texas
I bought this for my mom, because she was wanting a bigger eye shadow palette. She has sensitive skin and eyes and its made her itchy. She gave it back to me, but I like it. It doesn't make my eyes itchy, has great color pay off and very creamy. The only downfalls I see is it is very dusty, so I recommend doing your eye make up first.
You get what you pay for and then some. 4
SilverShade from Colorado
I purchased two palettes, one came broken and I lost one full shadow. The other palette was fine. For the price you get so many shadows, The colors all blend beautifully, the foils are absolutely amazing. So much shimmer! Every time I use these shadows I get compliments.
One downside is you do get a fair amount of fall out, so do your eye makeup first!
For the money I think you get a great palette! And under $20 for this many shadow can you really complain about the packaging?
The colors are nice but the case is ehhh... 3
Emily from NC
I ordered this pallet and another J.Cat pallet and although that one came intact, this one did not. It had one pan that was crumbly and everywhere. The second one was a mess but all still there. Ulta was great and replaced the pallet. The replacement showed up THE NEXT DAY but unfortunately this one had 10 out of 24 shattered pans :( I finally asked for my money back and I was refunded. The cases seem really flimsy and cheap when opening. I'm terrified to travel with them in my makeup bag.
On the fence 3
Lori from Lima, Ohio
Luckily my pallette arrived intact but the plastic case this came in is poor quality. It is very difficult to open and feels flimsy when snapping it closed. Plus it does not have a mirror. The matte shades are nice and blended easily but there was a fair amount of fall out. I left my baking powder in place for this reason ( I was expecting this based on reading other reviews). The glitter shades were not very pigmented nor easy to apply. I really had to dig to get any color on my brushes. Even setting spray didn't help much. After application I noticed fading and creasing within a few hours despite using a high end eyelid primer. I have been coveting this pallette for a while now and although I don't regret buying it (the matte shades are workable), I doubt I will replace it when it's used up nor will I recommend it to anyone. This is my first pallette from the brand. I had high hopes based on how well other products from this brand work for me.
