Product Reviews Rated 4.0 out of 5 stars
59 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Good separation & length Was running out of my Maneater mascara and this was on sale during the 21 days of beauty so decided to give it a try. One coat of this mascara is good for daytime use. It gives good curl & length, but doesn't seem to volume much. At least not like Maneater does. It's not clumpy and separates lashes nicely. Not very easy to build on, so I typically stick with one coat of this. Easy to apply and lasts all day without running or flaking. Comes off easily with soap & water at night. I like the drama of Maneater better so will probably stick with that one, but this is a good alternative for a more natural look.
Most Helpful Critical Review Works amazing, but irritated my eyes! I never tried tarte mascara before and I was in the market to try something new. Decided to give this one a try! The mascara itself works AMAZING. I love the brush, the way it applies & the look of the lashes afterwards. I have super long eyelashes as is, so I'm not sure what mascara even adds volume anymore. However - this product irritated my eyes. When I first applied it my eyes were so itchy and almost had a burning feeling to them. It felt like I had something in my eyes most of the day from being irritated by the fumes. After I washed my face, I really felt the irritation to my eyes and both of my eyes were bloodshot. Although the mascara is very pretty when it's on, ill be returning it due to the way it made my eyes feel.
Reviewed by 59 customers Nope 1
Sabby from San Diego
Does nothing for my lashes! There are definitely some drug store brands that work much better than this. Only bought it because it was on sale. Also the tube came out of it's stupid yellow coat after a few uses.
AMAZINGGG NO FLAKING 5
CC from Modesto
So I actually have long lashes and I've used so many mascaras but this one did not flake for me at all, it makes my eyelashes look so pretty and not clumpy! Will purchase again 😍
This is really good mascara. The best they have right now. 5
Sissy from Valdosta Georgia
I can't find anything wrong with it. It came in great condition.
It's alright 3
Kaitlin from Corpus Christi
The mascara does look nice and gives a great volume but it does clump up fast. There are clumps of mascara on the brush and have to put it back into the container to try and take them out. I also have some fall out because of the clumps.
Meh 2
Stephanie from Cerritos, CA
Nothing extraordinary or exciting with this product. Just a normal mascara that's honestly not worth the high end price. The packaging is annoying and it takes a bit to get used to, well at least for me. I tend to spin the brush into my lashes but I can't do that with the seams of the packaging so it's super annoying for me. I ended up dropping the wand on my hand and vanity because of it and made a bit of a mess trying to clean it up. So I definitely do not recommend. For that price you can get a much better mascara... even at the drugstore. Smells like old chemicals too.
Disappointed 2
Booker from Portland, OR
Too clumpy and flaky
Love it! 5
HB0524 from Baton Rouge, LA
I bought this mascara to try when it was on sale and I love it!
I would buy this agian 5
Kris M from cape coral, fl
Great product, make my lashes look amazing. Will buy agian
Only mascara I'll buy 5
Lipstick from NJ
I love this mascara! This is the only mascara I'll buy.
Yes 4
Yo from TX
Loved the product. No issues with it.
Love this product, will be the only one I use!!! 5
Jackie from Md
Everything thing is great about it .
Love it 5
Nessa from Pembroke pines
Love the volume and length it it gives me
💖 4
lei from va
it's good and lasts all day(even while sweating) but a little flaky
Love this mascara 5
J-9 from Missouri
Love this mascara . It's better then too face's new one. It does not give me racoons eye's like some have experienced. A little hint to fix that problem. I have been doing this for yrs . Buy some great lash waterproof mascara. It's the only one that works. And it's cheap. Put this on your bottom lashes over your mascara ( whichever your using on top and bottom)this will get rid of those racoon eyes. Remember only bottom since it's waterproof. Just lightly coat them..
Love How Pretty My Lashes Are With This! 5
AmyChere from SPring
I was shocked by how amazing my lashes were after using this!
great lashes runs, smudges easily 3
Melissa from Oregon
My lashes looked amazing! it was not at all clumpy but it did run and smudge easily. To be fair, it was humid and I had a heavy patient load so I came out of isolation room looking like a racoon. Fortunately this also means it comes off easily
Returned this mascara! 3
Lauren from Pennsylvania
I was a little disappointed with this mascara. I usually love all Tarte products. I was surprised because it got such good reviews. It didn't Separate my lashes enough and was very flaky.
Love! 5
Bri from New York
Love this mascara!! I have short lashes and this really lengthens and separates them nicely! Love it!
I wish I could give this zero stars! 1
Ashley from Scottsdale, Arizona
The formula was awful! The mascara stuck to my lashes it was so dry, and clumpy! It ran under my eyes for the whole day and would not come off! DO NOT buy this product!! I wish I could give this zero stars!
eh 2
gailo from Georgia
I loved that my lashes looked instantly longer, but after a couple of hours of wear, there was flaking and dark smudges under my eyes.
I'm very disappointed that for the cost of this mascara, that I had these problems
Had to return 2
Hillbeauty from WV
My daughter wanted to try this mascara, she did not like it at all. The formula did not build, nor give length. We returned it after one use.
Amazing! 5
Mel from Lewiston id
So much volume added. My new favorite!
Drug store stuff is better 3
Beautifulb13 from Oregon
Don't waist your money chunky and not build able
Love this mascara. 5
M Herrera from Spring, TX
This mascara gives me the length on my eyelashes that I was looking for.
Dry/flaky/clumpy 1
Jess from Mississippi
I normally love all tarte products, so of course I wanted to try this mascara. The first use was OK at best. I used it a few times to give it a couple more chances, but every time it flaked off and left black flecks on my face- even when I tried it with a mascara primer also. It was also clumpy and dry on the brush after only a couple uses. Would not recommend.
