Product Reviews Rated 4.0 out of 5 stars
45 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Good separation & length Was running out of my Maneater mascara and this was on sale during the 21 days of beauty so decided to give it a try. One coat of this mascara is good for daytime use. It gives good curl & length, but doesn't seem to volume much. At least not like Maneater does. It's not clumpy and separates lashes nicely. Not very easy to build on, so I typically stick with one coat of this. Easy to apply and lasts all day without running or flaking. Comes off easily with soap & water at night. I like the drama of Maneater better so will probably stick with that one, but this is a good alternative for a more natural look.
Most Helpful Critical Review Works amazing, but irritated my eyes! I never tried tarte mascara before and I was in the market to try something new. Decided to give this one a try! The mascara itself works AMAZING. I love the brush, the way it applies & the look of the lashes afterwards. I have super long eyelashes as is, so I'm not sure what mascara even adds volume anymore. However - this product irritated my eyes. When I first applied it my eyes were so itchy and almost had a burning feeling to them. It felt like I had something in my eyes most of the day from being irritated by the fumes. After I washed my face, I really felt the irritation to my eyes and both of my eyes were bloodshot. Although the mascara is very pretty when it's on, ill be returning it due to the way it made my eyes feel.
Reviewed by 45 customers Love How Pretty My Lashes Are With This! 5
AmyChere from SPring
I was shocked by how amazing my lashes were after using this!
great lashes runs, smudges easily 3
Melissa from Oregon
My lashes looked amazing! it was not at all clumpy but it did run and smudge easily. To be fair, it was humid and I had a heavy patient load so I came out of isolation room looking like a racoon. Fortunately this also means it comes off easily
Returned this mascara! 3
Lauren from Pennsylvania
I was a little disappointed with this mascara. I usually love all Tarte products. I was surprised because it got such good reviews. It didn't Separate my lashes enough and was very flaky.
Love! 5
Bri from New York
Love this mascara!! I have short lashes and this really lengthens and separates them nicely! Love it!
I wish I could give this zero stars! 1
Ashley from Scottsdale, Arizona
The formula was awful! The mascara stuck to my lashes it was so dry, and clumpy! It ran under my eyes for the whole day and would not come off! DO NOT buy this product!! I wish I could give this zero stars!
eh 2
gailo from Georgia
I loved that my lashes looked instantly longer, but after a couple of hours of wear, there was flaking and dark smudges under my eyes.
I'm very disappointed that for the cost of this mascara, that I had these problems
Had to return 2
Hillbeauty from WV
My daughter wanted to try this mascara, she did not like it at all. The formula did not build, nor give length. We returned it after one use.
Amazing! 5
Mel from Lewiston id
So much volume added. My new favorite!
Drug store stuff is better 3
Beautifulb13 from Oregon
Don't waist your money chunky and not build able
Love this mascara. 5
M Herrera from Spring, TX
This mascara gives me the length on my eyelashes that I was looking for.
Dry/flaky/clumpy 1
Jess from Mississippi
I normally love all tarte products, so of course I wanted to try this mascara. The first use was OK at best. I used it a few times to give it a couple more chances, but every time it flaked off and left black flecks on my face- even when I tried it with a mascara primer also. It was also clumpy and dry on the brush after only a couple uses. Would not recommend.
Would keep buying this one! 4
KT from Boulder
This doesn't make my eyes burn from any allergic response! Goes on smooth and light.
New fave mascara! 5
Kstarr94 from Illinois
I got it in a beauty box and tried it for the first time just playing around. I honestly haven't had a mascara EVER actually make me look I have lashes!!! They're so volumized and lengthy looking I just can't even!
ehh 3
kristen from indiana
I love this mascara normally. I have bought at least 15 of these tubes over the years. all the special edition ones, og ones, etc. Well I used my points to claim this so I paid like 50 cents for it. I got it was so excited as I always am to get a brand new mascara or any new makeup & was shocked at how it dried up after a couple days. These were defective or something. At least the one I got was. Don't waste your $, go buy the original LCL. This literally doesn't even do anything to my lashes. so disappointed..
Pass 2
Cass from Idaho
I bought this mascara when it was on sale and I was excited to get another Tarte mascara. Very disappointed. Started to dry up within a month. I'll definitely stick with their Lash Paint mascara. This one is not worth the money, even at a sale price.
Too Clumpy 2
Megan from Raleigh, NC
I was getting tired of settling for a cheap mascara. I decided to splurge on this one and I pretty much regret it. Yes, it's great for lengthening, but who wants long CLUMPY lashes? There is no volume, just clumps. The worst part is it was excluded from the coupon, so I paid full price for this disappointment. Don't even want to attempt other Tarte products.
Flawless Lashes! 5
Denney from Auburn, AL
This mascara is the best I have ever used! I have blonde eyelashes and they are short this mascara can't compare to any other mascara. It makes my lashes flawless and full!
Won't buy again. 2
Lauren from San Diego
Bought this on the 21 days of beauty sale to try it out, first use wast too bad, second & third use of it and it's clumpy, thick and a clumpy mess on my eye lashes, gross.
Honestly very good mascara would buy again 5
Marta from Wilmington, NC
I love this mascara you should most definitely buy it, it's worth it 😉
I am going to buy so many bottles of this!! it's amazing!! 5
styles by hannah from prairie grove arkansas
Since I am a cosmetologist I have to look the part! This mascara achieves every look and goes amazing with any eye shadow look you're trying to achieve!
My favorite mascara! 5
boisegirl from Boise, ID
I've used this mascara for a couple years now, and I always get compliments on how long my eyelashes are. This wand is not clumpy at all and lasts for a while. Ulta or Tarte will usually have these half off a couple times a year and I always stock up. My favorite Tarte mascara by far!!!
Good separation & length 4
Ainatl from GA
Was running out of my Maneater mascara and this was on sale during the 21 days of beauty so decided to give it a try. One coat of this mascara is good for daytime use. It gives good curl & length, but doesn't seem to volume much. At least not like Maneater does. It's not clumpy and separates lashes nicely. Not very easy to build on, so I typically stick with one coat of this. Easy to apply and lasts all day without running or flaking. Comes off easily with soap & water at night. I like the drama of Maneater better so will probably stick with that one, but this is a good alternative for a more natural look.
Nice! 5
Crystal from Las Vegas
I've only ever used the purple tube, so I wasn't sure if I would like the wand or formula, but it seems the same/similar, so no objections. Happily surprised it performs just as good.
The Best So Far! 5
Elmofj from Tampa, Florida
After having tried several different types of mascaras, from inexpensive drug store brands to high end, expensive brands this by far keeps coming up on top. It goes on smoothly, doesn't clump or flake and makes my lashes longer with just the right amount of volume. For a fuller, more dramatic look I just apply several layers. It's also very east to remove with eye makeup remover.
Love this mascara! 5
Amber from St. Louis
I bought this for the first time a couple years ago during a 21 days of beauty event, and have been in love since. I have long eyelashes, but they are light. I'm not sure if it lengthens your lashes, but it is super light weight with no clumps, and helps make my eyes pop.
