Product Reviews Rated 3.46 out of 5 stars
28 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Liquid liner Wand is easy to grip and gives better control. Tip: apply in short strokes.
Most Helpful Critical Review Dried up so quickly! I only used it twice and it was beautiful, but it was too dry after that. I made sure the cap was closed. I threw out the eyeliner I had, even though it wasn't finished, because I thought I had found the perfect eyeliner.Does NARS have any suggestions for fixing this problem?
Reviewed by 28 customers Not recommended 1
Wendy R from Fort Lauderdale
The liner smudges and it is really difficult to remove. I was looking for something that would not give me raccoon eyes. It does glide on easy.
Eyeliner for Steady Hands 4
anonymous from undisclosed
I like being able to go to a very fine line. This is my first experience with a wet eyeliner and it's going to take me lots of time to get used to it. Most mornings I have one eyelid quite different looking from the other.
nars eyeliner stylo 5
anonymous from new york
This i the only eyeliner ill ever use. It stays put and lasts all day.
the point stays sharp so it gives you a clean straight line that never crackles.
Great eyeliner 5
anonymous from undisclosed
Goes on easily and doesn't smear
Would not buy agsin 1
Sondie from Virginia
Does not flow good and make a easy line! Seems to not come out on felt tip
best eyeliner ever 5
drayugh from ny
I have used a plethora of high end eyeliners. Givenchy to Marc Jacobs and this liner takes the cake. All day wear, does not budge, precise tip also. EXCELLENT.
Easy and smooth 5
Taylor from Tucson AZ
I usually skip liner bc of the hassle but this liner is so easy to use. My main concern has been liner bleeding into thin lines making things look a bit crooked. This doesn't bleed on me and can easily make a very thin line
like others say.dry and disappointing 2
LisaO from new york, new york
I feel like this dried out too quickly. yes, i use eyeliner daily, but this went dry too fast. will NOT be buying again
no, moved w/ stay spray & applicator was too stiff 3
Brenna from Houston, texas
Winged eyeliner, no give when putting on
overpriced disappointment 2
A.S. from Moorestown
The felt tip drags across my lid as opposed to gliding, causing a bumpy line. Previous felt tip liners I've used were easier to work with than this one. The liner would also sweat off at the corner of my eyes over time. This liner does not last up time wise compared to other brands I've used, and does not apply well if you like a smooth thin line. Really disappointed in this product. I'm giving it 2 stars instead of 1 because a few times the pen would cooperate and leave a good, pigmented line.
Sticky lids... 1
MissC from Northern, NY
This liner is junk. Halfway through my day my lids are sticky and I have a black line built up in my crease. I haven't had an issue like that since I purchased a cheapo Maybelline liner as a last minute. This is what happens when I decide to try something new. I'll be sticking with my KVD and Tartiest after this experience.
Sticky lids, so gross. 2
MissC from NY
I wanted to switch up liners since my Tartiest was drying out quicker than it used to. I bought this because it had 5 stars. What a waste! This liner made my lids sticky! Last time I dealt with that, it's was a cheapo Maybelline liner. Wouldn't expect this from a nearly $30 liner. Highly disappointed.
Amazing Eyeliner - lasts all day 5
KMM from Fort Worth, TX
The only eyeliner I've found that lasts all day. I've bought other eyeliners (the same price or comparable) and they are wearing off in a few hours. Definitely worth the money.
Literally the best eyeliner I've ever used 5
Em from Huntington Beach, ca
The tip of the eyeliner is so perfect and gives the most precise line! So good and so long lasting!!
Faint color, tip dry and rough 2
AlyB from San Francisco, CA
I purchased this new from the Macy's in downtown Chicago. I was pretty disappointed when I first used it to find that it was not as moist as I had hoped, and that the color was very faint! Because it was dry (even after shaking and pinching) I had to go over my the line on my eye multiple times. Normally this wouldn't be an issue, but the felt tip was also rough and scratchy, making it a bit uncomfortable! I thought I had gotten a dud, but based on other reviews this may just be how it is
very dry and was disappointed with it 2
peachy7777 from Atlanta, GA, United States
loved other products that i bought, just not this one
dry 1
LillyG from Thailand
Unfortunately as some others have pointed out, this eyeliner does not last and dries out incredibly fast. I didn't even get beyond one use. The cap is not secure. It is a shame as it does not match up to the quality NARS normally delivers.
I'm addicted 5
Sam from Santa Cruz
Love this product! Just messy to remove.
It's excellent and... 5
Jacqueline hernandez from Fort Stockton, TX, United States
It's excellent and easy to use
Liquid liner 5
K Diffin from undisclosed
Wand is easy to grip and gives better control. Tip: apply in short strokes.
I would buy again 5
Ashley makeup lover from Phoenix az
It makes a great winged eye i love the felt tip
Dried up so quickly! 1
Frida K from Manhattan, New York, NY, United States
I only used it twice and it was beautiful, but it was too dry after that. I made sure the cap was closed. I threw out the eyeliner I had, even though it wasn't finished, because I thought I had found the perfect eyeliner.Does NARS have any suggestions for fixing this problem?
My favorite 5
Gigi from Orlando, FL
This is the only eyeliner I use. It does not run whatsoever and does not smudge through the day, even if you accidentally rub your eye. Nothing I have used compares.
I use Carpates (black).
4 stars 4
B love from West Virginia
Love it so much it is so pigmented and smooth
Former Favorite 2
Sue A from Bergen County, NJ, United States
I went through a lot of different eyeliners before swearing by this one, thinking that the search was over, that I'd finally found the liquid liner that I'll be sticking to. I'd recently purchased my second stilo after my first ran out, but the new one dried out after less than three weeks, post-purchase. I'd been so surprised, and had even checked to make sure that I wasn't accidentally using the old one instead of having throw it out... and especially disappointed, as the search now continues for another liquid liner.
