Product Reviews Rated 3.55 out of 5 stars
44 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Yaaaaas I recently purchased this product because I've been battling with dry skin and sensitivity. It got to the point that I started skipping makeup application daily because I didn't want to aggravate my skin any more.
Concealers are always a gamble with my skin because my under eye area is hyper sensitive and tends to flair up in irritating dry patches that are very difficult to cover up with makeup. This product has changed the game for me!
It's a very soft and smooth consistency that glides across my skin and hydrates. It's also not heavy and doesn't feel like it's just sitting on top of my troubled areas.
Instead, it feels like it's melted into my skin and is so light I've forgotten I even had it on. It smooths out my skin's surface and covers up my dark circles and hyperpigmentation while being gentle enough to use on my sensitive skin. It also doesn't crease so I don't even need to set it which is a plus because powders can make my skin look dry.
I like that it's a buildable coverage because I can decide how heavy I want to go for the day, and even at the heaviest application it never looks cakey and has a beautifully radiant finish. I'm obviously a fan and would definitely recommend this product to anyone with dry,sensitive skin.
Most Helpful Critical Review Sheer Coverage I like the fact that it's quite long lasting and has matte finish, but the coverage isn't good. If you're looking for an incredibly natural finish look, then this is it, but the product doesn't really work covering dark circles, at least it didn't on me. I wouldn't buy it again.
Reviewed by 44 customers Do not buy 3
Hailey (Makeup Artist) from Los Angeles
This product has THE WORST color range!!! Only three colors!!!! The lightest shade they have is ORANGE!!!!
Poor craftsmanship 2
Liz from Michigan
I ordered this after remembering how nice it felt on my skin, but just a few days after I got it, the dropper separated from the cap. Not worth the money. 2 stars only for the product itself, but since it will dry out and I didn't even get to use it beyond a week, not sure it's even worth those.
Poor craftsmanship 2
Liz from Michigan
I ordered this after remembering how nice it felt on my skin, but just a few days after I got it, the dropper separated from the cap. Not worth the money. 2 stars only for the product itself, but since it will dry out and I didn't even get to use it beyond a week, not sure it's even worth those.
Poor craftsmanship 2
Liz from Michigan
I ordered this after remembering how nice it felt on my skin, but just a few days after I got it, the dropper separated from the cap. Not worth the money. 2 stars only for the product itself, but since it will dry out and I didn't even get to use it beyond a week, not sure it's even worth those.
Please bring back Select Cover Up! 3
Janna from Denver
Nothing else is as good! I have tried a couple other MAC concealers, then tried Benefit and NARS.
awful 3
moiaaa from NJ
Dry, creasy, cakey, textured. Terrible. Deserves no stars. Returned.
Great for dry skin 5
LaurainPWN from Portland, Oregon
If you have dryer skin and tend to have creasing under your eyes this is the concealer for you! The coverage, in my opinion, is sheer to medium so not the best for if you need full coverage. I never have to apply moisturizer under my eye anymore or have to look in the mirror to check for creasing. M.A.C, please keep this product FOREVER!
fav concealer 5
laura from California
the best concealer I've used
Great concealer 5
Makeup Ru from Chicago
I'd been using pro longwear for years but now that I'm older (late 40s), it just looked too cakey on me. So I tried this and I love it. It's slightly luminous, looks great around the eyes. I just dab a tiny bit on the back of my hand and apply with a brush.
Soooo good! 5
Starbuck65 from Hawaii
I'm 54 and have dry-ish skin, particularly under my eyes, this doesn't dry me out at all and has a very natural finish. I can set it with powder and it still looks great. I find that my finger works best to apply this concealer as it's so fluid, a beauty blender would minimize the great coverage this concealer provides.
Everything I was looking for! 5
Cjmarhall from Michigan
I just switched to MAC after wearing BareMinerals for 15 years. What a game changer. I'm so impressed with how well it lasts and still looks fresh at the end of a busy day! I own my own daycare and have 3 children, my makeup was usually a mess by the end of the day. Not anymore! No creasing, no caking! And so so light and natural feeling (I use waterweight foundation too). I have freckles and like to be able to still see them after I apply makeup, the stuff is perfect for me but also buildable. I use very little and it goes such a long way!
Desappoint :( 1
Lp41 from Costa rica
My boyfriend bought this for me. Because he disn't find the one I use (mineralize concealer) and the consistency is so liquid and no cover absolute nothing. I Am really dissapoint with this product.
Gotta get creative 3
SammySweetCheeks from Tulsa, OK
This really isn't one of those products that you'll pick up and figure it out immediately. The dropper is weird, it's super runny, great coverage, creases like crazy, sets beautifully. At this point, I like to use this to clean up my eyebrows and if I'm doing a light makeup day, I could use this to conceal acne scars on my cheeks, but keep away from surfaces of your skin that crease.
This product is horrible 1
Lynz from Illinois
Broke up on my face
Hoped for better 1
Cassie from Texas
I was super excited about this product because I hate super cakey and thick concealers but this stuck to every dry patch on my skin. It doesn't go on smooth at all and looks super patchy.
Bring back the Mac select cover up! 1
mimimissy from Ohio
I was told by the MAC salesperson that this is close to the MAC select cover up, which was my favorite favorite concealer and product from MAC of all time. However, this is nothing like it. You guys really need to bring back MAC select cover up - it was the best concealer ever!
love it but the bottle came partially empty 4
Susan from Long Beach, CA
I really love this product. It matches really well to my skin and blends easily. It feels light and seems to last.
Pleasantly surprised 4
Brooke from Moscow, ID
I was very skeptical buying this at first because of how thin the formula was. After using it for a few weeks I can say that I really love this stuff. The packaging is trendy and easy to use. It covers my dark under eye circles great and doesn't dry out or leave my skin feeling greasy. The only con is how expensive it is for the tiny bottle.
Perfect 5
Christine from Virginia
I purchased Mac's concealer Th mix in my foundation for a lighter color and it works perfect.
Horrible 1
Jrzygirl130 from Brick, NJ
The sloppiest concealer, why it comes with an eye dropper is beyond me. Just taking it out of the bottle it drips all over your clothes and counter. Watery and just a mess
It's a great product. 5
Bunny from Apple Valley CA.
I have very sensitive skin and I love how this conceals without irritating my skin.
Great coverage for dark circles, but it creases like crazy 3
Julie from Birmingham, Al
I am 46 years old with normal skin. Foundation makes me oily, so I like using MAC Studio Fix NC15 for full coverage, and MAC Waterweight foundation NC25 for a more natural looking face. I use MAC Mineralize Concealer in NW20 and it is much more yellow than the Waterweight Concealer NW20. The Waterweight concealer is much more Salmon colored and is VERY effective in masking my purple undereye circles. Only a little product is needed as this product is very pigmented. Great, lasting coverage. However, the product creases like crazy and accentuates lines and patches. I am trying every method in the book to get this to work because it is unparalleled in its dark circle coverage. I have never had any product cover my circles so effectively. The creasing is a big turnoff. I use argan oil underneath, I use the lightest hand with setting powder, I don't use but 1 layer of product, and I only use it in the dark area; I don't use this in the popular triangle pattern. Nothing so far has prevented creasing. I am going to continue to work with this product until it is gone, but I will not repurchase unless I can lessen the creasing. If you are younger than 40 with only a few lines and little to no dryness under your eyes, this product may well work for you.
Amazing product! 5
Ruby from Menifee, CA
I have dark circles and this concealer does the job! Good coverage and light weight.
LOVE! 5
EC from Washington, DC
I heard Nadine Blodgett talking about how wonderful this concealer and how she even uses it as foundation, so I tried it. I am glad I did because I really, really like and I don't usually like any concealer. I have to say that I tried the Waterweight foundation previously and it never sat right on my skin. This is much better and blends in beautifully under my eyes and on my face too. A little goes a long way but it is buildable. Also appreciate that it's in a much sturdier bottle than the Pro Longwear concealer.
best concealer for my dry skin! 5
Ashlynn from washington, d.c.
I have fairly good skin, but it's dry! I don't like a lot of coverage and nothing too heavy and this is perfect!
