Product Reviews Rated 4.47 out of 5 stars
416 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review My New Favorite Awesome mascara. Natural. Coconut oil. No chemicals burning my eyes. Great price! I have finally found The One 😊
Most Helpful Critical Review Not All Natural I bought this with the intent of purchasing more natural, greener makeup products. This was before I did additional research and was new to the 'clean beauty products' available on the market. I'm not impressed with this mascara at all. It makes my eyes hurt after a few hours of wear, and it does actually contain preservatives, so it is not classified as a natural, green, clean product. I find it flakes and is sticky, and difficult to take off. Even after using makeup remover, I still find smudges and specks on my skin and have to scrub with soap to get it off. I do not believe I will be repurchasing this product again.
Reviewed by 416 customers My New Go-To 5
Opalyte from Philadelphia, PA
I love the color and the sheen. Easy to apply, big brush, doesn't smear as badly as other wands I've used. Even smells good. Will buy again!
Mediocre 3
Liz from Oahu, Hawaii
I really wanted to love this mascara, as I have sad eyelashes; they're straight, and short. It doesn't hold a curl at all, whether I curled before or after application(I know after can be bad for you). It really only made my lashes a little darker and that's it.
Amazing! 5
Laura707 from Sacramento
Amazing! Doesn't flake at all throughout the day and makes my eyes lashes look spectacular. I totally recommend this!
mascara 5
attackbunny from undisclosed
Really like the full applicator. It grabs all the lashes nicely.
A great mascara 5
Barbie Ellen from New York, NY
The texture of the mascara is not heavy, but substantial enough to give dimension to the eyes. As a fair blonde, I find stardust to be the perfect brown: not so dark as to look harsh, and not so light as to make me look washed out. A great choice for blondes and redheads. Extends lashes considerably, and removes easily.
A little disappointing 3
Rachula from Salem,OR
I was looking for a mascara that wouldn't irritate my eyes. I wear contacts and stare at a computer for 10-12 hours per day, so a lot of mascaras irritate. This one is non-irritating, but also almost looks like you're not wearing mascara at all. My eyelashes are darker, but don't appear fuller or longer at all. It also transfers onto my under eye.
The Best!! 5
Jenny from Ohio
I use this mascara every day! It makes my lashes look sooo long and super full! I get compliments on it all the time. It's also a super buildable formula so you can go for a more natural look if that's your jam, or you can trick everyone into thinking you're wearing falsies :) definitely recommend this product!
pacifica mascara! 4
ameilabedilya95 from undisclosed
I got this as a gift from one of my friends, awhile back, and i was pleasantly surprised of how nice this mascara is!! It lengthens, thickens, and goes on super smoothly!! The only complaint would be that it isnt water proof!!! If it was water proof then it would be a five star mascara!
Great for sensitive eyes with great results 5
SA from NY
This is a great mascara. It doesn't flake and it doesn't irritate my eyes while also lengthening my lashes. It also doesn't smudge easily.
It's Fine, But Not Great 3
BakeAndDestroy from Chicago, IL
I usually love-love Pacifica products but I'm underwhelmed by the Stellar Glaze mascara. It doesn't do much in the way of lengthening or volume and it smudges.
Lasts all day, no irritation 5
Autumnbynature from California
I love how natural this looks. It's very wet and can smudge easily before it dries but it looks great, doesn't clump, and best of all has never once caused my eyes any irritation. Also it lasts all day, and...yes, the next morning, still no makeup circles! It stays put!
Nourishing 4
shinelikethedawn from Oregon
This mascara nourishes and keeps my lashes healthy. My only struggle is the brush is too big, so I always bump my upper lids and need a q-tip to clean it up.
Pretty good! 3
Margaret from Mississippi
This mascara I would say is best for someone who already has lashes with decent length and density who also lives in climate with little humidity. I live in the southeast, so the humidity really puts mascara to the test. If you wear a light layer, then the smudging is minimal. It didn't ever clump AT ALL. Seriously, I could probably put ten coats on and no clumping. The brush is the biggest I've seen, so it is very difficult to put on your bottom lashes. As for the formula, it is very wet. If you're not careful it gets on the lids. I've tried many mascaras, and I'd give this one a 5/10.
Almost Perfect 4
onl1118 from Pittsburgh, PA
I love the length and volume that I get from this mascara, and the fact that it's all natural, cruelty free, and vegan makes it even better. My only issue is that during allergy season my eyes can get pretty watery and the mascara will sometimes run. For me, that's not a big deal though. Will buy again!
Love it! 5
DanaW from New york
Really quality mascara, not clumpy or sticky. Stays on and looking fresh even in this insane humidity we're having. I love that it's not full of weird toxic stuff!
Doesn't do much...and smudges 2
Lindsey from Albany
I really wanted to love this product due to its amazing, non-toxic ingredient list, so i can say that I tried it out with an open mind. It doesn't really do anything for your lashes. It doesn't thicken or lengthen. The formula is really thin, too which may account for the lack of well... everything. Very natural looking. I only had this on for several hours and I was working inside for the entire time and it still smudged.
Lush 4
MrsP from Chicagoland
Very lush and moist. The brush is nice and fat. My lashes feel conditioned. This will not make your lashes significantly longer or thicker like mascaras with fiber in them but on the flip side this doesn't give you clumpy lashes. My lashes look somewhat longer and somewhat thicker and feel soft, conditioned and healthy.
Mascara 3
Alison R from Oregon
It's a nice mascara I like it to have no clumps so it gave me clumps
Love this mascara!! 5
AudreySciortino from Detroit
This is the best lengthening mascara I have used. It does not flake and stays on all day.
Love the result! 5
cheasy24 from Billings, MT
This was the first product I tried from Pacifica and have loved it ever since! It gives my lashes awesome length that even my boyfriend compliments me every time I put it on! :)
Good option for vegan mascara 4
etherealtype from undisclosed
Not my favorite but a good option if youre looking for a clean, vegan option on a budget. I find this one a lot better for making my lashes look thick but it isnt super lengthening nor does it give much of a curl. It does wear nicely through the day without too much flakiness. I just wish it gave more length! Probably wouldnt re-buy but happy to use it up!
Will use no other 5
Cathie T from Utah
This Stellar Gaze Mineral mascara became my go to. Don't want to use any other now.c It is very natural looking and easy on my lashes. Absolutely no clumping and non irritating. Easy to build for definition if necessary. Absolutely love it!
My new favorite Mascara! 5
littlequeenbee from undisclosed
This is my new favorite mascara! I ALWAYS had to buy waterproof mascara before because I am a major crier. But this mascara is great even for when I cry or if I get sweaty. It lasts all day and looks stunning. Really lengthens and curls my eyelashes too.
Works Beautifully! 5
Shadow's Song from USA
Great! Works well! It will clump your lashes easily if you're not careful, but, with a steady hand, this brush will extend those lovely lashes evenly and beautifully! I am VERY pleased with this product! Thank you, Pacifica! ♥
Nothing Special 2
Kathyb from Hollidaysburg, Pa
This mascara is just okay. Not any better than any other brand I have used.
