Product Reviews Rated 4.22 out of 5 stars
69 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review I would buy this again. I've gotten the Eyeko Liquid eyeliner in one of my Ipsy bags and I absolutely loved it! I wanted to try this for my bottom lash line and I was not disappointed. It stayed out all day and didn't budge at all! And with the Arizona heat rising up to 90-100 degrees, it still didn't budge. And I have oily skin too. I love Eyeko.
Most Helpful Critical Review Smudges...so disappointed I bought this on the strength of Alexa Chung's winged liner trick (she's associated with the brand), and I am truly disappointed. I wore this on my waterline and it was gone less than an hour later. I tried it on my bare upper lid and it smudged before my 8 hour work day was over (and I work in an office, so no excuse there). Finally, today I tried it layered over my eye primer, and yep...dark smudges under my eye and a bit of product gooped up at the corner of my outer eye (and that never has happened with any other brand of liner). I can't imagine that this would stand up to a hard workout if it can't make it through a regular office day.
To make matters even worse, the liner itself seemed a little dry...I had to rub the product against my hand to get it moving across my lid. UD has far superior liners, but pretty much any brand would do better (I'm going back to my Ulta liner).
Reviewed by 69 customers Great product 5
Adri52 from San Jose, California
This eyeliner, love to use it when I'm going to the gym, stay in place , I don't have to be worrying about my makeup.
I wouldn't buy it ever again 1
Why do I have to have a nickname from California
I regret ever buying it, no good at all!
Worth the discounted purchase 4
KrysC from Stockton
I got this half off (thankfully). The first one was broken upon arrival because it's so soft. Ulta replaced it (: it is a great waterline liner. It smudges too much to be used elsewhere, in my opinion.
Does not stay put at all 1
Lucy from Boston
I've never had an eyeliner smear this bad. Even with primer, if I apply just a little to upper outer lash line, in less than a minute I have raccoon-eye/full-on-90's-heroine-chic smudge under my whole eye. I don't even know how it's this bad especially when I apply very lightly. If that's not the look you're going for, try a different brand.
Please don't stop selling this! 5
Docjessp from Pittsburgh
This stuff is a godsend. I have oily skin, and finding a non irritating eyeliner that stays put is hard. Gel like formula will glide on. You have about a minute to brush it or manipulate it, then it is set. Eye creams or serum will lessen that effect, FYI.
Stays on through workout and good w/ contact lenses 4
Neurotic label reader from Michigan
I got this on a half-off sale since switching up my eyeliner technique. I use it in my waterline and then use the included brush end to make a small flick and subtle cat eye shape. This eyeliner makes my eyes water slightly at first. I've found that short strokes followed by a blink help reduce irritation when applying. Once it is on, it doesn't smudge on my contacts, which is major. This eyeliner is almost too smudgeable, though. It does stay put once set, after about 20-30 seconds, but my complaint is how far it can travel before being set. Like, travels to bottom lid or smears out to greyness. I recommend drawing your line and waiting at least ten seconds before smudging so the color doesn't go everywhere. Like the name suggests, it survives a tough workout! I do like the non-toxic and nourishing ingredients. I would buy this again on sale, but probably not at full price.
Love it! 5
KW from Bend, Oregon
A must have for those that suffer from seasonal allergies. My eyes water all day from allergies and this eyeliner stays put!
This is the BEST EL EVER!! 5
Crystal from Wisconsin
It's blacker than black, and it does not move or transfer to the corner of the eye or lower water line. This is what I've been dreaming of my whole life! 5 stars!
Disappointment 1
Ruth from Nj
I bought this because of the reviews. I researched ! This is the worst! No gliding!! Can't get it on at all. It's like it's so dry it won't draw a kind ! Wiped the tip down. Tried again. It's awful. A lot of money for an eyeliner that doesn't line! Better off buying a drugstore pencil. So disappointed ! Waste of money !
Please don't stop making this! 5
Docjess from Pittsburgh
I love this eyeliner! Once I apply it, I smudge it with a small brush quickly, and once it dries, it doesn't budge for 10 hours. I have oily skin, so this is a godsend. I wish it came in more than one color! I always have a couple extra, I'm terrified that they will discontinue this!
One of the best 5
Queenofshopping from Clinton township mi
My favorite dark black mat eyeliner and I have tried a ton, from marc Jacob's to kat von d, theirs are good but not as long lasting as well as color payoff for me. I have been using this liner for years daily. I use the liner with dark shadow and you can still see the liner. I always buy backup of this liner since it seems to sell out quickly and hard to keep in stock. I my skin is normal to oily, I use my UD eye primer, then shadow (favorite is the natasha denona gold palette, BH zodiac, pat macgrath), then my liner.
The best eyeliner 5
Christine from Clinton township, Michigan
This is the best eyeliner! Its a true black mat liner, stays on all day without touch ups, no sharpening required. I use this everyday and have no complaints except for ulta being out of stock so long. I had to go to Nordy and buy more expensive brands to get the same benefits if this eyeko pencil. Also i will not purchase eyeliners you have to sharpen, its such a waste of product/money and its messy.
Its great! 5
Expert shopper from Clinton township, Michigan
I have been looking for the "it" eyeliner and this is it! I love that it does not have to be sharpened so no wasted product. And more importantly the color is a true black and it does not run. I spent to much money on other expensive brands before trying this. Too bad ulta has been out of stock for a while - so i have to purchase it else where.
She tries hunny 4
Posh Lula from Alabama
Close to perfect but not 100% in the corners so do check the mirror throughout the day of you have watery eyes like me. Doesn't stay on my lower waterline either but she tries hunny, she tries.
I would buy this again. 5
Cat from Casa Grande, Arizona
I've gotten the Eyeko Liquid eyeliner in one of my Ipsy bags and I absolutely loved it! I wanted to try this for my bottom lash line and I was not disappointed. It stayed out all day and didn't budge at all! And with the Arizona heat rising up to 90-100 degrees, it still didn't budge. And I have oily skin too. I love Eyeko.
I would buy this product again! 5
Ros from Phoenix, AZ
I tend to stick to my usual Stila liners and decided to buy on sale, glad I did, it didn't run, stayed in place throughout the day.
Great Product doesnt smudge 4
Becky from New Richmond
Very bold color. Glides on smooth...stayed on all day...love it
Nice bold line 4
Nicola from Los Angeles, CA
I really loved the way this eyeliner glides on with the coconut oil included in the formula. Since it's a crayon/pencil type I wasn't able to achieve my usual cat eye but it was a nice, dark line close around the eyes. I like to use waterproof just for everyday use to avoid smudging from sweaty eyelids and this did the trick.
Long-Lasting.... Finally! 5
MamainParadise from Scottsdale, AZ
Perfect for everyday wear. Strong enough to last through the full day at work... exactly what is needed for the working woman
Love this 5
Mandy from Arlington
Love it
i searched to get this product after i got a sample of it 5
T from Holbrook,NY
I use this product every day. I put it on in the AM and it is still there in the PM. I got a sample of it from birch box and then I had to find it in a large size. I love all the eyeko products.
pretty decent eyeliner 4
Mstack from Huntington Beach
It goes on great & looks good but by the end of the day it is pretty faded. I do have oilier skin though so it is hard for me to find something that lasts.
Awesome eyeliner! 5
Jenna R. from Maryland
I bought this during the 21 days sale having never tried this specific eyeko liner but already knowing I love the skinny liquid. So far it seems like it has great staying power, I can't wait to really test it on my upcoming vacation.
Definitely will buy this product again 5
KK from Jacksonville, Florida
Eye liner it's my must have, because I don't use much makeup, but eye liner it's always on... definitely love this one
Stays on Great! 4
TA from Oshkosh
Bought on special, like it better than Urban Decay! I also got a great deal on it!