Rated 4.19 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Should get all of the awards
Incredible product through and through. My eyes are extremely sensitive, and so it can be hard to find a mascara that doesn't make my eyes water, itch, or puff up. I have none of these problems with this mascara! It also does its job like a miracle worker!!!! Let's just say that I've had multiple sob sessions with this mascara on, and there is no way you can tell. This mascara also excels in the lake and pool! I've used other waterproof mascaras in the past, such as Bobbi Brown's, and they have all smudged a little, or after exposure to water, the volume has gone down. Neither is the case with Eyeko! This also comes off with makeup remover without any resistance. Basically, whatever you need from a mascara, the Sport Waterproof Mascara Catch & Curl can handle it all with ease! I don't think I will ever use another mascara again!!!
Most Helpful Critical Review Too little for too much
I had ordered the regular waterproof Eyeko and was very pleased, except some flaking. It also didn't fill out my lashes as expected. This mascara is perfect, except after about 5 uses, I noticed it was drying out already. It's too expensive for that kind of performance. Perhaps I just received a bad tube.
Reviewed by 100 customers not very good
tricia from MA
I found this neither made my eyelashes look longer/fuller nor was sweatproof. It smudged very easily. Would not recommend
Worse than Eyeko Beach Waterproof Mascara
Erica from Chicago, IL
Would not recommend this mascara by Eyeko. I really loved the Beach Waterproof Mascara and thought I would love this as well. It is not as waterproof, smudges, is very watery, and does not build up.
Harley from Miami
Legit the best and most waterproof mascara I've ever used. My skin is oily and it always melts off my mascara, this one won't smudge at all throughout the day.
Smudges very badly
Lil from IN
This mascara smudged throughout the day. Not every long-lasting. I have dry skins around my eyes. I almost never got smudges and when I did it was mostly only the tiny area close to the corner of my eyes instead of the entire undereye area. I did not realize how dark my undereye had got till after I came home from work at night. I would recommend using powder to set this mascara before applying a finishing layer.
Lost eyelashes! Don't buy
Makeup junkie from Michigan
Never in all my life have I had eyelashes lost due to mascara. Initially I loved it and it worked great during our beach vacation. Within a few days I noticed I was bare in some places along my lash line. I was SHOCKED. I hadn't used any fake lashes during this trip, where I'd normally lose lashes. I noticed many lashes on the brush every time I used it. Fast forward a couple weeks and I tried using it again at home. I cleaned the brush completely and still lost half a dozen lashes at a time. I just threw it in the garbage. I usually use high end mascaras priced no less than $22. I've also used lesser expensive but none made me lose wads of lashes. I'll be going back to Dior.
I would buy this again and again
Susan from San Antonio, TX
Applied in morning and didn't have to worry about it ever again
Wanted to like it
Natalie from Toledo, OH
I love the packaging of this product & was super excited to use a mascara that was designed for waterproof sport defense. However, every time I use this mascara my eye becomes irritated & I only notice this happening when I apply this mascara. I want to keep using it, but my eye is so irritated (it feels like something is poking my eyeball) that I don't want to keep experiencing the feeling.
Not For Me
SJGN from Phoenix, AZ
I gave it 2 weeks worth of tries. I have the most difficult eyelashes, so I am very critical of how mascara performs for me. My lashes are short, sparse, angled down and sideways, and holds a curl less and less as I age. Only one pro: the brush shape and bristles length made it easy to get into the small corners.
Cons: uncurled the lashes, flakes after 3 hours, crunchy, volume at the tips of my lashes point downward instead of upward.
SO GOOD AND SO WORTH IT
Maya from New Jeresey
This is hands down the best mascra I have ever used!!! It's allergy season and I am constantly rubbing my eyes and my eyes are always getting SUPER watery and irritated, but this mascra doesn't smudge one bit! I like how the brush is curved so it helps curl my lashes because I have stick-straight asian eyelashes that won't keep a curl, and this does the trick. It is a more natural mascara, as tubing mascaras are meant to be, but I actually really like that because you can build it up and it won't apply too much on your lashes on the first swipe. It is a more pricey mascra, and being someone who will buy the drugstore option every chance I get, I think it's TOTALLY worth it.
Wouldn't buy again
P from NC
Did not take very long before i had smudges under my eyes. I liked the Beach version better.
Good thing I like it, because it's practically permanent
MissDelta from Los Angeles, CA
This is a great mascara. It's not drammatic, but I also would not call it natural. It gives a little volume and a lot of lengthening blackness. And it is REALLY black. The brush is a little odd in that it somehow attracts hair out of the air (I have cats and I shed) which I then have to pick out of it the next time I use the mascara.\
The biggest downside is that it is TOUGH to remove. I LOVE waterproof mascara and eyeliner. I understand that most makeup removers won't get them off. But there are some that are good at removing stubborn waterproof formulas...except for this one. I bet you could do a triathlon in this mascara. It takes WORK to make it budge.
My Favorite Mascara!
Liz from Marietta, GA
My new favorite mascara. I switched to this amazing mascara from Too Faced Better Than Sex because I wanted something waterproof AND to be able to last through my police training (which can often times be a hard, sweaty workout). This stands up beautifully and doesn't budge. I love the curved brush as it truly does curl your lashes. I've really worked on simplifying my makeup routine to something that I can wear in uniform and withstands my daily demands and this fits the bill. It is a dry formula (which isn't good or bad, I guess that is a preference thing and I do prefer it drier). I love the packaging; I feel like you get a lot of product and will waste less than using a traditionally packaged masacra. I bought an extra tube for my travel bag and a backup for when I run out. < 3 < 3
Not worth the price
Joyfal from Hartford,ct
Disappointed in this product given the price. Takes a long time to apply. Does not cover well.
Debra from Maine
I got a full size tube of this mascara with one of those 20 or 30 pc free gift pkg. First of all, I can't believe how much mascara is in this tube, this is huge. I love how it stays on, I use the non oily makeup remover or baby oil and it comes off great. One thing I don't like is the brush, it's way too big but I generally save a brush or 2 when throwing old mascara away, I clean it and put it with the rest of "just in case" items. I've used the same mascara since I was 12 which is the maybelline green and pink tube, waterproof. No matter what I tried I always went back to that. This is my new mascara, I absolutely love it.
waterproof, but doesn't hold a curl
Stephanie from Washington, DC
I have very stick straight Asian lashes that only stay curled if I wear waterproof mascara. Somehow, this only holds about 30% of my curl, despite having a waterproof formula. I already don't like this because of that. The texture is also very interesting - it's kind of waxy, not quite a dry or wet formula. Just waxy. It makes it hard to deposit product onto my lashes, so the end result is a very very natural look. I always have to layer a volumizing mascara on top to make my lashes visible. If you like a very natural look and need just a bit of hold, this will work for you. If you're used to other waterproof mascaras, you'll be disappointed in this one.
klaatsch from Louisiana
First off, I have to say that I truly love this mascara. I have been searching for a long time for a mascara that doesn't transfer onto my undereye. That being said, it does nothing for length or volume, or at least not in the amount of time I want to spend on doing my lashes. I layer it over an Essence mascara and it still doesn't transfer. Be warned, it doesn't come off easily, even with an oil cleanser.
I Love the Brush...
Colleen from Edgewood, MD
I like this mascara - I love the brush....I have short, thin eyelashes and use an eyelash enhancer, and I think the curl in the brush helps to enhance the length of my lashes. I like the length of the brush too, because it really helps to separate my lashes. The only thing with this mascara is sometimes I find it comes to me a little dried-out and other times it's more liquidy....Overall, I really like this mascara, because I keep purchasing it.....
Brooke from Cleveland, OH
Still leaves black ring below eyes.
Very Straight Lashes
Laura from Southern California
Easy to take off but left my eyelashes so straight. Even after curling them. I wanted curly lashes for that price. Returned.
t from illinois
Very dry and irritated my eyes.
It's an okay mascara
LipsNlashes from Bethlehem, PA
It's an okay mascara nothing special. I won't repurchase again.
Best Waterproof mascara
TME from North Carolina
Stays on with swimming and active water sports in pool and ocean.
No smudges while glistening!
Pickleball gal from Shreveport LA
I wear this mascara when I play Pickleball. It doesn't smudge, run or flake off while "glistening" from 2 hours of exercise!
My Absolute Fave Go-To Mascara!
Estee Dahan from Longview, WA
This mascara is the bees knees! I was beginning to think that I'd never find a waterproof mascara that wouldn't make my lashes stick together. This mascara had everything I was looking for: waterproof, non-sticky, and natural fibers for length. Hands down, this has been the best mascara for the money!
I wouldn't buy it again
ME from Boston, MA
I don't like the brush, hard to get on each lash