Rated 4.09 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Lasts
I have been using this eyeliner for about a month now and I really like it. It goes on easily and lasts all day. The only thing that would make it better is if it was a roll up but it is an awesome pencil.
Most Helpful Critical Review Great liner one the first few uses... then useless
Loved this eyeliner and was so excited to have found a new eyeliner that really did stay on and didn't smudge.... HOWEVER, once the tip got dull and had to be sharpened, it has never been the same. The tip falls apart and I still cannot get it sharpened enough for using again. This sucks because it's a brand new liner that I can't use- and I have go out and find another to takes its place. Revlon please remake this eyeliner with a better "vehicle" (pencil) that can be easily sharpened.
I gave 3 stars because when it works, it's actually a great liner, if you can get it to sharpen...
Reviewed by 270 customers not as waterproof
Ms from WA
I use this to tightline the eyes. It comes out very dark which is good but doesn't last long so I'm guessing it's not really waterproof
How do I sharpen!
Heidi from Missouri
Not happy with quality of sharpening since I can't!
Heather75 from Oklahoma
After trying several eyeliners, I came across this one at my local drug store. I was very impressed with the first couple of uses until I needed to sharpen the pencil. Even though the color was great and the ease of how well it went on was great; the inability to sharpen it was disappointing.
Could be 5 stars
Jeng from undisclosed
The product itself is awesome! The eyeliner goes on great, looks great and last longer than most drugstore eyeliner. But you get a few uses and then it's impossible to sharpen to a point, even after placing in the freezer. Might try again after the pencil is replaced with a roll up dispenser.
Loving this product
Christie from Seattle, WA
Love the long wearing use of this product. It's waterproof and goes on so smooth.
I keep buying this !
Christie from Seattle, WA
This is my favorite eyeliner. Goes on smooth and stays on all day and during my 12 hour shift at work! This is my only eyeliner I use now!
Hippy from undisclosed
The liner itself is great. Regarding the sharpening of it, don't try to use a sharpener on it. I have had this problem with this and other liners where you can't sharpen it. So.......Try taking off the top part of of the pencil with a pair of pliers. Then use a nail and insert it into the hole at the top.....you can then push down the liner substance and keep using it.
Would not recommend
Kary from undisclosed
A lot of other reviews say they are unable to sharpen the eyeliner. I'm just trying to extend it in order for me to sharpen it! I twisted the bottom of it for about 60 seconds and nothing happened. I broke it open and there is definitely eyeliner in there, but I am unable to access it. I hope I'm not just having a dull moment....
Dee from Idaho
As others have posted it was great at the beginning until I needed to sharpen. I have a great sharpener that works well on other products but when used on this eyeliner it was a fail. Bought it while on vaca so unable to return :(
Yaneth from Aliso viejo
ashlik from Boston, ma
I loved, loved, loved this liner, until I needed to sharpen it.. then it was useless. I got it enough to work but never the same.. they need a better design.. i feel like I basically paid for the use of the tip of my liner
Come down, you can sharpen this...
AshMelb from Melbourne,Australia
I also thought I couldn't sharpen the eyeliner but you can do it with eyeliner sharpner. I doubt if you can use a cutter knife though.
I used to use similar products from Korea which I swore by, those eyeliners are very convenient to use by twisting the pencil. If Revlon had better understanding about their product to choose what type of packaging they would use for this eyeliner, they wouldn't make such kind of mistake making it into pencil type to sharpen, especially for this creamy and soft liner.
REVLON so fierce vinyl eyeliner
Katelyn from Minnesota
This is my second time buying this product thought maybe I didn't know how to use it and destroyed the first one. Bought two more thinking it was a operating error on my end just to find out none of them twist and do not sharpen nice. What I did get to use works great, but the rest of the eyeliner was not reachable. It's really a bummer.
Tip does not come out
Notgonnabuy from Utah
Bought 2 and with both the tip will come out. Twist and twist and nothing. What junk!
Priced right, great quality, excellent finish
Tre from Maui
Have already repurchased this 4 times! Glides on easily (on average non-crepey lids), stays put, bold liquid like finish, easier to use than a liquid liner. If you're looking for these qualities, worth a try. This also does not transfer on me, and I have an oily skin texture.
Can't sharpen--waste of money
ErinG from Portland, Oregon
I just bought this and discovered that you only get a small tip of eyeliner, and there's no way to keep it sharpened. So once you use it a little bit, the tip becomes dull. I feel mislead.
Threw mine in the trash
Lulu from undisclosed
Poor design. Good for a few uses and that is it. Very disappointed in Revlon.
Horrible! Don't waste your money!
Sirenvox from Raleigh, NC
Revlon usually create great products, however, this is not one of them. As many other reviews mention, it's impossible to sharpen. The more you try to sharpen, the more of a mess this makes. It's currently all over my hands and desk. I just bought this and only used it a few times, now it's a worthless mess. The good reviews must be before these poor souls tried to sharpen it. :) As I said, very disappointing product. Save your $ and try something else! Next time, I'm reading reviews first!
Sager from Lewisville, Texas
I can't believe Revlon made this product. First, they don't tell how you are supposed to use the product once you've used the initial tip. Second, why should I have to put my makeup in the freezer? Your product should work. Third, they don't include a sharpener with the product. I never right bad reviews but this made me mad that I could only use it for a week and I had to go online to figure it out. I wasn't the only one who had issues. I've used Revlon eyeliner for years and loved it but I don't think I will again. Sorry!
Itsdreyaa from Norwalk
Super black. Which I love. Lasts quite a hours! Not my favorite however for the price I would totally buy again.
Yes i would definitely buy this again
Mar from Omaha ne
Goes on very smooth and really stays on for the day.
Slide right on
Mandapleasee from Denver, Colorado
The best thing about this so fierce eyeliner is that it glides right on and doesn't smear. Even though it isn't waterproof it still stays on well but comes off easy with my makeup remover.
Pidge from Upstate NY
I'm not the greatest at applying eyeliner so the smoothness factor is tricky for me but not a deal breaker. It drags slightly but overall I'm very happy. Nice pigmentation and it doesn't budge! This is the first eyeliner, liquid or pencil, that hasn't transferred from my lashline to my upper eyelid area. Today I used it on lids prepped with Fiona Stiles Invisible Eye Primer but even without primer it hasn't transferred.
What a rip off.
Andy from Tampa, Florida
The pencil is only good for two or three uses. You can't sharpen it. It doesn't twist at the bottom and it falls apart in a pencil sharpener. . I am baffled why such a reputable company put out such a terrible product before testing it. Do they really think we would continue buying it every day?
CJ from Iowa
Makes perfect lines and is easy to clean up with a qtip if you make a mistake.