Product Reviews Rated 2.92 out of 5 stars
26 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Waterproof AND Washable! A+ This is the most innovative mascara on the market and the one I will wear everyday. It is waterproof AND washable, so now you no longer have to choose between having to scrub your eyes out or long wearing mascara.
Most Helpful Critical Review NOT WATERPROOF AT ALL I had such high hopes for this mascara because the brush is shaped in a curve which helps to coat every lash without missing any, and also has many tiny bristles which I've learned is great for volume. However, as much as I may love the brush, the formula is not waterproof at all - as it claims to be. The very first ingredient in this is.. WATER so of course it isn't going to be waterproof or hold a curl. As someone with long straight lashes, a waterproof formula is very important for holding my curl. If maybelline makes this a true waterproof formula, I will continue to purchase as I loved the brush!
Reviewed by 26 customers Horrible 1
Juju08188882772 from Montreal, Canada
Its sticks to the other lashes. I even try the waterproof test after and it comes out right off so easy... never I experience this with a waterproof mascara. Dont buy it if it for the waterproof . For the rest it ok i guess.
Older women's go to 4
Roni702 from Las Vegas
I LOVE this mascara! I dont give a hoot about a curl in my lashes. This mascara gives me volume and length without clumpy. It is waterproof but doesn't peel my lashes of when I remove it. I'm 54 and still have great lashes and dont use fake ones. It does crumble a little, but only when getting to old and minimal smudging. Great price for great product...for me.
Excellent Brush 4
PatyE from El Centro, Ca
I like the brush, but the consistency of the mascara is a little heavier. However, is one of my favorites mascaras
might be the worst water proof ever 2
Adeline27 from WI
takes forever to get off, smears, clumps, and literally glues your eye lashes together.
Not waterproof 1
Laneygrey from Charlotte NC
This waterproof mascara is not waterproof .
Put it on for the first time heading to a pool party was telling my friends how much I liked it.
Got in pool and my mascara completely came off. All of it. Also irritated my eyes until I was able to wipe it all of
nice for the basic every day subtle definition 4
Sintia from Los Angeles
Similar to waterproof clumpcrusher but with a little more oomph and I like this brush better. Also the reviews are true, it didn't hold my curl but maybe it needs to dry up a little first?
Not for those with straight lashes! 2
Ltaylor from TN
My lashes are very straight therefore I have to curl them and use waterproof mascara. I love the brush and the look it gives to my lashes. However it will not hold curl. My lashes were drooping within minutes. What a shame.
I Like it 4
Learning Makeup from North Carolina
The mascara does exactly what it is suppose to do. The applicator is easy, the product goes on smooth and my lashes look fuller and longer. However, removing the mascara at the end of the day takes work. I use an oil based mascara remover and a make up wipe and it still takes multiple swipes and scrubs to finally get it off.
NOT WATERPROOF AT ALL 2
mb12 from New York
I had such high hopes for this mascara because the brush is shaped in a curve which helps to coat every lash without missing any, and also has many tiny bristles which I've learned is great for volume. However, as much as I may love the brush, the formula is not waterproof at all - as it claims to be. The very first ingredient in this is.. WATER so of course it isn't going to be waterproof or hold a curl. As someone with long straight lashes, a waterproof formula is very important for holding my curl. If maybelline makes this a true waterproof formula, I will continue to purchase as I loved the brush!
Does not keep lashed curled 1
Land from new mexico
A great buy if you like mascara that uncurls your lashes. . It almost instantly uncurled my lashes, even though it's waterproof, this formula did not do the job as most waterproof
So bad 1
Bella from Los Angeles
Ugh I had such high hopes because I think all the other maybelline mascara formulas are great! However this one was horrible. I think it's because it's meant to be a tubing like mascara in the first place. I curled my lashes and it didn't even hold the up for 30 seconds. I wanted to like this but it's not living up to it's claims.
Another one bites the dust 1
ambrenn from Oshkosh, WI
A great buy if you like mascara that uncurls your lashes. I've learned far too many times that I always need to buy the waterproof version of any mascara if I want it to keep the curl in my lashes, but that didn't matter with this formula. It almost instantly uncurled my lashes, even though it's waterproof.
The applicator is nice, the product glides on smoothly, I just can't wear it when I have others that perform better.
Nope 1
Ky from Irvine
Bought this to try out since I ran out of the L'Oréal Voluminous False Fiber Lashes last minute in preparation for my birthday dinner and it didn't do anything to my lashes, I will stick to the other mascara.
Not impressed 1
Lora from MI
Fake marketing got me to buy this based on promises of a simple formula with no clumps. I wore it two days and gave up. There are clumps on the brush coming right out of the tube. Clumps all over my lashes and flakes on my cheeks half way through the day. A waste of my money. Covergirl Clump Crusher is a far better product.
This is a great tubing mascara 4
Ditto from San Antonio, TX
I have very sparse, straight lashes that do not hold a curl. That's why I've always used waterproof mascaras, they seemed to be the only ones who held a curl. I got tired of the removal process of wp mascaras though, so I decided to try this since it's waterproof but also a tubing mascara. This is great for everyday. It won't give you that false lash effect, but it does a good job of coating your lashes and separating them. They do slightly droop so I just give them a small curl after the mascara and I'm good to go. I make sure to be extra careful and not pull out any lashes in the process. The removal process is where this shines. All you need is some warm water and you will see the mascara come off in little tubes. It's also super easy to remove with just a makeup wipe. Super fast and easy and doesn't leave any black smudges under your eyes. Doesn't flake all day either. I definitely recommend this mascara if you're tired of that waterproof removal process on an everyday basis.
NEW FAVORITE MASCARA!!! :-) 5
Mama Bear from undisclosed
I never bothered trying this before, because it didn't come in waterproof and I need waterproof mascara to be able to hold the curl in my stubborn, straight, hard to curl lashes! I was so excited when I saw that they released a waterproof version. I went out and bought it, and thus far... I am NOT disappointed at all! In fact, I LOVE this mascara SO MUCH!!! I've only had it for a little while, but from the first use, I loved the way that it made my lashes look. It's buildable, so you can really customize how "intense" you want it to be! I only wish they would come out with the waterproof in more colors, as well because I normally wear brown mascara. But now that they have the waterproof, I think I will actually go out and purchase the original version, in brown, as well. And use the waterproof as a base layer to hold my curl and use the brown as a topper and layer on with that. I might even go for the black cherry as well, if I can find it in-store! Point being... this mascara is AMAZING!!! And I hope that Maybelline never discontinues this waterproof version! I will be repurchasing for sure! PLEASE KEEP THIS AROUND!!!!
Why is it sticky???? 2
June from Arizona
Upon first application it looks beautiful, it also holds my curl. However as the day goes on my eyelashes start clumping. They end up looking like literal triangles. The top lashes even get stuck to the bottom eyelashes and it's hard to open my eyes. People have pointed it out too, so it's really noticeable. I really wanted to love this mascara as they truly do look fluffy and long, but my eyelashes end up looking like the triangle anime eyelashes at the end of the day but not in a good way.
Waterproof AND Washable! A+ 5
Angie27 from undisclosed
This is the most innovative mascara on the market and the one I will wear everyday. It is waterproof AND washable, so now you no longer have to choose between having to scrub your eyes out or long wearing mascara.
Everyday hit 4
Starkan from Saint Louis
This mascara has a lot of pros for me. I normally wear L'Oréal voluminous and have both waterproof and regular. I love the wear of a waterproof but I hate how hard it is to take off. This mascara doesn't give the volume that others do, but it does coat lashes well and gives a decent amount of volume and color. Where this mascara shines is that it works as a waterproof, but it really comes off in a snap. It has become my everyday mascara. The brush is wonderful to work with, and if you are pretty quick, you can build up a few coat before it dries. The color of black is a very true black and it is in between a matte and glossy finish when dry. I really like it!
Love it 4
Kate from NY
This is an amazing product gives my lashes a ton of length! It won't budge during rain or shower and is really easy to wash off. No smudging either! The one con is that it doesn't layer well though so put all your coats on before it dries.
Not even slightly waterproof 1
Bmh from South Carolina
Not waterproof!
The world's first washable waterproof mascara 5
Angela from San Francisco
Ladies and gents, the future is here: the world's first washable WATERPROOF mascara. Never worry about heavy rain making your mascara run down your cheeks again when you wear this. I don't know if it will hold up to a dip in the pool, but this thing really will not budge even under heavy shower. This will revolutionize the whole mascara game for the whole industry.I give it 5 stars for the idea and innovation. The brush could be more separating and volumizing, but this is my everyday mascara because I don't want to have to worry about water ruining my mascara!
Waterproof Formula 2
Kelly from Hawaii
I absolutely love Maybelline's waterproof formulas because they hold the curl after I curl my straight Asian lashes. This mascara did NOT do that. One application and my curl went flat. This mascara may be more suitable for those already with a decent curl. This also gave more length than volume. I'll stick with the maybelline rocket mascara in waterproof.
Does not budge 5
Mommymohawk from Indiana
I love the original snapscara and have three of the colors but they do flake if you rub your eyes. This one does not and it still comes off in tubes with warm water. It really is amazing if you want definition and length that will last all day. It doesn't layer great though so get all your coats in in one side before moving to the other eye. Definitely recommend if you want something that is waterproof but still easy to remove and won't damage your lashes.
All time fav 5
#1 fan from Um United States
This mascara is the bestttt no cap
