Rated 4.19 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Best mascara EVER!
I'm not a review writer, but I had to write this review so Maybelline and everyone else will know how amazing this mascara is! I don't wear a lot of make-up; typically just under eye concealer and mascara. I have small eyes and thin, short eyelashes. I've been a Colossal buyer for years, but saw this and decided to give it a try. I work 12+ hour shifts and this mascara stays put...it doesn't flake, smudge, or transfer to my bottom or top eyelids. When I get home, I can easily wipe it off with a make-up remover towelette or simple put my face in the shower stream. I love it and as long as Maybelline makes it, I will NEVER buy another mascara!
Most Helpful Critical Review Great mascara but not for sensitive eyes
I love this tubing mascara-it doesn't clump, but lengthens beautifully, and comes off easily. Unfortunately, the black cherry color gave me a bad allergic reaction; my eyelids turned red and swollen and painful after a few days of using it. I have seen other reviews of customers having reactions to the black cherry version, so perhaps the red pigment is the issue. If you have allergies, I would not buy the black cherry color, and maybe avoid this mascara altogether.
Reviewed by 719 customers Flakes like crazy!
ReptilesandElephants from AZ
The brush is good and it's fairly clump-free. I did have some clumping on my longer outer lashes. 2nd coat was a total clumpfest. Once I separated them they looked good.....for about an hour. Flaked like crazy. I do have oily skin, so that could contribute - but this was over the top. I'll stick with Maybelline's Lash Stiletto for a nice washable option. My all time favorite washable is Touch in Sol Stretchex, but Ulta doesn't carry it for some reason. :(
I would 100% buy this again and again! Amazing!
MJ from Georgia
I almost didn't buy this because of the reviews but so glad I did because it's fantastic. It really comes off as easily as they advertise, which makes it so easy to remove little smudges from skin, too. Goes on clump-free and looks very subtle, perfect for me as a I wear little to no other makeup most of the time. Bought the brown snapscara to be even more subtle.
I hope they never stop making this stuff!!
Courtney from Houston
Started flaking all over the place and getting into my eyes within a couple of hours of application. Will be returning.
DEBSKI08 from GROTON, CT
THIS MASCARA RUINED MY EYELASHES! THEY ARE SPARSE AND THIN NOW! IT CLUMPS AND BREAKS OFF AND MAKES A MESS! WHAT A WASTE OF MONEY AND NOW MY EYES LOOK TIRED ALL THE TIME BECAUSE I HAVE SO FEW LASHES!!!
user27 from undisclosed
I bought the Black Cherry color, hoping for a burgundy to bring out the green in my eyes. The color on the package looks beautiful, but once I put it on the color was completely black. The formula is really good though! It added a lot of length to my already long lashes without clumpy volume. Please make the color brighter!
Debru from New Jersey
As soon as I opened the mascara it flaked from the top. When applying it only adhered on some lashes had to apply multiple coats then it became too thick in some areas not on others. Felt like shelf life was a factor here.
Best mascara! No black eyes
Gi from Nj
The only mascara, out of high end too that I've ever used that doesn't leave black under my eyes! Love it
Would not buy again
Rose from Philadelphia
I bought the burgundy one and was really disappointed. It sort of clumped all my eyelashes together without making them look longer or more voluminous. It's easy to get off while also staying on pretty well (no flaking, for example) but I was expecting a more natural look based on the advertising and product description.
Does nothing for the lashes
Erin from Washington, D.C.
I bought this mascara because I've been wanting to try tubing mascaras; I struggle with regular mascaras smudging under my eyes. I figured I would go with an inexpensive option first to see if I like the tubing technology. First of all, it doesn't smudge. And honestly, this is the only reason for the 2 stars. This is the first mascara I've ever used (and I've tried A LOT) that doesn't smudge even a little under my eyes. So, that's a definite win. HOWEVER, it does absolutely nothing for my lashes other than make them a little darker. It doesn't provide length, volume, or curl. If you're looking to try out a tubing mascara, I'd recommend going with something else.
Lindsay M. from Fallston, MD
I really wanted to like this. I heard a lot of good things about it, so I tried it. It's just nit anything special. I looks like my eyelashes, but a little longer. They don't look thicker or fuller or anything else. The annoying part is that after wearing this for about 10 minutes, I had a black smudged line along my lash line. I have no idea what they were thinking when they made this, because it's not anywhere near as good as the other Maybelline products I have. Hard pass.
NOT what I expected from Maybelline!
mbush525 from Pittsburgh PA
After curling my lashes and applying this mascara, my lashes straightened out, as though it was not waterproof. It also went on rather thickly, making my lashes look clumpy. I waited until it dried, to correct the curl, but my lashes were a mess by then and I just went without ☹
Gwen from Burlington, VT
This mascara runs everywhere for me! If you live somewhere humid or wet, or if you sweat a lot, I would not recommend this. I know it isn't waterproof, but I've used waterproof mascaras that run less in pouring rain than this mascara runs when it's misty.
natasha786 from Islamabad, ISL
This mascara is absolutely amazing. It doesnt wear off and can be easily removed. It makes my lashes look long and voluminous and I truly recommend this to everyone.
cosmetologygal from Asheville,NC
I absolutely love this mascara! I've been wearing it since it came out in black and ultraviolet since my hair was purple for a while. It goes on and stays on well and never has made me look like a raccoon even after sleeping in it (I know that I should wash it off but I don't haha). I now can't find ultra violet anywhere and I'm so sad over it!
Flakes like crazy!
Linn from SC
Had high hopes for this mascara but it flakes like crazy and that makes it unwearable even though the eyelashes looks good right after application.
Bring back the Dark Cherry shade!
Dezzy from Oregon
I bought this mascara specifically because I have hazel eyes and thought the dark cherry color would give my eyes some brightness while looking more natural. The mascara is super lengthening and won't smudge, which I love. I wish they hadn't taken that color out of Ulta! So sad :(
Not a good Mascara
skyler from San Diego
It was not a good mascara to wear was disappointment
best mascara ever!
Cristina85 from Walpole, Massachusetts
this smudge proof mascara is the best I've ever used. It stays on so good and makes my lashes look unbelievable and it's so easy to remove.
I like the look of it👍
Katieohairdesigns from McAllen
So I have a mixed review of this product bc first, I am very picky about mascara and they way it does, how clumping, the applicator brush, how much did the bottom lash run, how much lengthening and volume it has. And I was surprised that I did like the look and all that very much. However washable?? I don't know about that one. I was using micellar water to remove it and I normally never have to apply that twice but that's what I did and there was still darkness left over. But again it comes out really nice when it's on.
Best Mascara I've Ever Used!
kay from Nampa
Absolutely love this product!! out of all the mascaras i've tried this is by far the best one! it doesn't go on clumpy or uneven, it's smooth and the color is bright and beautiful!!
I really don't like this mascara.
Lms17965 from Ohio
Mainly for the sheer fact that it gets very clumpy especially the waterproof version. I was not impressed I was hoping for it to be more of a curl and more of a lift. I didn't get that.
MJ from Pittsburgh PA
I use it every day. Took a chance because I never used this type before. Live it.
No raccoon eyes for me
Lucy Ladbug from Georgia
I love this mascara b/c it does not transfer under my eyes. The only product I've found in all these years to not do so. It gets really gummy after a month or two and clumps up badly. However, I just purchase a new tube and am back in business...
LOVE this mascara
Kearnie from Wash State
I love I can change up colors to match outfits or colors I'm teaching my preschoolers.
Love This Product
Lesley65 from Pasadena, TX
I use this product daily and I love it.