Rated 3.95 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review most favourite lip liners!!
NYX pencil lip liners are my absolute favourite. affordable yet so smooth, pigmented, and very long-lasting! also love supporting a cruelty-free brand. i see in previous reviews that there's a lot of confusion/disappointment regarding how one should sharpen them. the slide on lip pencils are not retractable, but rather have a plastic casing as opposed to the conventional wooden lip pencil. i heard NYX sells a sharpener specifically made for this purpose but i personally use the wet 'n' wild dual pencil sharpener and it works just fine (: hope this helps! NYX lip pencils will forever be my go-to!
Most Helpful Critical Review Defective - Can't Twist - Can't Sharpen
I bought the shade SLLP24 "Knock em Red" online. When I read other comments saying they don't know how to sharpen their lip pencil I thought they were dumb. Well, it just happened to me! I cannot sharpen mine. I cannot twist it up either because it's not made to be a twist-up. There is no way to sharpen because it's made out of plastic. I have another shade in SLLP02 "Bedrose" that I purchased about a year ago and I'm able to sharpen it. Please view the photos I included. "Knock em Red" is a true red. Appears long lasting. I haven't worn it yet besides swatching on my hand. I was too flabbergasted by the defect to try it on my lips before the review. I dislike the hassles of returning/exchanging. I just wanted to let other buyers out there to be aware if they are on same boat as me. You are not dumb! It's defective.
Reviewed by 2831 customers Never buy
Alexi from Saginaw MI
I was extremely disappointed after someone recommended this in the store just to find out it doesn't stay in place long at all. I was looking for a creamy brown eyeliner and learned THIS ONE is not it.
Love the color!
Lorimom from Atlanta, GA
Love this color! Nice blues are so hard to find! Please don't discontinue this color! Not too shiny, no glitter, but not too mat either. Goes on smoothly and lasts. Great price. Will definitely buy again!
Wouldn't buy this product again...
PatA from PA
Color is very muted. Very understated.
Not that Great
Sana from El Paso, Texas
The color is very vivid great however did not last all day, not long day wear so will not be buying again.
Idea, New Invention called a Pencil Sharpener!!
Makeup addicted Red Head from Steuben County
I received this pencil in a subscription box, the black brown shade. Perfect for what I like when I don't want black or colored liners. It works well, states all day in my water line which is the purpose I use eyepencils for.
I was floored by a few of the reviews saying they couldn't twist up more product, so they only received a tiny amount of product? Not to be a JERK but if they don't know that you can sharpen a pencil with that thing they call a pencil sharpener maybe its too dangerous to let them have any kind of a pencil or sharp object. Stay out of the makeup store!!!
Any way it's just so crazy, some of the reviews I read on here! Definitely a place to go if you want to laugh or just be amazed, yeah I'll put it that way. no shade meant!!
love the pencil.
By the way, they work great but you will need a PENCIL SHARPENER!!!
I would buy this product again!
Wanda the crafter from Georgetown Ky
Love the colors and easy to apply.
Fern from CA
It's NYX, they're a great brand! The eyeliner is pretty inexpensive so you can buy a few at a time, they don't crumble on you, and still look good at the end of the night.
NYX eyeliner some are made in Germany great product
Lid from Massachusetts
I would buy this again and again
Lori P from Fort Lauderdale, FL
I use this color every day. I'm a hair colorist and beauty is important to me. This color lasts all day. Love it
Not pigmented at all, barely shows
tph from Miami, fl
product is awful, you can't see it on your skin no matter how much you layer or go over it.
Used once and ordered a back up already!
ChiChiR from Louisiana
I bought the shade black brown and it's the perfect shade alternative to black and it isn't too brown. I used it once and knew I'd found the perfect shade so I ordered another one. It's a real wooden pencil, not that weird plastic-wood junk that's hard to sharpen. Sharpens easily to a fine point. Applies easily and lasts well.
Love this pencil!
Lorimom from Atlanta, GA
Love this pencil. Not too shiny, not too mat. Nice color. Goes on easily and stays on.
Miss Jeanne from Lewiston, Maine
The white has no pigmentation it seems. I apply it to the waterline and it isn't there. It doesn't build up, just smudges what little applies. It also straight up disappears if you manage to get some on. Won't be buying again.
Not the best but gets the job done
cookies from Dallas
I got this in the shade dark brown as I wanted a more casual daily use liner that wasn't as bold as liquid liners. This definitely met that expectation. However, buyer beware: this liner wipes away with the lightest touch. The application was alright, but I do wish the texture was more creamy so it could glide on. There is definitely some tugging with this formula.
I wouldn't buy again, but this isn't horrible either for the price.
Bedrose color too pink.
Pam from Maumee, oh
I love these lip liners but they no longer carry the color nude pink. I tried bedrose but it was too pink. Exchanged for allure which I liked. Allure is more of a neutral nude.
Sam from Austin, Texas
I was so looking forward to using the baby blue color for a change in look I was going for but was immediately disappointed. It was practically nonexistent when I would add it to my waterline. I tried it out on the back of my hand to see if it possibly needed a sturdier base to get the color going, but it wiped off so easily! The color looked so promising but the formula is just not it. Def returning and will not be repurchasing.
Color Me Perfect!
Rozzi from MD
Feels great applying to lips! Looks great with Matte lipsticks, gloss or alone.
I would never buy this product again!
Diana from Yuba City, Ca
I was very disappointed with this product. I was told by an Ulta sales associate that I was buying a retractable lip liner. So obviously I thought that as soon as the lip liner product was finished, I'd be able to bring up more lip liner product, by twisting the bottom of the lip liner, and try to push up more of the lip liner product to come out. I assumed retractable means to push in and out. Well, I twisted the bottom of the lip liner and no more lip product came out! I spent 8 dollars for only a tiny piece of lip liner product? I will never buy this product again. I wanted to go back to Ulta and tell them I wanted my money back, but somehow, I lost my receipt.
I would NOT buy this product again.
Pam from Morehead City, NC
I tried, as well as my daughters, to use this item. The actual liner does not advance up from tub making this product useless and a waste of money.
Love the color
mindy from NC
I love the color. The ease with which the liner went in with was a amazing. I was sweating a lot while wearing it the first time and it didn't go anywhere.
Susie from Dyersburg Tn
Used this for years, glides on easily & looks great
S.H. from California
The pencil is great- creamy and smooth and easy to use. But the color Bedrose on the website looks like a nude brown but when I got it in person it's a bright pink :/ have to exchange.
first i've tried
helen from miami do
it's amazing! wish it showed more but it is still good.
One of my favorite lip pencils!
BR from Idaho
My go to color is bedrose and I absolutely love it! I have repurchased it and have purchased other colors! Give it a shot :)
Not a good eyeliner
Amber from Allen, tx
It is hard to apply because it is not soft and it's not noticeable either.