Rated 3.95 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review most favourite lip liners!!
NYX pencil lip liners are my absolute favourite. affordable yet so smooth, pigmented, and very long-lasting! also love supporting a cruelty-free brand. i see in previous reviews that there's a lot of confusion/disappointment regarding how one should sharpen them. the slide on lip pencils are not retractable, but rather have a plastic casing as opposed to the conventional wooden lip pencil. i heard NYX sells a sharpener specifically made for this purpose but i personally use the wet 'n' wild dual pencil sharpener and it works just fine (: hope this helps! NYX lip pencils will forever be my go-to!
Most Helpful Critical Review These were a hit or...
These were a hit or miss for me. Out of the four that I purchased two were excellent and two were horrible. I got Taupe to use for my brows and it is the perfect match, blends like a dream and makes it super easy to fill in sparse areas. Yellow has great color payoff. However the Sky Glitter and Silver Glitter are just plain awful. The points break off immediately upon contact, even with the barest touch. I also found them difficult to sharpen. I'm willing to try many of the other colors though I'll hesitate before trying another of the glittery ones.
Reviewed by 2869 customers Meh
Sarah from Arizona
It is very whatever. It's not terrible but it certainly isn't show-stopping. I eventually started using it on my brows instead of my lids.
Heidikin from Garland. TX
I used it for an everyday look. Both waterline and upper lid
I like it ...color is great ...
Brenda from Naples FL
Like it, great color but it doesn't apply very dark, have to keep applying to get a darker line...but other than that it's great...would buy again 🙂
I wouldn't buy it again.
Jayymie from Los Angeles
I wanted to use this eyeliner to brighten up my eyes by applying it on my waterline but it's not as opaque. It's pretty transparent with a tiny hint of color. I tried going over my waterline many times but it didn't make a difference.
and I have!
Pinky from Stafford Va
I love this pencil, and have only been able to find it in the color I want (dark green) at ULTA!
Great lip liner
Jax from San Antonio, tx
Best with a nude lip, and a gloss.
Not Waterline Friendly
Echo from Springfield, OR
The only color payoff I got on my waterline was what stuck to the base of my lashes. I'm greatly disappointed because I was looking forward to the blues and greens. Maybe there will be better payoff on the lid?
Nice light brown color
Happy camper from Los Angeles, CA
I generally wear a pretty natural look, so I bought this in light brown and taupe. The light brown is exactly what I was looking for--a softer, subtle shade that doesn't make my eyes pop too much. Since it was BOGO 50%, I also got the taupe. Would not recommend the taupe because the color is too muted. I wear this on my upper lid and don't notice any fading
YES YOU CAN SHARPEN IT!
KittenCake from AZ
MY GOD HOW DENSE ARE SOME PEOPLE? You can TOTALLY sharpen this and any other LIP OR EYE PENCIL WITH A SHARPENER! WOWEE WHAT A CONCEPT! This is NON RETRACTABLE YOU NEED A PENCIL SHARPENER HELLO!
Great lip pencil! Works every bit as good as Urban Decay at less than half price! I have a few! Bed rose is a bit more pink than it shows here but it's lovely.
Bea from Louisiana
Will never stop buying this!
Matsunme from Portland, MI
I love this color fory brown eyes. It enhances them perfectly while not overpowering them. A color I can wear everyday and still look amazing.
Ummm...is it just me?
Amy from IL
Ummmm...Am I supposed to be able to twist this to use more than just he amount exposed on the tip? My pencil must be defective or something. I love the color, but taking it back if all I can use is .5% of the product.
S from Idaho
I was excited to try this product as I've used the retractable eyeliner so I was hoping this would be just as good but was left very disappointed. Runs too much under my eyes right after putting it on. Wears off easily after a few hours or less.
Just what I wanted
Dot from Sacramento, California
I have a lot of blue in my hazel eyes and wanted a liner with just a hint of blue that would brighten my eyes. Y using this on my waterline it it works great.
Mjungewaelter from Gulf Breeze, FL
Nude suede shoes is the perfect my lips but better shade on me! The formula is so comfortable, definitely my favorite liner at the moment
Color was muted but cute overall
Adrienne from Iowa
I used it for winged liner but the color was unfortunately too muted for that. Could definitely be used for waterline but not strong enough for much else
not a fan
msh from san diego
I have to press really hard to get any color payoff on the lid and get no color payoff on the waterline.
Good not great
local girl from Vancouver, WA
I love this brand, love the Browns and blacks, didn't realize this was so metallic and that it would be so much softer to put on. It did stay on all day though, through work and the gym.
Super creamy and pigmented
I.E.SuzyQ from Inland Empire
This lip pencil is better than NYX regular lip pencils.
Love the color.
BA from Cleveland, Ohio
I had been using an Estee Lauder pencil this color which was discontinued. I looked for a year before I found this one. I should have gone to Ulta Beauty first!
no.. just no.
mirabelle from cali
i really wanted a subtle eyeliner look and this is not it. the pigmentation is not great at all, and if i wear this for literally an hour it goes away.
Matches my lipstick perfectly
Jonnyd from Mesa, Arizona
NYC is my favorite eyeliner pencil to buy
blushy from Levittown PA
My favorite eyeliner pencil are these hands down. Goes on so nice without pulling or scratching underneath my eye...
Gorgeous shade & gorgeous formula—
Sam Z. from TX
This reminds me a lot of the Kylie Lip Liners in both formula & type of packaging! Very creamy and not drying. Long lasting for a lip liner imo. & they have a variety of shades!! Allie Glines on YouTube raves about this one in particular and I now can totally see why! Really nice neutral that could be used daily or for more special occasions.
I LOVE IT!
Areli.z from Victorville Ca
Okay NEVER ever have I tried such Amazing lip liner, I have tried The mac lip liner Like 3 Times and It was horrible lasted Only 4 Hours, This Nyx Lip liner is My favorite after one use of it I LOVE IT!, It Last Me Literally morning to night; All Day Long, for longitivity I use it Under the Mac Retro Matte liquid lipstick. BEST COMBINATION ever. When I say it's waterproof, It is Literally went swimming with it, I eat with it, Drink water and stuff, and STILL LAST ME ALL DAY LONG. I recommend it, You just use a sharpener for lip liners to keep it sharpened, When I mean it lasts all day I mean it, If you use it correctly.