Rated 3.94 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review most favourite lip liners!!
NYX pencil lip liners are my absolute favourite. affordable yet so smooth, pigmented, and very long-lasting! also love supporting a cruelty-free brand. i see in previous reviews that there's a lot of confusion/disappointment regarding how one should sharpen them. the slide on lip pencils are not retractable, but rather have a plastic casing as opposed to the conventional wooden lip pencil. i heard NYX sells a sharpener specifically made for this purpose but i personally use the wet 'n' wild dual pencil sharpener and it works just fine (: hope this helps! NYX lip pencils will forever be my go-to!
Most Helpful Critical Review These were a hit or...
These were a hit or miss for me. Out of the four that I purchased two were excellent and two were horrible. I got Taupe to use for my brows and it is the perfect match, blends like a dream and makes it super easy to fill in sparse areas. Yellow has great color payoff. However the Sky Glitter and Silver Glitter are just plain awful. The points break off immediately upon contact, even with the barest touch. I also found them difficult to sharpen. I'm willing to try many of the other colors though I'll hesitate before trying another of the glittery ones.
Reviewed by 2927 customers great
gigi from gardena ave
it think the white one is preety good but it doesn't realy show and the black on is perfect! give this a try
Melissa from CT
I am always looking for a new shade of green eyeliner. I was pleasantly surprised that the color matches the packaging exactly and looks really good.
TeresaH from Ft Myers, FL
Just tried this NYX eyeliner in blue. It goes on easily seems to stay put and the price is very reasonable. I will be buying other colors soon.
Renee from Dallas, TX
The formula is okay. It glides on easily but I prefer their regular lip pencil, personally. And this color was WAY too light for me and I'm paler than pale.
New Routine Staple
rroofe from Batesville, AR
I bought this based in Nude Suede Shoes on Allie Glines reviews and have not been disappointed. I've already repurchased. It's become a regular staple in my routine and will repurchase again once needed. It lasts for a good length, goes on smooth, and looks great.
Babs from San Jose, CA
I love this color, just wish there was more on stock, sells quickly.
LIP. LINER. Read it with me...Lip Liner
SOVIXEN from Texas
I have used this product for over 7 years. SEVEN! I understand the strange ratings about it going on eyes. It was advertised as a multi use pencil in stores for a long time. I even bought it in gold and purple to use on the eyes 6 years ago. It goes on your, read it with me, LIPS. I use the Urban Cafe as a liner and although the color is phenomenal and unlike any other, it only last about 1 hour under lipstick or gloss, unless you over use and layer it. Lasts about 2 hours alone (talking, smiling, sip some coffee or eat? Forget about it. Gone). Looking for a dupe of higher quality.
Colors are off
Sandra from Salt lake city, utah
The texture is nice, but be careful ordering online, because the colors are very off from what is shown. Nude suede shoes is very bubblegum pink.
I do buy this pencil again & again!
Susie from Dyersburg tn
Used this for years, perfect color, goes on easily & economical! Very unhappy when it's sold out!
This is lip liner
Laur from Philly
This is absolutely lip liner. It literally says so in the description. Glides on well. Was easy to sharpen. Confused about the discourse in this review section
Never ordering this again
Dajah from Dallas Tx
Gave me a broke one does slide up
Perfect Nude - Creamy and stays all day!
Amber from Jonesboro, AR
Great product. The cap was unreal to try to get off.... but once it did - this is the best lip liner I have tried. The color is gorgeous - just a hint of pink! Love it!!!
Verdict isn't totally out
Aimee from Fort Lauderdale
I got this hoping it would be a brow pencil that could be powdered down in a grey or pale charcoal as the color of the pencil and the color of the actual painted sample showed it was pale and almost soft and may even be metallic... NO... I could have been a panda bear or a member of kiss. Didn't work for my plans but
This def could work for someone with black hair. Way too dark for me. For the price it's a no brainer.
It did glide and apply with ease. Would def buy again and try in another shade
Cam is dumb. This is a eye liner not lip liner.
Slayer from Los Angeles
Dummy. Learn to read.
I would not buy this product again.
June from Michigan City
Pencil needed to outline my lips to define.
THIS IS A LIP LINER
Cam from Omaha
i went to review this product and saw yall reviewing this as an eyeliner???? Babes...... its a LIP... LINER.... AS IN IT GOES ON UR LIPS.
anyways yeah it's nice as a lip liner it glides on nice and has good pigment!! not super long lasting though tbh
Delaine from Ojai CA
Nice color. I can apply this without pressing hard. No tugging. I will get more colors.
would not buy again
carla from illinois
great color but can't sharpen and lead was was down in pencil not good product
Sucks don't go on eyes good you can barely see
Kim from Dayton nv
Feels like crayola
Karen from IL
Just open it and feels very dry and inconsistent color. I've bought other NYX eyeliners and have been okay this is just not good
Love color but doesn't last
Michelle from COOKVILLE TN
The liner wore off by time I got to my work 30 mins later. Awesome color when first applied
Perfect for a light day look
Katie from Chicago, IL
I bought this for water line use and to smug out for a pop of color that isnt too intense. It does go on lighter then i expected, but the champagne color is like a highlighter for the eyes. It makes my eyes pop and is easy to create a smugged out look. I love it!
Sydney from Columbus
I absolutely love the colors. I got sapphire and emerald city, both of which look wonderful on my green eyes. However, the formula smears a lot. I have hooded eyelids so I end up looking like I'm wearing light blue or green eyeshadow. I also think the formula fades quickly, but that's probably due to the smearing. In order to get deeper colors you have to apply more but that's not too bad.
Nella from New york
I purchased the white one it makes me look so awake im obsessed! Highly recommended
My new go-to eyeliner.
Jen B from Yorktown, VA
I'm always on the look out for a pencil eyeliner that will STAY ON. I'm very pleased with the look and long-wear of this eyeliner.