Product Reviews Rated 4.2 out of 5 stars
1646 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review I love these! Theses are by far my favorite eyeliner pencils. They're super soft, pigmented, don't crumble when I use them, and one they set, they SET. I have no eyelid transfer with them and they even do a pretty good job of staying put in my waterline, which is tricky. So far I have them in black, silver, both purples, turquoise, blue, both greens, and bronze and I honestly would like to collect all of them!
Most Helpful Critical Review Eh I bought this product sometime in the summertime and when I received them I was excited to use them. However when I tried to use them, they did not glide on smoothly and instead tugged on my eyelids. I also had to go over it multiple times to get the color that was advertised. Overall, I enjoyed the coloring but I would not purchase again, unless I knew the product would work as advertised.
Reviewed by 1646 customers Can't love withoit 5
Rocky Squirrel from American Fork, UT
I love this eyeliner. I have worn it every day since buying it. It doesn't fade and when I take it off at night it is still amazing looking after a long day.
Yes 5
Neffie from West Palm Beach
Very soft and stays all day
If I could give it no stars I would. 1
Crys from Elkhart Indiana
I like the color of it. Wish I could have actually used it.
Returning it 2
danatoo from Florida
This is not a smooth eyeliner, it doesn't give a smooth line, or take to smudging well. Feels cheaply made, and discount store quality.
Glides like creamy liner. It is perfect! 5
Gigi from Arkansas
Glides on perfectly. Great price!
This is where it's at for mature skin!! 5
BossBrunette from Indiana
This eyeliner is a great dupe (maybe even better) for UD 24/7 glide-on pencil or EL stay in place pencil! NYX's version glides on like butter, just like the more expensive versions, which is the most important quality I look for in eyeliners on my 42 year old skin! I do not have to tug, or "stretch" out my eyelid any at all!!! I wish it was a little more long lasting like the EL version is, but i'm willing to sacrifice longevity for one that glides as smooth as this formula does!!
Beautiful 5
Kryssie from Phoenix, AZ
I finally found a bright gold that I wanted!
Glides On 5
Angel85 from Bradenton, FL
Love to make your eye's pop? This is what you want! Rich, and bold colors!!!!! I do recommend! Cause I know I love to make my eye's beautiful and make a statement. These are better then the pencils!!!!!! I am doing a huge switch! I wasn't sure I was gonna like these but when I got home and tried the black one on, I was I fell in love!!!!!! Just one gliding movement on my eye and bam! Not like the pencils where you have to go back and forth getting it on. This was just one stroke for me to put on! Try it! I'm gonna see if I can get the rest of the color!!!!!
I would not buy again 1
Marsha from NJ
I used to tightline my eyes, but color disappeared after a few hours
Love these 5
None from Texas
I have in 4 colors and love them
Beautiful 5
None from Texas
Great, creamy, last color is beautiful
Bold color stays on 5
Vickie from Victorville
Loved this eyeliner. I was using an eyeliner that smudged under my eye and the corners of my eyes would have a glop of eyeliner after an hour! This eyeliner stays in place for hours. It's bold and works great! Glides on smooth and lives up to that super long name.
My favorite eyeliner of all time! 5
Hazel-eyed woman from Macomb, Michigan
This is my favorite eyeliner. I have hazel eyes and the metallic bronze with black really makes my green and gold tones pop. I get numerous compliments on my eyes when I wear this combination. The metallic bronze is the perfect shade and I haven't found a comparable version with any other brand or eyeliner type.
Perfect for wearing contacts 5
Momof3 from Newport News, Va
This is the only eye liner that I can use with my contacts. All others have caused irritation.
awesome 5
patty from michigan
As a contact wearer, Ive finally found an eyeliner that I can wear on my waterline!! It doesnt smudge or transfer onto my contact lenses!
Totally need more of these wyeliners 5
Lisa from Vernon Hills
Great color need more very nice application!
I would buy this product again. 5
Ulta Luver from Pine, CO
I bought this for my eyebrows to match my hair since they are so hard to die and it matches my hair perfectly. With all the different shades to chose from. I also bought the white and use as an eyeliner and it works amazing.. I love NYX slide on pencils..they work exactly as they say!!!
My go to eyeliner! 5
Robin from CA
This is now my favorite pencil eye liner. I get so many compliments on the color. I have brown eyes and want them to pop, and this does the trick. I don't wear a ton of makeup, but this is a must have. I used to buy a more expensive brand that had the purple liner, but the color wasn't as vibrant.
I would buy this product again 5
Bg from Dalton ga
Great eyeliner
Lasts all day even with tears 5
Redhead from San lorenzo ca
Awesome color...lasts and doesnt bleed
Love Nyx Products 5
Steph from Philadelphia, Pa
Love Nyx products and eye pencil saves me after I take my lashes off
Not worth the money 2
cnguyen1 from texas
Do not use this to tightline!!! It caked up on my bottom lashes and made them look clumpy, not pigmented either
Worked only 2 days, 1
becky from lewiston idaho
Do not buy it
long lasting and pigmented as frick 5
chaosky from roseville
this eyeliner is IT
No 3
Lyn from Portland tn
This product smeared in a later day. I was hoping it will stay better.. I love the that it's easy to apply and the color is awesome but it won't stick well.
