Rated 4.2 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review I love these!
Theses are by far my favorite eyeliner pencils. They're super soft, pigmented, don't crumble when I use them, and one they set, they SET. I have no eyelid transfer with them and they even do a pretty good job of staying put in my waterline, which is tricky. So far I have them in black, silver, both purples, turquoise, blue, both greens, and bronze and I honestly would like to collect all of them!
Most Helpful Critical Review Eh
I bought this product sometime in the summertime and when I received them I was excited to use them. However when I tried to use them, they did not glide on smoothly and instead tugged on my eyelids. I also had to go over it multiple times to get the color that was advertised. Overall, I enjoyed the coloring but I would not purchase again, unless I knew the product would work as advertised.
Reviewed by 1618 customers Bold color stays on
Vickie from Victorville
Loved this eyeliner. I was using an eyeliner that smudged under my eye and the corners of my eyes would have a glop of eyeliner after an hour! This eyeliner stays in place for hours. It's bold and works great! Glides on smooth and lives up to that super long name.
My favorite eyeliner of all time!
Hazel-eyed woman from Macomb, Michigan
This is my favorite eyeliner. I have hazel eyes and the metallic bronze with black really makes my green and gold tones pop. I get numerous compliments on my eyes when I wear this combination. The metallic bronze is the perfect shade and I haven't found a comparable version with any other brand or eyeliner type.
Perfect for wearing contacts
Momof3 from Newport News, Va
This is the only eye liner that I can use with my contacts. All others have caused irritation.
patty from michigan
As a contact wearer, Ive finally found an eyeliner that I can wear on my waterline!! It doesnt smudge or transfer onto my contact lenses!
Totally need more of these wyeliners
Lisa from Vernon Hills
Great color need more very nice application!
I would buy this product again.
Ulta Luver from Pine, CO
I bought this for my eyebrows to match my hair since they are so hard to die and it matches my hair perfectly. With all the different shades to chose from. I also bought the white and use as an eyeliner and it works amazing.. I love NYX slide on pencils..they work exactly as they say!!!
My go to eyeliner!
Robin from CA
This is now my favorite pencil eye liner. I get so many compliments on the color. I have brown eyes and want them to pop, and this does the trick. I don't wear a ton of makeup, but this is a must have. I used to buy a more expensive brand that had the purple liner, but the color wasn't as vibrant.
I would buy this product again
Bg from Dalton ga
Lasts all day even with tears
Redhead from San lorenzo ca
Awesome color...lasts and doesnt bleed
Love Nyx Products
Steph from Philadelphia, Pa
Love Nyx products and eye pencil saves me after I take my lashes off
Not worth the money
cnguyen1 from texas
Do not use this to tightline!!! It caked up on my bottom lashes and made them look clumpy, not pigmented either
Worked only 2 days,
becky from lewiston idaho
Do not buy it
long lasting and pigmented as frick
chaosky from roseville
this eyeliner is IT
Lyn from Portland tn
This product smeared in a later day. I was hoping it will stay better.. I love the that it's easy to apply and the color is awesome but it won't stick well.
Easy to glide on
Elmer27 from Santa Maria, CA
I enjoy the variety of colors and the colors are so vivid.
This product was extremely disappointing.
Kat from Lakewood, CO
This product was extremely disappointing. I was only able to use it a few times as it would not twist up for continued use. It was not waterproof as stated. This eyeliner never stayed for long. What a waste of money!
My Favorite Eyeliner
Leah from Clearwater, FL
I have tried nearly every eyeliner out there and this remain my favorite non-liquid liner. Goes on so smooth and gives a nice clean line of super pigmented color.
Great color and stays in place
IndieEnthusiast2020 from Milwaukee, WI
Beautiful, creamy color that goes on easily and has serious lasting power.
Didnt recieve my order poor service
Ashley from Brownsville texas
No ítem was delivered
Smudges soooo fast
Kate from Indiana
I bought this as a waterline eyeliner. It stayed on for all of 4 hours before it all smudged in the corners and disappeared on my lash line. The only good thing about it is that it went on super easily but it didn't stay on for long at all :(
Loved this Product!!! Want more colors now!
Hoya_ur_Esty from Chicago
Product is true to color! Has a shimmer! Great accessory to your Covid masks!
Learning Makeup from North Carolina
I really did not like this liner. It crumbled as I tried to apply it. Just to get a basic line took multiple layers. What's worse ,with the consistency , soft and creamy, of the pencil I assumed that it had a retractable function. The bottom even twisted but the product didn't budge. I found out later that it was meant to be sharpened. I can only imagine the pain that would have been to try to sharpen something that texture. Nevertheless, it was returned.
I would buy this product again
Nique from New York
Best Pencil Liner!
Nelie from South Gate
I stopped wearing liner because it always smudges and I look like a raccoon. I always emphasized on my lips, but seeing as we must wear a mask to be safe, I wanted to emphasize my eyes. For me, it's go big or go home. I wanted bright colors and this one popped out to me. It didn't smudge or smear at all. Stayed on all day. I loved it so much I bought a second color the next day.
mel from boston
It took a pair of pliers to even get the cap off. I finally opened it and the pigment was all broken up, and the tip was broken off. Straight to the garbage!