Product Reviews Rated 3.75 out of 5 stars
165 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Best Pencil EVER! I have tried so many different brands of brow pencil, and brow powder, and other brow products. None have ever been remotely close to the correct color for my brows. I have strawberry blonde hair but my brows are much lighter. I bought this in Taupe and it's literally an amazing natural match. I took a photo of my brows done with zero makeup on the rest of my face.
Most Helpful Critical Review Disapointed by shipping The product itself is a good product. I think I would've like the small shape of the pencil even if I'm used to a round version with other brands. I really wished I would have been able to replace these other pencil with the Kat Von D version but every time I used them they would break even when applying a lighter pressure. Very dissapointed as I was looking for vegan/non tested on animal replacement for other brand. One of my pencil lasted me 2 weeks...
Reviewed by 165 customers Dry and crumbly 1
Mikaela from Sacramento
Don't buy this unless you want your pencil to almost slice your eyebrow because it's so dry and crumble before your own eyes. Hard pass
Great product 5
NursePierce from Southern Illinois
I really like this. It's my go to for now.
In love with this brow pencil 5
SyLu from undisclosed
I was thinking in doing microblading until I bought this brow pencil. I love it!!!!!! Love that the lines looks like hair and my brows look so natural. Definitely I recommend it!
Meh 2
Amberrc from MD
I got this as a blond for lighter more natural brows but it is really really light. But I think overall it's the hardness of the pencil that is the problem. If it was as softer crayon the light color would gently apply and I think look good. This feels like I'm running an actual lead pencil on my brows and I have to push hard to see any color (and the pencil end will snap off lol). I think I will pass on this one. But if a soft crayon could be developed I would definitely be interested .
Not bad 4
Sara from Indiana
It's good, but formula could be better
Would recommend. 5
BrittanyL from undisclosed
Favorite brow pencil! I enjoy the fine application.
Brow pencil 4
Monica C from Bakersfield, California
Easy to use pencil that worked perfectly with the brow pomade
good pencil 5
Lee P from New Orleans
It is a hard pencil, that provides a realistic looking brow fill.
Best brow pencil 5
Alyaa from Bahrain
Very easy to draw eyebrows with it's so blended nice texture
Not bad, but average. Color description is wrong. 4
Denise1 from undisclosed
Since I have very dark brown hair with some red strands at the end, I followed the color description and bought "dark brown". But it came out a very medium brown color. It's not dark enough, and it's quite obvious on my eyebrows. It probably would have been better with black.
Perfect Brows, Here I Come! 5
spookyghost from undisclosed
Everything about this pencil is perfect. I love the tone, the consistency, and the longevity. it's easy to apply and creates very natural looking brows
Could be better 3
Selene from undisclosed
Love the way its shaped to make fine strokes, a little hard to paint with tho.
Almost perfect 4
AliciaOD from Green Bay, WI
I really like the design and feel of the pencil. The product looks nice on the skin and has a fine natural shape. My only reason I can't give it a 5 is because upon the first use, and I've used many products like this before so I know not to extend it too high, the tip broke while I was using. I'm sad because I like using it. I know only a little came off, but it's something to note.
Favorite brow product 5
Makeup lover11 from undisclosed
My fave brow product ever! The color matches my brow hairs perfectly and the pencil will literally last forever!
Brow pencil 5
Becket Dana from undisclosed
Lasts all day, easy to apply, very natural looking!!
WOW it's perfect 5
HarlowX14 from Sacramento California
This is The ONLY brow pencil I'll ever use!!! I'll never use another!
Not good 1
Not good from undisclosed
Pencil was too dry. It scraped my skin when trying to use on eyebrows
Dry and hard 1
Angel from Florida
Only works on paper. It just kept breaking off. Tried to warm it and it did not improve. Waste of money.
In love with this product 5
mapi from PR
This brow pencil is my #1 go to brow product. Very pigmented and easy to use. perfect for sculpting fine detailed brows and it stays on all day.
Best! 5
Jessssica from Arizona
Honestly in love with this one. Very small and precise liner
Precision but expensive 3
Tiffany from AZ
Way too little product for the amount paid
Love! 5
Amarie from Brighton
Perfect!
Amazing I love it 5
Nelly92 from Indiana
Amazing! Absolutely love it! I just wish it was thinner for better precision but it's great!
Stick to the brow pomade. 1
Erin Rose from Midlothian, IL
This pencil was so hard and dry it almost impossible to use. Not sure if the one I received was just old/ dried out but it's not good. Don't waste your money.
GOAT brow pencil! 5
Capt Bringdown from Queens, NY
I've tried a few different brow pencils, and what makes Signature Brow superior is: 1. Tiny tip, perfect for precision 2. Formula, not too soft (no gross waxy buildup if i go overboard) or too hard 3. The color is perfect for my black hair! Neutral undertones, without looking dark brown or cool grey.
