Product Reviews Rated 2.84 out of 5 stars
182 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Bring back original compacts! Not sure why jane Iredale has decided to switch this compact for a cheaper, larger, plastic version but the original version needs to be brought back. I received the new version as part of a promotion and within a week threw it away after it cracked. It doesn't compair to the original. Thank goodness I have a few of the original ones left. I've also noticed, all the other products including eye shadow, blush etc...have been switched to the new plastic version. Very disappointing as I have used this product line for years. Please bring the original ones back!
Most Helpful Critical Review Should've kept the old compact I've been using this product for about 10 years. The new compact is not good quality. Prior to the plastic compact there was a nice metal compact. Heavy duty and long lasting. After a few months the new compact looks awful and worn not to mention the powder itself breaks inside very easily.The makeup itself is wonderful however for the price point you would think they would offer a compact case that's efficient and durable, not plastic.
Reviewed by 182 customers Miss the old one 1
Drsweber from IL
I've been using this product for over 15 years. I'm very disappointed that the compact has been changed over to plastic. I very much dislike it. Cheaply made doesn't stay shut to last even the first powder put in it. The old was was 100x's better. Please bring it back!
Great coverage 5
Collette from Pittsburgh
I've been using the refillable compact for the past 2 weeks. The powder is so light, offering great coverage without the dryness that usually comes with using a powder. The application puff is just right. I apply the powder after the moisturizer in the AM. The coverage lasts all day, even under a mask, and is easy to remove at the end of the day. So glad I discovered this product!
Slim, Lightweight, scratches easily 3
Becky W from Virginia
The only downside to this compact is that it scratches very easily, and they don't provide the little plastic protective slip for inside anymore (to keep the thin round makeup pad from rubbing the pressed powder all the time - this wears it down faster, and each time I open it dust poufs out). After 2 years, I have to buy another of these plastic ones because it looks so scratched and worn-looking, it looked dirty. I had the same metal compact from 2002 - 2018, and the outside looked fine, except for light scratches. The only reason I replaced it with this plastic one was that the inside mirror had finally antiqued to where it was hard to see. Miss the metal one, but this is fine. For the quality though, I feel it should be less expensive, since it seems to need replacing every few years.
lasts forever 5
mls13 from undisclosed
I've been using my JI compact for years. It still looks like new.
not the best quality 3
susanjgd from okeana oh
Pretty color but it seems to be cheap plastic and I imagine the finish will wear off. Surprising given the cost. Wish it were metal and higher quality but needed this brand to fit the refill.
Love the product 5
Sheila from Palm beach fl
This is only my second powder
The first one lasted so long
Also easy to navigate website and speedy delivery
They are plastic 2
Teresa from Salem, Alabama
They are plastic and do not hold up well, they scratch/scar easily. I do not understand why they quit putting the little slip and covers over the cases like in the past several years or so ago. I really miss that and I would much rather have metal than plastic as well
durability is lacking 3
Sherry 56 from Holland MI
I am giving this 3 stars because it is attractive and refillable, but by the time I wanted to refill it for the 3rd time the push button no longer worked to be able to close it again. Since this is purchased separately I would expect it to be more durable.
durability is lacking 3
Sherry 56 from Holland MI
I am giving this 3 stars because it is attractive and refillable, but by the time I wanted to refill it for the 3rd time the push button no longer worked to be able to close it again. Since this is purchased separately I would expect it to be more durable.
Where do you keep your applicator 3
Dina from Boston
This does not seem very convenient because there is no place to keep your puff or brush. Also, people have been asking you to bring back the metal one for YEARS!!!
Where do you keep your applicator 3
Dina from Boston
This does not seem very convenient because there is no place to keep your puff or brush. Also, people have been asking you to bring back the metal one for YEARS!!!
Please bring back the metal compact! 1
EE43 from Florida
I have used Jane Iredale products for over 15 years. I am now accessing my pressed base from the refill container it comes in, because I no longer have my original metal compact, which was perfect for the product. When I thought I was reordering a replacement, I was seriously disappointed to receive the cheap, plastic version. I can't help but think that your company was not thinking of the long-term customers, like myself, when you decided to swap out the perfect compact for the junk you are currently selling. Did you really think that no one would notice? Or worse, have you been swapping out product ingredients for cheaper alternatives, rather than prioritizing quality? Please bring back the metal compact, and focus on the quality I have come to expect from your company.
Please bring back the metal compact! 1
EE43 from Florida
I have used Jane Iredale products for over 15 years. I am now accessing my pressed base from the refill container it comes in, because I no longer have my original metal compact, which was perfect for the product. When I thought I was reordering a replacement, I was seriously disappointed to receive the cheap, plastic version. I can't help but think that your company was not thinking of the long-term customers, like myself, when you decided to swap out the perfect compact for the junk you are currently selling. Did you really think that no one would notice? Or worse, have you been swapping out product ingredients for cheaper alternatives, rather than prioritizing quality? Please bring back the metal compact, and focus on the quality I have come to expect from your company.
Could be higher quality 3
Jen67 from Cookville, Texas
I love the powder base make up that goes in the compact but I agree with other reviewers; for the price the quality of the compact should be higher.
Could be higher quality 3
Jen67 from Cookville, Texas
I love the powder base make up that goes in the compact but I agree with other reviewers; for the price the quality of the compact should be higher.
Why are there negative reviews??? 5
KayB from Dallas, TX
I really don't understand the negative reviews... It's a beautiful compact that stands the test of time and is reusable! I simply buy my replacement foundation, pop out the empty one, put in the new one, and I'm good to go. I've used the same compact for over 4 years and even bought an additional one to have a duplicate in my purse! Of course if you drop it, I'm sure the foundation would break but come on people, that's NORMAL! I have however dropped mine several times in the sink and it hasn't broken ever! It does need to be cleaned with a q-tip occasionally in between refills just because everything requires cleaning - DUH!
Why are there negative reviews??? 5
KayB from Dallas, TX
I really don't understand the negative reviews... It's a beautiful compact that stands the test of time and is reusable! I simply buy my replacement foundation, pop out the empty one, put in the new one, and I'm good to go. I've used the same compact for over 4 years and even bought an additional one to have a duplicate in my purse! Of course if you drop it, I'm sure the foundation would break but come on people, that's NORMAL! I have however dropped mine several times in the sink and it hasn't broken ever! It does need to be cleaned with a q-tip occasionally in between refills just because everything requires cleaning - DUH!
Cute 5
Mary from Kansas City
I love bees and this is a cute limited edition product for someone like me.
Cute 5
Mary from Kansas City
I love bees and this is a cute limited edition product for someone like me.
Beautiful compact 5
Chlocam from AL
I received the silver compact. I love the color and durability. It looks much better than your average makeup compact.
Beautiful compact 5
Chlocam from AL
I received the silver compact. I love the color and durability. It looks much better than your average makeup compact.
Lightweight case, refillable 5
FloridaAuthor from Florida
The pros are it's lightweight and reusable, making it a good choice for travel or daily touchups. The con is my older one (also refillable) is a substantial gold finish metal and very attractive.
Lightweight case, refillable 5
FloridaAuthor from Florida
The pros are it's lightweight and reusable, making it a good choice for travel or daily touchups. The con is my older one (also refillable) is a substantial gold finish metal and very attractive.
Love the gold color 3
Llla from undisclosed
I love the color! Too bad it's easily scratched and feels chintzy. I appreciate the compacts are refillable vs wasting packaging each purchase
Love the gold color 3
Llla from undisclosed
I love the color! Too bad it's easily scratched and feels chintzy. I appreciate the compacts are refillable vs wasting packaging each purchase
