Rated 4.27 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review White eyeliner? What was I thinking....
So I read this cosmetic blog from Pinterest that talked all about how white eyeliner was the newest most fantastic thing to ever grace the world of makeup. So I hope in my car and decide to get me some of that. First, and only, application was an epic fail. But that was on me, and not the actual product. The eyeliner was like silk going on and was very smooth. I went back and got black. My white can rot away with that contouring kit that I eye every morning like a venomous snake on my vanity.
Most Helpful Critical Review Long lasting but difficult to apply
This is not my favorite liner but I still keep it in my makeup bag because it is long lasting and doesn't fade after wearing it all day. It is not creamy enough to easily apply to the top lid and the pigment isn't strong enough to stay on the waterline. Personally I like to use the Nyx matte liquid liner on my top lid and then I put it on the outer corner of my lower lashes and smudge it out. I think this liner works pretty well for a good smokey eye. I would say that this product is a good addition to your makeup collection but you might want to look elsewhere if you are just looking for a more versatile liner.
Reviewed by 2009 customers I would buy this again.
Jeanette from Odenton MD
Goes on smooth like the retractable liner.
Not the best, but still good
Mila from Aliso Viejo, CA
When I started to take my eyeliner off, it did not come off for the longest time. I read the eyeliner packaging, and it said it was waterproof. It was not advertised as waterproof at Ulta.
Stacy from MN
I currently have the bronze color and it goes on smoothly. The color payoff is great and it has a subtle shimmer to it, which was surprising since I wasn't expecting it but it's very pretty.
Love this product
Mandi from Rockford, IL
I am obsessed with this eyeliner. The formula is creamy & works immediately. It glides well over the eye & has no tugging or pulling for $5 I was skeptical about it, but it amazed me instantly. I would buy this again & again
Love this eyeliner
Sarah from Baltimore, MD
I can't believe for the price how great this eyeliner is!! It goes on so smooth and doesn't smudge!!
JJK from Los Angeles
Wow. I bought this literally just to put my order to meet the limit for some awesome Ulta special. I am so impressed, this is my new liner. I don't use much makeup, and I tend to go for the higher end stuff, but I like this BETTER than my Lorac!!! It stays on better and doesn't bleed around my lower lid area. And the PRICE? I can get one in every color : )
Jexxie from Florida
Love the color love the cruelty doesn't burn
Jexxie from Florida
Love the color love the cruelty doesn't burn
Not for me.
Tumbleweed from MINNESOTA
I will not buy again. Pencil kept breaking and I needed to line my eyes twice to get the white to show.I bought
IndieEnthusiast2020 from Milwaukee, WI
I really enjoyed this color - it's like a peacock blue - but the product doesn't last in the waterline! The description says it lasts all day, but when I used it in my waterline it melted away after half an hour.
j from tn
easiest eyeliner I've ever worked with, however it is still a bit hard to apply on hooded eyes. I only wore it for a few hours but it didn't smudge and came off easily. would recommend to beginners with eyeliner for the ease of use.
I love it!
AdaNelly from Palmdale,California
If you're a beginner with eyeliner's like me and is scared of liquid ones I would definitely get this one to learn about control and what you want your "go to" liner to look like. At some point it's hard to keep a sharp tip in eyeliner "pencil" but overall it's pretty good!
I liked the smooth way the pencil glided over my lid.
Holly from Wooster from Wooster, Ohio
It is a nice color brown and applies smoothly. It lasted all day.
I would buy this product again and I have!
Suzy from Fort Mill, SC
I've been using this eyeliner for a few years now. I just wish I could still get it in the emerald green. It was my favorite.
Not good, even for the price
Teacher from Seminole, Florida
First couple times ok, then broke, then got mushy, not a fine line, was clumpy and wouldn't draw a line. Not worth the little bit I paid. Check out other negative reviews - same problems. Sad; I loved the deep purple color.
Cubby's Mom from CA
I purchased this eye liner along with the NYX Slim Eye Pencil because I couldn't decide which color I wanted and the price was good for experimenting. Both shades were in the green family, one more mossy than the other so I mix them or use them separately. I find that most retractable eyeliners run out of product before the ones that you sharpen on your own, however this one seems to last as far as wear ability, longer. It is easy to apply and stays put on my upper lid and ok but not 100% on the lower lid. Next time, I may try another brand but this will do for now.
This liner is everything!
Andee from Austin, TX
I like to use the gray color as an alternative to black to create a softer look and also if I'm running late, it works perfectly because it doesn't need careful application to look good. I also apply it to my lower lash line and water line and it glides on and stays put. My favorite look is black liquid winged liner on top and the gray color on the bottom. I have oily skin and the staying power is 100% there. I will definitely buy more colors.
Great basic black eyeliner
Jen from Kokomo IN
I really like this eyeliner. I use it almost every day for just basic black outline. Goes on very smooth, easy to lengthen the point.
Great value, love the colors, long-wearing
Junie from Tustin, Ca
Liner consistency is on the softer side, but it stays put and doesn't smudge! I like that it's retractable and not a pencil.
Perfect color replacement
Just a simple small town girl from Texas
Love this color and have had to resort to this being that I can no longer find my very favorite eyeliner URBAN DECAY color ROACH. I'm guessing they discontinued it and I loved it, I have came across it when googling but it's expensive, so I looked at other liners to replace it and found this one, I love the color as it's so similar to the other, but the downfall is that it does not have a sharpener, ugh!! I'd really love for it to have one, as some do come with one even though you twist it out and i think somewhere it's considered An automatic self sharpened eyeliner. In my opinion it could use one, being that sometimes a thiner sharper line is needed and wanted. I use to have a Mary Kay eyeliner called bronze that I loved and was discontinued as well :( but it was made like this and on the opposite end you could pull the cap off and inside the cap was a sweet little sharpener. Maybe they could add one!?! Ha!
Jax from MN
This is a womderful eye liner if you like the gel type. It goes on super smooth and the color is very clean and sharp.
Love this pencil better than Lancôme's for half the price
Tapatiame2 from SoCali
It glides on smooth and lasts even in humidity
Kinz from Va
Pretty happy considering the price. Works almost as good as the $20+ brand I used to use. Have been searching to find something that works as well and this definitely comes the closest. Moves a little bit (I do have pretty oily skin) but I can deal with it. Nothing major.
DO NOT BUY!!
ultabuyer from ulta
I bought this because it was on sale on top of already being cheap & fairly good reviews. The first couple of times of use, I set the liner with eyeshadow, which helped the wear but still had some smudging, but no big deal. One day I was running out of the house and did not set the eyeliner and ended up with racoon eyes!! Save yourself the couple bucks and invest it into a different eyeliner. If I could leave 0 stars I would.
I love this eyeliner, its the best!!!!!
Angel from Brunswick GA
I love this product, very good!! It's the best!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
ULTA is always on TIME!!!
Thank you ULTA!!!!!!!!!!!!