Product Reviews Rated 4.27 out of 5 stars
2086 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Stays put no running.I... Stays put no running.I can even use on my waterline with contacts!!.Glides on and great pigmentation.Plus the price is awesome.The Brown is a nice shade.Black too.LOVE! my search is over
Most Helpful Critical Review Long lasting but difficult to apply This is not my favorite liner but I still keep it in my makeup bag because it is long lasting and doesn't fade after wearing it all day. It is not creamy enough to easily apply to the top lid and the pigment isn't strong enough to stay on the waterline. Personally I like to use the Nyx matte liquid liner on my top lid and then I put it on the outer corner of my lower lashes and smudge it out. I think this liner works pretty well for a good smokey eye. I would say that this product is a good addition to your makeup collection but you might want to look elsewhere if you are just looking for a more versatile liner.
Reviewed by 2086 customers You get what you pay, excessive crumbling 2
Reviewer from Chicago
You get what you pay with this eyeliner. This crumbles so bad and you have to apply multiple layers to get colour. I will stick with my Infallible L'Oreal eyeliner, way better than this one and just $3 or so more expensive, but the diffetence is huge, with the L'Oreal Infallible just one pass and it leaves the color and lasts all day. I will never buy one of these again from NYX.
Wouldn't purchase again 1
Mrodriguez from Bridgeport CT
This product point brakes easily and mushes quickly and easily
I wouldn't buy this product again 1
M.Rodriguez from Bridgeport CT
This eye liner mushes very quickly and the point brakes easily wouldn't buy it again
Amazing! 5
TieraBrianne from League City, TX
Super soft and creamy application. Slides on like butter and never dries out. I always use this pencil to tight line or go over my gel liner to make my wings darker and lashes blend. For this price, I'm obsessed!
Yes I would. 5
None from Sacramento CA
I love this eye liner and the price is wonderful.
Love it! 5
BB from Woodstock, GA
For a simple eyeliner it works just as well if not better than some of the more expensive ones. I will buy again and I recommend.
Better then I expected 5
Leila from Minnesota
Would buy this again, will try other colors
Don't understand the good reviews 1
Alexa from IL
Could not use this product. Save your money. This smudges terribly and is difficult to apply.
It's okay 3
Madi from Michigan
These eyeliners are one of the very few that don't irritate my eyes; however, they aren't very long lasting.
Gorgeous shade to outline eyes 5
Sparkles from NY
Eyeliner to highlight my eyes.
Great eyeliner 5
Denise G from New Bern, NC
This is a great eyeliner! It goes on easily, and the self-sharpening tip is a definite plus. It doesn't tug, and it's easy to remove.
Not great 1
Just J from WI
At first I really liked it, but it does not stay put. Smeared all over my lids without ever touching it. Transfers too easy
LOOKS GREAT - CRUELTY FREE - GREAT PRICE 5
Nessa from US
I always spend less than $10 for eyeliners. I used to buy other brands that tested on animals. When I tried this eyeliner I loved the feel , you don't have to sharpen it. It last along the day (just make sure you use setting spray to really lock it in) love it ! CRUELTY FREE & affordable ! This is probably my 4th purchase and will keep buying
Love it! Stays on all day 5
Rachael from Virginia
I love this eyeliner. I always apply eyeliner to my lower waterline and usually by mid day(if that) my old liner was gone. This eyeliner is super smooth and easy to apply. I can get a bold full line with one swipe and it lasts all day long.
I think I got a defective one, it won't wind up 3
Allison from TX
In waterline
Yes buy it! 5
Steph from Burbank
I always get compliments on this when I post photos on social media. I love the formula. It does not budge. I have never had an issue with it. You can't beat the price for this good quality.
Best waterline eyeline I've used! 4
Yasmine from Colorado
I use this on my waterline. I'm sure I'd you used this product on any other part of your face it would do just as good. Product went on really smooth, the formula is velvety. Also price is super affordable!!!
Smooth Beautiful Color 5
Maldonatalie from La Habra
Use this product if you want to wear eyeliner but don't like brown necessarily. The military green eyeliner can be worn for everyday use if your eyes to pop but in a softer way.
MAKES YOUR EYES POP! 5
girlpopglam from United States
I got the white color. It is super smooth and pigmented!
I ordered (1) black and (1) brown, did not receive brown. 4
DBurr from Charlotte, NC
Works well, does not "drag" like other similar products.
awesome product! 5
Sloane from Michigan
I've been using this product for a few days and love it! I use it for my lower waterline to make my eyes look bigger, and it's perfect. It doesn't smudge or run, and you can apply multiple coats if you want a really stark white look, or just use one coat for a more natural look. Overall, great product. I'd definitely buy it again!
Great product! 5
Sav from Ogden, UT
I'll be back for more!
My favorite eyeliner right now 5
Double L from Corona ca
Obsessed with the color and how it makes my brown eyes pop
10/10 would recommend 5
Lanie from Baytown,TX
It is a super good low key eyeliner and so affordable!! I have 2 colors of this eyeliner and I use it to spice up my look sometimes.
Phenomenal Eyeliner! 5
Jackie M from CT
I've been using this eyeliner for several years. At the beginning I was hesitant to purchase it because the eyeliners which I was using before were all expensive, big brand names, which somehow could not last all day long on my eyes. The Ulta specialist recommend me to try NYX. She said what could you loose with trying it for a while? She was right. These days, I always get 5-6 of these eyeliners, so I do not have to think about the replacement.
