Product Reviews Rated 3.84 out of 5 stars
136 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review LOVE THIS. So, firstly let me say that I do NOT write reviews. Even for products that I love. I'm just lazy I guess, I don't know. But THIS EYELINER... IS AMAZING. I do winged eyeliner. Every. Single. Day. I've done it the same since high school, and I'm going to be 25 now so... And lets just say I've been around the block when it comes to buying and testing and trying different liquid liners. I've been using stila's stay all day pen for years, but I've always dreamed of the day that I no longer need to spend $20+ on quality eyeliner, but I had accepted the fact that it might not be in my stars. But that day has COME, y'all!!! I'm free!!! And it is all thanks to revolution!!!! I love you guys. I used it for the first time yesterday, and it was probably the best day I could have chose to test it. I worked 13 hours and 8 hours of that consisted of me carrying heavy trays of food and dishes while running up and down stairs, in almost 90 degree heat. And I didn't have to touch up my wings at ALL!!! No transfer, no bleeding, no smudging. It kind of cracked a little bit on the wings, but what can you do? I wish I could give a big ol' kiss the person who made this formula, seriously. You have my heart, revolution!!! xoxoxo
Most Helpful Critical Review Caused an allergic reaction I really liked this eyeliner until I realized it was the cause of an allergic reaction (watery eyes, runny nose, itchy eyelids, eczema)! I don't have particularly sensitive eyes and frequently rotate products because I love trying new things, so I was very surprised to discover the allergy. I eliminated all my eye products, gradually adding them back in and saving this eyeliner for last. It caused an allergy within an hour of application, so unfortunately I had to get rid of it. This is the ONLY eye product I have EVER been allergic to! I am a frequent user of Makeup Revolution's products (as well as many different eyeliners from other drugstore brands) and usually have good luck with them, so I was sad to conclude that this was a dud. The two stars are for the pigmentation and ease of application, but sadly I will be giving this one a miss in the future.
Reviewed by 136 customers Don't waste your money! 1
Brittany from VA
This eyeliner is horrible! It's too shiny, doesn't go on smooth, and flakes! I was so excited to try this and is was such a disappointment! I rather just use my NYX or even Crayon Case liners because at least then I'll know the application is going on correctly and the finish look is on point (winged).
Best eyeliner but where is it in the shade black ? 5
Sierra from Ohio
I'm confused on why the black shade isn't on here again anymore ???? It's hands down the best eyeliner ever but I'm not sure on the blue and brown shade ! Hopefully the black one will come back
So much better than what I had before! 5
Hailey from Valdosta
The way this pen of designed makes it so easy to hold and manage while also making it elegant and sleek. The pen is a fine tip, which makes it easy to build up the line, but it is not so thin that the edge of the pen scrapes your eyelid. The tip is nicely tapered, I have had some pens that are teardrop shaped and do not lay down thinly or evenly and this fixed all of these problems. This is my new favorite!
Best eyeliner I have found, great price 5
Taylor from Massachusetts
Super easy to use, doesn't smudge, long lasting, and super affordable. Checks all the boxes.
OMG!!!! 5
Dione from Albuquerque NM
This product is truly heaven sent!! I have never wrote a product review in my whole entire life,but this one needs all the praise! For 9 dollars I was very skeptical but I will never use a different product for my eyeliner! I have tried multiple products that would run or make me look like a panda after a few hours. I have EXTREMELY oily eyelids, and nothing worked. I apply this around 5 in the morning, go workout, chase my headstart students all day, and come home to clean and cook and OMG! It doesn't even budge!! All I can say is TRY IT!
Worst Eyeliner I've Ever Tried 1
Ang from Michigan
This eyeliner at first try was very black and I liked the tip. However, after probably two uses the tip dried up and was difficult to apply. I don't know if I got a faulty one or not, but I was super displeased.
poor packaging 2
jc from MI
The good thing about this liner is that it's very black and stays decently well. However, the packaging (although pretty) needs to be improved. The cap kept popping off of mine until it popped off one night and the liner dried out completely. Also, right before it dried out, the tip bent in such a way that ink was got getting all the way to the tip. All this happened within just a couple of weeks of using it. I may repurchase at a deep discount just to see if it'll work better, but otherwise I wouldn't recommend this.
I HATE THIS 1
Em from PA
To start off positive, it's very black. That's all I like about this pen.
The shape is nice but if you have any lotion or moisturizer or anything on your hands you can't freaking get the cap off! The tip is very stiff and the pen dries out pretty quickly. The tip is also VERY stiff. But that's just personal preference I guess (for reference, I love the NYX epic ink liner). The eyeliner also rubs off. It doesn't smear or anything but I'll look in the mirror a couple hours after application and the wing will just be gone! Never buying this again.
Separated and dried patchy 1
Dee from WPB Florida
Couldn't wait to try this, so many good reviews. As soon as it dried on my eyelid it separated and got patchy. Very disappointed.
Awesome! 5
Gtlady from Reston, VA
This eyeliner is incredible: super black, EASY to work with, and cute packaging. I love it and keep repurchasing it.
Dried Out Within 1 Month 2
Long-lasting Lizzy from Barboursville, WV
I purchased this September 29th and started using this a few days later. I'm not sure if it was just the one I picked up but this thing dried up already and it's November 8th. I'm super sad because I love the shape of the pen, but obviously disappointed if it's not going to be long-lasting. I'd rather go back to my $2 Elf eyeliner.
STORE THIS PRODUCT UPSIDE DOWN! 3
Jen Klen from Allen Park
This product really makes eyeliner fun again with its easy-grip handle in the
middle, flexible felt point (which is the
only kind of tip I like to use), HOWEVER, YOU HAVE TO STORE THIS PRODUCT UPSIDE DOWN TO RECEIVE ANY PAYOFF!! Otherwise it dries down so much!! I will do this to any Physicians Formula eyeliner now that I know what will happen if I don't!
Works great 5
Alynnk from Springfield il
I usually do winged eyeliner daily and I love how easy this is to work with and it stays all day!
Awesome eyeliner 5
Adriann1973 from Virginia
I purchased this eyeliner over a year ago and just now ordering a second one! Still hasn't dried out nor has the brush top frayed. Stays put on the eyelid!
Love! 5
littlepeach from Atlanta, GA
Perfect wings. Great pigment.
Dried out too fast 2
D from Florida
I barely used it and it dried out after the second use.
Worth it 5
Haley from Montgomery Al
Love it! Possibly considered water proof.
Great product, great price! 4
Ashley from Indiana
I have the same problem no matter what liner I use, my eyes water at the outside corners so my liner will run a little, but I know to expect that so I just carry it with me. It dries matte which I prefer and is very smooth going on!
Easy to use, Bad at Lasting 3
Salome from Brooklyn, New York
This would be my perfect eyeliner if it lasted half as long as my others. It has a beautiful brush tip for drawing wings. I hate felt tip liners, but for some reason they last longer. Honestly really disappointing.
Not buying this again 2
E from Levittown
It's stays on all day. But I don't like that it isn't matte. It didn't dry down quick enough for me. Constantly have transfer.
Ugh 2
LunaLeviosa from HSoWaW
I tried this eyeliner, based on the great reviews it has, but I straight up hate it. It's very runny, doesn't dry quickly at all (for me) and bleeds into every tiny fine line that I didn't even know I had. Then, after struggling with it, to get a reasonably respectable top lid line, and then waiting to let it dry thoroughly, it started coming off in spots, with just the tiniest touch. I had to line over it with a better product, lest my entire eye look be destined for the pooper. I bumped this dud up to 2 stars because I love how super dark black it is, but I'll also be bumping it back to the store, as soon as possible.
I just wish there were other colors available. 3
Carrie from Goodyear, AZ
Most people will use black eyeliner because there is no choice. I prefer a softer look and buy brands that offer taupe or brown eyeliner. My wish is that this brand would do that.
Love this eyeliner pen 5
Jess89 from Tulsa ok
I love this eyeliner. The shape of the pen is easy to hold for even lines. The formula is easy to work with, goes on smoothly, dries quickly and lasts through the day. It's very pigmented! I've had mine for months and it's still going strong. I'm not great with wings but with this pen it's a lot easier for me than with other pens I've used. I will definitely purchase again.
Best eyeliner I have ever used 5
Lyshie Q from West Valley City
This is by far the best eyeliner I have ever used it goes on so smorh and easy I love how dark it goes on as well
Works well 4
Sherry from Baltimore, MD
I don't now that I would re-purchase this product, but I do like it. Nothing stands out and above many of my other eyeliners.
