Product Reviews Rated 3.38 out of 5 stars
16 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review I would recommend and buy this product again. I use a fresh puff in the morning to wash, exfoliate and tone. Then I drop it in the machine washable bag and I wash them weekly. I bought two sets so I can have enough to use once or twice a day. I'm also giving them as a white elephant gift. Great product!!
Most Helpful Critical Review Poor Quality! I love my original makeup erasers and was wanting a set of the smaller ones then I saw this set and decided to try it out. I got this set and the 7 day set of the pink/peach colored ones. I received this today and when I opened the bag, I picked up the first one by the ribbon tag thing (the black ribbon that says "makeup eraser" in pink writing, it's like a little handle type thing sewn onto the puffs), came out of the puff. I picked up another one and the same thing happened. These ribbons are attached to the puffs on both sides, but on one of the sides it's only attached with ONE thread in the middle. Two out of the 5 puffs were like this. I'm honestly afraid to put them through the washer because I feel like they're just going to fall apart. You can tell that the way they're sewn together is messy and just poor quality. Too many loose threads. I'm so disappointed in makeup eraser! I'm returning this set AND the other set that I ordered, I am posting a review on those too it's the set with 7 pink/peach colored cloths.
Reviewed by 16 customers Not worth the money 1
Joanna from Sioux City, IA
I'm obsessed with my makeup eraser, so I was excited to try these. It was a huge disappointment. They feel very cheaply made, are hard to keep in your hand when scrubbing your face, and any product just gets "stuck" on the puff. I definitely won't be buying these again or recommending them to anyone.
Would not recommend 1
Cary from Miami
This product works fairly well, the issue is when you wash it. I followed the instructions perfectly and still the product disintegrated in the wash. The puffs bled and stained all of my towels with black markings and they shed white lint everywhere, despite having washed them in their linen bag. It seems this product should be marketed as disposable instead of reusable.
Love this eco friendly makeup removing option! 5
Kayla F from Avon Indiana
Use these pads to apply my toner or remove makeup. Can also use them to wash your face! So versatile I love them!
Great Gift 5
m from Colorado
Gave this as a gift and my in law rants and raves about how much she loves them. Would recommend them.
Them being white doesn't make much sense to me 2
Maddie from Illinois
Nice idea but not thought through at all. Who wants to see dirty stained makeup even after washing. Wish both sides were black.. kinda gross looking after awhile.
I would recommend and buy this product again. 5
Joanne from Brownsville, TX
I use a fresh puff in the morning to wash, exfoliate and tone. Then I drop it in the machine washable bag and I wash them weekly. I bought two sets so I can have enough to use once or twice a day. I'm also giving them as a white elephant gift. Great product!!
Perfect for me & the environment 5
Briana from Pennsylvania
I really love this product! I actually bought two sets and use them everyday now!
Does the job 4
Elise from California
I leave one in the shower, to use when I wash my face. So, far so good, leaves my face very soft. I recommend the product. Good for travel.
Not great 2
Caty from So Cal
I like the concept of this puff set, and the amount of puffs you get. I used them as directed and it didn't work. The white side is very soft but the black side is very rough even when wet. Will have to find another use for them.
Poor Quality! 1
Marissa from Lexington, KY
I love my original makeup erasers and was wanting a set of the smaller ones then I saw this set and decided to try it out. I got this set and the 7 day set of the pink/peach colored ones. I received this today and when I opened the bag, I picked up the first one by the ribbon tag thing (the black ribbon that says "makeup eraser" in pink writing, it's like a little handle type thing sewn onto the puffs), came out of the puff. I picked up another one and the same thing happened. These ribbons are attached to the puffs on both sides, but on one of the sides it's only attached with ONE thread in the middle. Two out of the 5 puffs were like this. I'm honestly afraid to put them through the washer because I feel like they're just going to fall apart. You can tell that the way they're sewn together is messy and just poor quality. Too many loose threads. I'm so disappointed in makeup eraser! I'm returning this set AND the other set that I ordered, I am posting a review on those too it's the set with 7 pink/peach colored cloths.
absolutely love them !!!! 5
chocokat from Orlando Florida
I love the product so much I got two more sets.
Take care washing 2
Ali love from Austin
Not sure how they perform yet but I did an initial wash (Woolite, delicate cycle, in the launder bag it came with)—I washed a pillowcase along with it. There was black lint everywhere and stuck to the pillow! What a mess—I hope the lint doesn't come off on my face when I use!
I was hoping to love, but I dont 1
Bri from Colorado
I got these and washed them in their bag that they come with and when I took them out they were falling apart... idk if I got a bad set or what.. I love the makeup eraser but these not so much..
Amazing 5
jess from nyc
i bought these cause im tired of waste. i have the og make up eraser and i lovedddd it.
My new holy grail puff! 5
Mind blown 🤯 from Cali
Where has this product been! It's a complete game changer. It sets my makeup flawlessly!!! No more disposable waste either! Win win
MUST HAVE 5
Heather from Virginia
these are perfect! Comes with a bag to wash them in. Super soft and takes makeup right off
