Rated 3.33 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Great eyeliner AND SO CHEAP...
I bought this because I was tired of paying $20+ for eyeliner, I knew a cheap eyeliner would work just as well as an expensive one. So I decided to buy this one because I wanted something cruelty free and brown. I tell everyone to try it and I consistently repurchase. I like that the felt tip is a little bit more firm, allows for a more precise application. I have tried sooo many expensive liners and this one is my favorite.
Most Helpful Critical Review Nope
If you touch your eye you turn into a raccoon. And then when you want to wash it off you'll need a power washer. I don't know how something simultaneously smears with the breeze but doesn't come off easily, but wet n wild managed to achieve something physics cannot explain.
Reviewed by 67 customers Ok...but staying power needs work.
MelissaP from OK
Felt eyeliners are a new thing for me. I have always used cake liners or liquid liners. This was easy to use and went on very well...even over my layers of shadow. Unfortunately after a few hours the liner started to transfer onto the upper parts of my eye lid and also started to melt away in places. Note that I did use an eye primer before application. If the product were waterproof it might last longer but something would have to change in the formulation to keep it from transferring.
Sorry Wet and wild
Jane doe from Canada
I bought this and tried this a year ago now. I don't know if they changed the formula and it's better now, but anyway: it wasn't a good purchase for me. It didn't last even an hour. It smudges, and finally melts and disappears. That's all I have to say. The price is good, the quality, not so much.
I'll give the credit to wet and wild for posting bad comments tho.
Kara from Morehead City, NC
This does not glide on smoothly, you have to kind of press hard to any of the liquid out.
Felt tip liners
Carolina F from undisclosed
Not enough liquid, does not glide on smoothly. It left uneven steaks when trying to use. Would be ok for bottom water line but not for a cat eye
I love this eyeliner!
Nici Gi from San Diego, CA
Simple easy to use. Best deal for the price out of all the brands!
Perfect for on the go
MM0120 from New Mexico
I love this stuff I use this on my brows in case I need to touch them up for some reason it's perfect to just throw in my bag
Lasts all day long and beyond !
CeCe696969 from Boston
Please dont ever discontinue! This is my go to eyeliner. Always get compliments when i wear. Love it
CC from North Carolina
My first liquid liner and this one is perfect! Easy to use and smooth application.
I've never done eyeliner before
JJ from Sylvania Ga
As a noob to eyeliner, this eyeliner pen was easy to control, the brush tip gave me great precision, and it's a nice jet black
Precise and perfect!
Makeup lady from Midwest
Love this! So easy to use, I have arthritis in my hands and the precision of this is remarkable. I only wish it came in waterproof.
I was using mac when I fell in love with this
izzy from nyc
I was using the mac brushstroke liner when I bought this because wet n wild had a buy 1 get 1 50% off. I love the mac liner for durability but the black one is too harsh and their brown one is too transparent. So I gave this a whirl, I was amazed at how easy it was to apply, so much easier than what I;m used to and I've tried soo many eyeliners of every form. The color is also a nice opaque brown, very good for the fair skinned, black is a bit harsh on me. I'm gonna stock up on this, seriously amazing deal for the money. Highly recommend it.
Ms. Maria from Los Angeles
I started using this liner for my eyes over the pencil one and i cant be more please with it. I get alot of compliments on how it looks.
Please fix the cap issue!!!!!
Jenn123456789 from Akron, oh
I love the product and have purchased it 5 or 6 times and with every new tube, the cap will just shoot off without even touching it. Please fix the cap issue! You're selling a defective product.
Spend extra to get something decent
Mae from Michigan
Barely worked. Had to re wet and darken with a brown pencil liner
Sherry56 from Cornelius, NC 28031
I'm on the fence about this guy. I love the control I get with this liner. But, after one swipe with the felt tip and placing it back into the tube like you do to get more mascara, it never gives me enough of the liquid. It would be nice if someone could explain how to use this liner.
Geri from Oregon
Excellent especially for the price!
I give wet and wild a 10
Wet n wild lover from Cincinnati, ohio
I love wet n wild I have been using wet n wild ever since I was a teenager. And now me being 44 years old still use them.
Lid design is faulty
16em16 from undisclosed
I love the way this eyeliner stays on without fading or smudging. But the lid comes off so easily, sometimes without even touching the product. So now my nearly-new eyeliner is completely dried out.
Good but needs update
Katym3 from undisclosed
I had bought this eyeliner and found it very good. Unfortunately, the cap came off and it dried up. I bought another one and made sure to close it properly but it still opened and dried in my make up bag. This was unfortunate as I really liked this eyeliner.
Great eyeliner for a novice
Palomita from Vacaville
Love this felt tip liner. I don't apply eyeliner often and find this much easier than gels, brush tip liquids, or pencils. Super easy to get a fine smooth line for a natural look or to add on a nice pointed wing.
Hard to work with
SavannahJ from Wisconsin
I don't know if I got a defective one but I constantly have to shake mine to get product and it doesn't like to come out of the top but the sides. Very annoying
lid STILL pops off
lilgibby from ohio
ive been using this product for over a year because i love it despite the lid issue. i thought maybe i was doing something wrong so i came to the website to see if i was the only one experiencing this and i am not. to read reviews OVER a year old of the same issue and it has still not been fixed. i love this liner, but i may have to find another if this issue is still ignored.
Oms A from Springfield
I bought this a week ago and the cap doesn't want to close so it dried and I only wasted my money even if it's cheap it should be of good quality if it's a big company like this one. Don't recommend.
The best felt tip eyeliner!!
Princess from Worcester Mass
I absolutely love this eyeliner! It stays on better then the high end brands. Just wish it was avail in more colors
Naty1102 from Miami, Fl
Horrible! I love Wet n Wild and use a lot of their products. They've really stepped up their formulas from when i was in school. i have their highlighters, powder, nail polishes, matte glosses, lipsticks, eyeshadow pallets, i mean the list goes on. As you can see i've tried lots of their products but this product was TERRIBLE! The first and most frustrating thing was that the eyeliner cap was defective, it kept popping off, literally and therefore dried it in less than a day...regardless i got to use it twice before the cap went bonkers and every night when i took my eye make up off with my eye makeup wipe, it gave me raccoon eyes... i hate that!! i plan on writing to Wet and Wild because i also bought a Mascara that promises to volumize and lengthen but it did neither. it doesn't even look like i have mascara on! So frustrating. Bottom line, don't get this eyeliner... you'll regret it.