Product Reviews Rated 3.42 out of 5 stars
52 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Great eyeliner AND SO CHEAP... I bought this because I was tired of paying $20+ for eyeliner, I knew a cheap eyeliner would work just as well as an expensive one. So I decided to buy this one because I wanted something cruelty free and brown. I tell everyone to try it and I consistently repurchase. I like that the felt tip is a little bit more firm, allows for a more precise application. I have tried sooo many expensive liners and this one is my favorite.
Most Helpful Critical Review Nope If you touch your eye you turn into a raccoon. And then when you want to wash it off you'll need a power washer. I don't know how something simultaneously smears with the breeze but doesn't come off easily, but wet n wild managed to achieve something physics cannot explain.
Reviewed by 52 customers Perfect for on the go 4
MM0120 from New Mexico
I love this stuff I use this on my brows in case I need to touch them up for some reason it's perfect to just throw in my bag
Love this! 5
CC from North Carolina
My first liquid liner and this one is perfect! Easy to use and smooth application.
I've never done eyeliner before 5
JJ from Sylvania Ga
As a noob to eyeliner, this eyeliner pen was easy to control, the brush tip gave me great precision, and it's a nice jet black
Precise and perfect! 5
Makeup lady from Midwest
Love this! So easy to use, I have arthritis in my hands and the precision of this is remarkable. I only wish it came in waterproof.
I was using mac when I fell in love with this 5
izzy from nyc
I was using the mac brushstroke liner when I bought this because wet n wild had a buy 1 get 1 50% off. I love the mac liner for durability but the black one is too harsh and their brown one is too transparent. So I gave this a whirl, I was amazed at how easy it was to apply, so much easier than what I;m used to and I've tried soo many eyeliners of every form. The color is also a nice opaque brown, very good for the fair skinned, black is a bit harsh on me. I'm gonna stock up on this, seriously amazing deal for the money. Highly recommend it.
Spend extra to get something decent 1
Mae from Michigan
Barely worked. Had to re wet and darken with a brown pencil liner
Excellent 5
Geri from Oregon
Excellent especially for the price!
Great eyeliner for a novice 5
Palomita from Vacaville
Love this felt tip liner. I don't apply eyeliner often and find this much easier than gels, brush tip liquids, or pencils. Super easy to get a fine smooth line for a natural look or to add on a nice pointed wing.
Hard to work with 2
SavannahJ from Wisconsin
I don't know if I got a defective one but I constantly have to shake mine to get product and it doesn't like to come out of the top but the sides. Very annoying
The best felt tip eyeliner!! 5
Princess from Worcester Mass
I absolutely love this eyeliner! It stays on better then the high end brands. Just wish it was avail in more colors
Very Disappointed 1
Naty1102 from Miami, Fl
Horrible! I love Wet n Wild and use a lot of their products. They've really stepped up their formulas from when i was in school. i have their highlighters, powder, nail polishes, matte glosses, lipsticks, eyeshadow pallets, i mean the list goes on. As you can see i've tried lots of their products but this product was TERRIBLE! The first and most frustrating thing was that the eyeliner cap was defective, it kept popping off, literally and therefore dried it in less than a day...regardless i got to use it twice before the cap went bonkers and every night when i took my eye make up off with my eye makeup wipe, it gave me raccoon eyes... i hate that!! i plan on writing to Wet and Wild because i also bought a Mascara that promises to volumize and lengthen but it did neither. it doesn't even look like i have mascara on! So frustrating. Bottom line, don't get this eyeliner... you'll regret it.
Meh 2
Charity from Tennessee
This is not my favorite felt tip liner. Make sure before you use it you shake the product to get the liquid to flow to tip but even doing that you will have to stop mid eye to shake again to finish the rest of the eye. It takes a while to apply my liner because of this, the liquid stops and when I start back it seems uneven so I have to fix that as well. It's just a pain to me it's worth to pay a little more for a better liner.
Great Product for an even better price! 5
Brandy from Butler, Al
This product is amazing! Very inexpensive and doesn't smudge or run. Lasts all day and removes easily.
Lid pops off 3
. from Wi
I really like this but after about 2 weeks the kid started popping off a ton so then it dried.
Good liner but the packaging sucks 3
Hannah from CA
I really like this liner, it's cheap and I can draw really fine lines, but the spring mechanism on the cap doesn't work well. Whenever I buy one the cap ends up sprinting loose and when I come back it's al dried up
Not great 3
B from Florida
Spend extra money and get something great. I was being cheap and definitely got cheap results.
When removing all over eye 2
Audrey from New York,NY
This eye liner was ok for the first day very hard to do a cat eye with it also when I attempted to do a cat eye I didn't even put it under my eye and while taking it off it went all over my under eye don't recommend this eye liner
Don't bother 1
Angie from CA
Went on like butter at first but turned patchy after minutes of use. When i tried to go over a patchy line it dried and became flakey. Also was near impossible to take off. Wet N Wild managed to make something so easy to smear yet so difficult to remove.
Sorry far so good 5
cece from 70816
I guess I should wait until the end of the day to write a review. I just picked this up because I'm out of eyeliner and I didn't want to spend $25 on a luxurious brand. I did notice that this one on just a smooth and had a wonderful felt-tip. so far so good! I am so happy because this was a very nice eyeliner for a cheap price
I got a really bad allergic reaction to it 1
Ugh from Deer park
I got a really bad allergic reaction to it. It made my eyelids bruised and it made me break out Bc I made hearts with it on my face! I want my money back
BEST EYELINER EVER! 5
madz from Puerto Rico
This is the best eyeliner i have ever tried in my entire life. I can go my whole day (9-5) and it looks the same as if I had just done it. It doesn't run nor creases and it is incredibly easy to make a wing with!
Can't go wrong with wet n wild 5
MC from NJ
Wow I bought the black and it's beautiful. I loved the brown so I had to have both colors. This might be my favorite liner and I've tried quite a few trying to find one I liked. This doesn't "leak" into fine lines and looks matte. Simple, easy, efficient, and cheap!
Where have you been my whole life? 4
FabLav from Corpus Christi, Tx
I've been using pencil liner my whole life and I went out on a limb and tried liquid. The size of the liner is perfect considering I have tiny hands. The brush tip makes this eyeliner so easy to apply and it doesn't smudge over the course of the day which is what I'm use to. I absolutely love this product!
1st time user 5
Tracy from GA
I am getting more mature and want something that glides on, without dragging. I just have to practice with it a little more.
Lid does not stay on! 2
Anna from Chicago
Just like one of the other reviewers noted- the lid continuously pops off! I actually really liked this liner, but it dried out in 3 days because the lid kept coming off. I'd rather spend a bit more and get a product that's packaging isn't poor quality.
