Rated 4.52 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Amazing Quality
I got this for myself as a birthday gift, and i absolutely love it. I have 2 of these lip pencils and they are both my favorite lipsticks to wear.
Most Helpful Critical Review Not Long Lasting
I had this product in Cruella and LOVED the color. The texture is creamy and doesn't feel too dry, but the color fades immediately after eating or drinking. I wear reds all the time and was extremely disappointed in the lack of this product's durability, especially after reading such good reviews. Even when I blot my lips on a tissue, half the lipstick comes off and I'm left with an awkward lip liner ring. I would love this product if it stayed on for more than half an hour!
Reviewed by 416 customers My Go-To
Tacsmom from Morganton, NC
I absolutely love the Velvet Matte Lip Pencil in Cruella - it's my go-to as it matches mostly everything and is very complimentary with my skin tone!!
Hailes from Ohio
After Taylor Swift's recent Red re-release, was inspired to try out a bold-er Taylor-esque red and found Dragon Girl. I love this shade! I have a bit of rosacea to my skin, but this red looks great even so. It also does not make your teeth look more "yellow." It did not dry out my lips. 10/10 :)
Shaunte from IL
I've purchase this shade in a mini version of this color. After watching several different reviews of people trying this color on, I wanted to give this shade a try. My all time favorite color from NARS is American woman. This shade reminds me of it. When applying Walkyrie to my lips I see more pink tones then the burnt coral red. My only issue is that the pigmentation isn't the best for my natural lip tone. I have to layer it quite a bit for it show up. Not sure if it's because its a similar shade so close to my natural lip color. It's a pretty everyday shade that I would not mind wearing. My only wish is that it is a little more pigmented and that is actually showed more of burnt coral red as oppose to pink but this will do.
The Best Matte Lipsticks! Dry Lip Friendly!
Caroboo from Houston, Texas
I don't know what it is about these lip pencils, but they are incredible! I have been using them for over 6 years and I no longer use anything else. I have naturally dry lips and most lipsticks flake off in minutes and give me the "liner" look. These pencils not only stay, they don't dry out my lips either. I own almost every color and I couldn't recommend them enough!
Shade Dance fever velvet matte lip pencil
Jabin from New York
Loved this color, finished quickly as I wear it everyday (almost). But can't find it anywhere anymore as it seems out of production. Please recommend a similar shade.
Best lip liner but can't find my color!
Susan1974 from Utah
This is the best lipliner of all. Matte and stays on well. I've had a few of these in the color Marnie for years but can no longer find it. Would love to know what is the closest color?
without a question
Michelle L. from Summerville, SC
When I first tried this lip pencil, I was hooked. This pencil glides on like bullet lipstick. Very comfortable, long-wearing, fades so pretty, worth every dime! I've worn makeup long enough to know this period of time is the very best of the cosmetic industries products and this one product is a keeper! It doesn't dry out your lips. It doesn't leave your lips feeling like you've powdered them. Just a win all around.
Naz from MI
So nice and smooth but don't like that it doesn't last long
I would buy this item again.
Dinora from Harlingen, TX
I loved the color and texture.
My staple Lip Pencil!!
Chiya from New York
Finally I found my staple item. I'm falling in love with this color in Good Times. This color is just perfect on my skin tone, somehow it makes my face healthier. I love to use this pencil as a eyeshadow base as well. Formula is amazing, this matt lip pencil never dry up my lips.
Love! But where is my shade?!?
paintedwithemily from Texas
I've had the "bad girl" velvet lip pencil for a really REALLY long time. I'm almost out of it and I absolutely love it. The last time I got lip filler, it was my saving grace as far as it going on gently yet solid.
Thing is, I see that bad girl is not a shade I can purchase now. Is there a comparable shade to the one I am searching for?
I sure do hope so. It's definitely perfect.
Best natural lip
Mandy from Herndon, VA
I love this color, it's a great natural lip color for brown skin. Only thing that sucks is when I sharpen the pencil it never looks as pictured.
The Perfect Colour! But...
Oceania from Southeast US
The colour I've been seeking for so long, Train Bleu. What has me so disappointed is that it just doesn't stay on very long. I bought this matte formula because I had been led to believe that it stayed on for hours. On me, it does not. I really wish it did because the shade is so beautiful. I recommend this if you do not expect long lasting and are okay with reapplying a few times during the day or night.
perfect shade for day or night - long lasting!
LauraOrtuondo from Cupertino, CA
color stay perfect, neutral and flattering color for my love skin to use day or night. I LOVE this color and I wish I could find a "kit" that included all complementary products to go along with it in one single kit: lip liner, rouge and eye shadow...just perfect.
Great Lip Pencil
CrystalCake from New York, NY
Goes on smooth, feel great on.
leaves a nice stain
sasasa from North Carolina
not matte under a mask but sans maks is good
Feels like silk
DAMT from Dallas
Applies like smooth silk. It could stay on a bit longer. I love the colors, but I need something a little darker for me. Will but again just darker colors.
Let's go crazy - so good!
Katie Bart from South Dakota
I LOVE these pencils. I have many colors! When will let's go crazy be back in stock - I need a refill! ;)
Love this lip color and buy repeating
Red Lip Mamma from El Paso, TX
With covid restictions being lifted I can show off this beautiful shade.
Dragon Girl perfect red
venus814 from Cleveland
This is the most perfect lip pencil I have evwr used. The color is beautiful and it lasts hours
sara_l100 from undisclosed
Please bring back the color Intriguing! It was the perfect shade!
Train Bleu Lover
Nikki J from Houston, TX
I love the Train Bleu color. It is my most coveted makeup piece. I pray they never stop making this color. I am a forever buyer.
Lip pencil Intriguing
Merissa from Miami, FL
Love this color!! PLEASE RESTOCK!!
Daisy from Texas
I got it because Taylor Swift says she uses it, and it's so smooth and lasts I love it
My Go To!
MizJan from Denver
This is my go to everyday lip color! I've worn it for several years now & given as gifts to friends & family of all ages..
It even holds up well with masks!