Product Reviews Rated 3.59 out of 5 stars
108 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Buxom addicts will love this! Dry liquid lip fans won't I had a hard time giving this 5 stars because it feels a bit gimmicky/trendy. It's as if their lip cream and lipsticks had a baby. It also is exactly what it says...like they put a glossy lipstick in a tube. This is NOT like the matte liquid lipsticks that dry down and stay all day. This is literally a high pigment gloss that dries down to a lip stain basically. I actually LOVE that about this product because I'm a Buxom lip product addict. I'm writing this review specifically for that reason - for other Buxom addicts.
So the #1 question I wanted answered about this product- can I stack it with Buxom lip glosses and other lip products? This product is GREAT to use with the Buxom lip pencils. Because of its high pigmentation and stain, you don't really need to use a lipstick with this product. But I definitely suggest using a lip pencil to help with definition and add depth. It isn't so great for using with gloss at first because it's very glossy itself to start out with. HOWEVER, as it wears down it turns into a beautiful long lasting lipstick, so it's great to have a gloss on hand after it's worn down some to help vamp it up and take it up a notch. Plus there's the bonus that it's easy to just reapply the color itself like a normal lipstick or gloss. This is basically a great lipstick to wear during the day and then turn into a great evening look simply by what gloss you choose to revive it with. There are also some great night time looks.
If you're looking for something like a long wearing matte liquid lipstick this isn't for you. It doesn't dry down to a non transfer finish. It wears more like a traditional long wear lipstick but just has a more glossier finish to start(which you can always freshen up). Other con is that the color it starts out as has a slight variation from the color it wears down to. Taupe it off looks amazing with Hush Hush Plump Liner and White Russian gloss center lip.
Most Helpful Critical Review Disappointed. Poor color description and awful feathering I was so excited to try this product during the 21 Days of Beauty promotion. Unfortunately, due to the pandemic right now, we can't go into stores to test out colors so I had to go by verbal description and the online picture. I like nude peachy-pinks, so I went with "Russian To You" as it is called a "nude pink." I'm so sorry to say that it is a dreadful color with a white pasty base highlighted with some kind of florescent peach tone and a touch of gloss. It looks like a color from the 60s for a Femm-Bot in white patent leather go-go boots to wear in the Austin Powers movies. It's smooth and creamy - went on nicely, but then after an hour or so of wear, the pasty unnatural wall paint color was bleeding outside of my lip line into my skin. So now I look like a train wreck of a hussy. I don't mean to be a party pooper, but essentially, you would need a lip primer to make the product stay put. If I can exchange the product and try a different color with a primer, I might be happy. But for now, I'm pretty disappointed.
Reviewed by 108 customers My favorite lipstick! 5
Mal from 28412
No it does not sting or tingle but this formula does not work that way. A few minutes after I put it on it starts to plump and stays that way long after it wears off and it stays on for at least a couple hours for me. Yes I do recommend sampling the colors in person. Dolly is my favorite.
Big no for me 1
Tish718 from NC
Color on website did not match what I got at all,thought it was gonna be pink but with just a hint of brown making it not so pink not HOT PINK. I got it on sale for $10 but went to exchange for another color didn't realize till after since I purchased a bunch of other things instead of letting me exchange it she charged me full price.I'd never would've gotten it if I had known(couldn't return it again cause was out of state)again that color wasn't what I thought it would be either it was a gross nude brownish dull color I thought was gonna have a hint of pink. Besides the color being horrible it was too dry for me,lips are already chapped,it did not make my lips look nice or plump they looked dry&the same. I wouldn't get this again especially full price,I don't know why she didn't honor the sale price&don't know if she even used my ulta account unless it only shows what you order online¬ in store.
I should have taken the comments seriously 1
SandyM from Jax. Fl
The color does not match what it looks like online nor the description. Also it is not shiny and it dried my lips out. I am returning.
Pigment and shine! 5
MEL. from Yuma, AZ
The absolute best pigment and gloss put together!. Such a beautiful finish!.
Nice!! 5
Squid from Ohio
Good on its own, it has plumping feeling too it, but it isn't strong. I'd say it's pretty comfortable to wear.
Disappointed in shade 1
Les from La
Thought it would be a glossy shade due to description but it wasn't.
Good formula, bad color 2
MommaLikesMakeup from 48146
Ordered the nude pink, it is more of a neon pink almost. Looks nothing like the tube, but the formula was really nice. I would reorder but I'm too scared of what the color will turn out to be.
Returning 2
JMS2020 from Midwest
I'm typically a big fan of Buxom but was very disappointed in the quality this lipstick. Wine Me ran down the corners of my lips after my morning coffee, I've never had that happen with a lipstick! The other color I purchased had no definition on the edges, appeared blurry on my outer lips.
Lip gloss 1
EM from San Pedro,CA
It's a lipgloss with some color. Nothing to it
Deceiving 1
Chocolate from MD
I have quite a few of the "full on plumping lip gloss" and I really love those. So when I saw these were on the 21 days of beauty I had to get them (side note I have deeper skin so I gravitate towards neutrals & purple) after receiving and doing some swatching need less to say they look nothing like the picture or what's described
FLUORESCENT PINK, not "coral" 2
Leah from Arizona
I ordered the coral color... the color looks like pink highlighter. There is no peach at all. Extremely disappointed. Two stars only because I like the formula.
Lovely product 5
Kells from WI
I've got this in Honey Do and wish I had it in more colors! I've got naturally full lips, so with this my lips look REALLY good. The strong peppermint sensation may not be for everyone though- I find it to be almost stronger than some Burt's Bees products. The shape of the applicator is really good too.
Good quality 5
Add from Bay Area, CA, USA
I got "Feel the Passion" and I think it's a little bright for my skin tone, I think the product is great, and I love mixing it with a darker shade!
One star as the color did not work with my Olive skin tone 1
Mrs.LCW from San Jose, CA
I love Buxom's plumping lip pencil and lip glosses. I was hoping this would work. With COVID protocols, I was unable to try this as a swatch on even a tissue paper. Therefore, I had to go buy the look in the container. It was too flat, too Barbie doll pink looking on. Pasty flat color. Returned it and purchased different Buxom lip shade in a gloss, Jessica. Beautiful color and works great alone or layered over a lip pencil, especially their lip pencil Dolly Danger.
Great color and texture 5
Lisa24hr from Cedar Park, TX
I really love this color and the coverage of this lipgloss.
is the color worth the chemical burn.. 3
Bre from USA
beautiful color, was hoping it would dry down at some point, definitely not transfer proof. when I was removing it I got a small portion of the product on one of my fingers and it gave me a chemical burn. my lips are fine, my finger is not.
Not long lasting 2
Mandy from Chicago
Color is nice and vibrant, but lip plumping not so much and it is more like a gloss than a lasting lipstick.
Best liquid Lipstick EVER 5
Buxom Girl from California
This shiny Lipstick is the best.
This product Is MY ALL TIME FAVORITE I
I purchased 6 of them in different colors.
Moisturizing, plumping and just amazing.
If I want to add high shine I add Buxom Gloss!
I will buy this product again 5
Brenda from Florida
First time trying this product and very pleased. It stays on longer than a regular lip gloss and doesn't feel heavy and sticky on your lips.
MUST try on at store 3
laura from NC
The colors look nothing like they do in the tubes. You really need to test them out or at least open them and see how the color is. Even the ulta employee was surprised when we tried to look for a good shade on me. Other than that it stays pretty well but bleeds some. use with a lip primer
Never buy again 1
Cookie135 from Dallas, Texas
This is not acceptable. It is not at all as advertised.
There is no moisture, No tingle, and does not last.
I will never buy this again.
Garbage Quality.
I would buy this again. Love Buxom products! 5
Nancy from Holbrook NY
Stays on well, no drip on lips, this red is a perfect red
No. I would not buy this product again 1
Deb9 from Tuscaloosa alabama
Did not like. Not right for me.
No 1
Karina from Chicago Il
More pink than it should look
Disappointed. Poor color description and awful feathering 1
jenneyBGCO from Denver, CO
I was so excited to try this product during the 21 Days of Beauty promotion. Unfortunately, due to the pandemic right now, we can't go into stores to test out colors so I had to go by verbal description and the online picture. I like nude peachy-pinks, so I went with "Russian To You" as it is called a "nude pink." I'm so sorry to say that it is a dreadful color with a white pasty base highlighted with some kind of florescent peach tone and a touch of gloss. It looks like a color from the 60s for a Femm-Bot in white patent leather go-go boots to wear in the Austin Powers movies. It's smooth and creamy - went on nicely, but then after an hour or so of wear, the pasty unnatural wall paint color was bleeding outside of my lip line into my skin. So now I look like a train wreck of a hussy. I don't mean to be a party pooper, but essentially, you would need a lip primer to make the product stay put. If I can exchange the product and try a different color with a primer, I might be happy. But for now, I'm pretty disappointed.
