Rated 4.66 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Pretty decent
At first I wasn't very impressed by the quality but after giving it a few more chances, I really like it. A few shades (the two lightest) are less pigmented than others but they are all above average drugstore quality. I would also like to add these are very high quality especially when comparing them to other "natural/clean" cosmetics a the same price point. The mattes are creamy and smooth and remind me of the one of Becca's Ombre Nude 5 pan palettes. The darker shimmers are lovely and pigmented.
I think this palette is best suited for someone with minimal needs. (Like, not looking for a full instaglam look.) It is versatile day to night for a casual user.
Most Helpful Critical Review Disappointed
I am not normally very picky with eyeshadows, but I cannot use this palette anymore. The fallout was dramatic, the light shades took three tries to even seem like they were on my eyelids at all, and anything darker than the base shades looked so muddy. It seems that most other people do not have these issues so I don't know if I got a weird one, but this is the first eye shadow palette I've ever just given up using.
Reviewed by 74 customers So pigmented I love the colors
Makeuplover from undisclosed
Beautiful I been using it every day since I got it
Mic from Nevada
Matte colors are wonderful and creamy. The shimmer colors need a bit more work but overall a lovely palette.
Eye shadow palette
Sara O from Rohnert Park, CA
These shadows are so silky smooth and they stay put without creasing! I love mine so much that I even bought one for three of my friends! They love it too.
Kaymae from Little Rock
So, first let me comment on the packaging. I was very pleasantly surprised that this was such nice packaging! And the shades inside are beautiful. The shimmers are the perfect formula! The pinkish color in the bottom right, I don't have a single dupe for in my collection (it isn't as basic as it looks). Very highly surprised and pleased with my purchase.
KelliP from undisclosed
Love the colors in this palette. Will be ordering again!
Dana from undisclosed
Great pallet. Have in warm too. Great pigment and very good staying power. Wish u would make a mat shadow pallet
DebraDancer from Arkansas
Ulta shipped this in a plastic envelope with no bubble wrap or any other kind of protective filler. The 2 large pans of shadow were a crumbled mess. So mad when I opened the box that I couldn't really tell you whether the shadows were pretty or not.
Can't Wait to try!
Lisa RN from Potomac, MD
Just received my p/y/t beauty Day to night eyeshadow palette! It is BEAUTIFUL. From the packaging to the feel of the compact, not slippery! Perfect size mirror to apply on the go. The neutral colors compliment every skin tone. Feels smooth. Can't wait to apply it!
pamhan from Florida
I love this pallet. You can layer and it looks great. Colors are perfect.
PERFECT COMBINATION OF COLORS
Lauriez626 from Owings Mills, MD
This pallette has the perfect combination of colors for both day and night use. I love the lighter colors for every day and the darker colors are perfect to add depth and dramatic effect. I also love the shimmer! This pallette is amazingly high quality at a reasonable price. In the past, I have purchased palettes by other brands and have hated that I had to replace them after using only one or two colors. Such a waste. This palette is wonderful and I love experimenting with different color combinations. Buy it! You'll thank me!
Made in China
Vegasbeauty from Vegas
Saw it was made in China. I do not trust the integrity of this product and thus it is getting returned.
Excellent eye palette
Multitasker from undisclosed
Love this product! Use it everyday. Brightens my eyes for full days on Zoom!
Kristine Z from Saint Louis, MO
Sadly my age group isn't very well represented in comments and reviews. I see many comments about the companies sending product for review from the younger women. That's great but I'd love to see more of that from my age group. I love PYT and I think the products are great quality. I even bought a spare of this pallete so I'm not without.
Dana from undisclosed
Super blown away by this pallet!! So glad I bought it!
Long lasting payoff
Plum kitten from NY
This is my favorite eyeshadow formula I have ever tried, clean and unclean brands. The colors are pigmented, beautiful, and they blend! Also they last! All day! There wasn't much fall out in the pan. I'm thrilled with this purchase
AG from Colorado
love love love love love!! colors are great, stays all day, does get smudgy or greasy, and it blends super well!!
anonymous from San Diego, Ca
Great colors! I also love how natural this brand is. I'm not looking to sacrifice great make up for a natural product.
The mattes outperform very high end shadows
AFKingValkyrie from Nj
I've tried viseart, natasha denona, and these MATTES are better. Holy frick, they smooth the eyelid, any texture anywhere is gone. I kinda wish they made face powders in this formula
Day to Night Palette - I use it every day!!
anonymous from undisclosed
This is an incredible palette. The colors are beautiful, blend beautifully and last all day. My make up at the end of the day looks almost like when I applied it. This never happens with my other palettes which include some popular ones. I love that it's also made with clean ingredients!!
Everyday go-to palette
anonymous from San francisco, CA
Amazing! First of all bravo to PYT for removing the talc from their ingredients. These shades are buttery soft and blend like a dream. If you're a neutrals kinda person, you'll love it. It's an everyday wearable palette but you can definitely get smokey eyed looks out of it. It's compact, has a nice sized mirror. There's no fallout, the wear time without a primer, on oily lids is 4 hours for me. I haven't found a clean beauty eye primer that works, so i stick with concealer and set with powder as a primer. Definitely highly recommend.
Great everyday palette (but don't drop it!)
Sue from Corvallis OR
I love this palette. Applies well, great everyday neutrals with some sparkly evening options, and it lasts. This is my second time purchasing this eye shadow—I dropped it the first time and the large palettes crumbled into powder, and I had to toss the whole thing. :(
a little hard to see pigments but amazing
Xitlalli from Oakland,CA
I have very sensitive eyes and I couldn't find a palette that didn't irritate my eyes but this palette did not irritate my eyes at all. It is a hypoallergenic palette which was super hard to find in other brands. The colors definitely come through after a while. Definitely will be buying the warm palette soon!!
easy to use - made me feel like a pro!
Katie from Philadelphia, PA
I don't normally wear eye shadow because I am terrible at applying it! This palette was easy to use, the simple suggestions on how and where on each part of eye were amazing - I feel like I know what I am doing! I love that I can add more color for a night time look.
Kenzie from Los Angeles, CA
A combination of matte and shimmer, neutral and extra, I can literally use these colors for every occasion. I'm not one to go all out on my eyes but using these colors adds a little (or a lot) extra, while looking effortless. Never buying a different brand ever again.
Perfect for every day
Jill from Palm Springs, CA
I just tried the eye shadow for a zoom meeting - and was so happy with how it brightened my eyes. I just used one of the pale, neutral shades and it went on well and made my eyes look like a better version of natural me.