Product Reviews Rated 3.43 out of 5 stars
515 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Amazing eyeliner The Thats the Point eyeliner is an awesome product! It creates amazing eyes with minimal effort! I appreciate the fact that it goes on flawless given my limited skills, and doesn't smudge or wear off. The product is priced well and the results are beautiful! Im in love!
Most Helpful Critical Review Giving it one more try I had high hopes for this product. I consistently do a winged look and I don't have time to try to perfect my wings before work. This product definitely made it a lot easier to get my winged look as well as be symmetrical (one of my biggest problems) However, the ink in this lasted a week. I am trying to give it the benefit of the doubt because I've used NYX liner before and it lasts months and months. I'm hoping this was just a defective one-off product.
Reviewed by 515 customers My go-to 4
Alli986 from U.S.
A lot of the comments on this are negative and honestly I'm not sure why. I purchased this about 3-4 months ago and wear it most days. The tip has gotten a little feathered but it still works really well. I love the thin lines that you can get from this, and the brush is really easy to use. I've tried NYX liners in the past and haven't been impressed until this one. I wish it was a little cheaper but I still think it's worth it!
My Favorite Liner! 5
CharlieFR00 from Alabama
This is my most favorite eyeliner ever! I use the super sketchy and have loved it from the start. The angled tip makes it easy to do thick or thin lines and I can get incredible wings with the tip. I will always recommend this liner. Only downside: occasional leakage. The bottom of the tip tends to bubble (literally) and pop which leaks on my hands, but I honestly don't care. It's such a good liner!
It Works For Me 5
Nol ❤️ from The Middle Of Nowhere
I'm very confused by the comments because I haven't had any trouble with mine yet. With that said I am very bad a eyeliner and I think this is good if you want to practice. Now one thing that I don't like it that it smears but I mean with the right makeup that could look good. I got PUT A WING ON IT and it works good. If you twist the end of the pen(?) it helps with the makeup coming out.
I will never buy this in "A Bit Edgy" again 1
Jaguar LaCreme from Chicago, IL
I made the mistake of buying this product in "A Bit Edgy" for the first and last time. The applicator tip was uncomfortable and difficult to use. The pigment itself was uneven and extremely difficult to apply, it went on sheer anytime the cap was off for more than 2 minutes. If you like to draw sharp, precise wings, don't buy this product in "A Bit Edgy". It was a complete waste of my time and money.
Do not buy 1
Sorry not sorry from Gainesville, GA
I only bought this because I was referred to buy it by an employee helping me. I normally use ELF liquid eyeliner because it works wonderfully but this product does not.
Awful 1
EOK from Atlanta
This is the first Nyx liner that I've purchased. I was intrigued by the marker concept and different tips. I thought it would make it easier to apply. This is the worst eyeliner I've ever purchased. It's totally see through. I thought maybe I bought a used product that's how light the pigment is. It's not easy to put on and bleeds like crazy. Don't waste your money.
Good eyeliner 3
Mel672 from undisclosed
I like the thinness of the brush, but it is very messy. I have hooded eyes so I thought it would help define my lash line.
Extremely faint 1
harv from undisclosed
I was so excited to try this because sometimes I have trouble with liquid eyeliner and thought the felt tip might make it easier. I ended up having to essentially apply my eyeliner twice; this was so faint, I just put my regular liquid liner on over it. Really disappointed.
Doesn't Work 1
pgrankin from undisclosed
I returned it immediately after I tried it once. It's almost completely transparent and I can't get a single wing out of it. Other eyeliners from this brand work great but this one is awful and completely unusable.
Trash 1
Madi from KS
This eyeliner is the worst eyeliner I've ever used. It doesn't stay on very long and isn't really pigmented, I loved other liners of nyx but I've noticed over the years they've became more hit and miss and this is definitely a fail.
Worked Once 1
Gaja from undisclosed
The first time I used this, it went on great and I was super pleased! The second time I used it, I couldn't get a line to save my life, even after pushing the tip against the cap a few times to try to moisten it with product. Pressing it against the back of my hand I managed to get a fat, sloppy, wet line, but anything with finesse or only using the amount of pressure I'd be willing to use on my eye got the vaguest of greyish streaks. Normally I love eyeliner markers, but this one just doesn't work.
Am I missing something? 1
Pyrothefox from undisclosed
Brand new and it goes on so transparent, am I missing something? It just seems like a complete waste of money from a brand that's had such good products...
Bought it, opened it, tip was dry as a bone 1
Victoria T from Indiana
Opened it the day I bought it, was excited to use it. Sadly the tip was dried out, even after shaking it, nothing!! Put it up in a cup tip down thinking the ink would flow to the tip and tried the next morning, still nothing coming out. Very disappointed customer!
Doesn't work 1
Unhappy customer101 from San Diego
I couldn't even get one use out of it. It was dried out as soon as I opened it. Wish I would have read the reviews before buying. Would like a refund.
Heck nah 1
Libby from Longview wa
within 10 minutes it was extremely smudged. Didn't go on smoothly and was not nearly black enough
Super disappointed 1
wingedit from Toronto
It barely has any colour, feels like it's dried out even though it's brand new. I use to love NYX eyeliner pens but they seem to now only last few a few weeks before they dry out. I store them properly and don't use much of the product so it's really disappointing. I never write bad reviews but I've never had a product from NYX be so incredibly disappointing.
Sucks 2
Katnip from California
One of the worst eyeliners of used, the tip dried out after a day and the liquid isn't going down the tip. I tried shaking it, rolling it, gently pressing the base of the tip with my nail to extract the liquid, still doesn't run down. I got so mad I aggressively hit it on my hand which kinda coated the tip for a second but immediately goes dry again. The color is not even good. It's very shiny and cheap looking, because it's so hard to put on it ends up looking caked on and gross. I would never recommend this. I hate it so much.
this eyeliner didn't work 3
Axe from Passaic
Axe
Waste of money 1
Sad customer from undisclosed
Really wanted to like this. The shape and texture of the brush got my hopes up, but disappointed upon application. Color was barely visible, maybe I bought a dried out product :( wish I could return.
Love this eyeliner so much!!! 5
Love from Highland
I fell in love with this eyeliner
I would buy it again! 4
Bella from Pleasanthill
I really like this eyeliner it stays on all day without having to keep replying it. It also washes off good with mild face soap
Dried out 1
emdub from undisclosed
It came dried out when I first got it. Not impressed.
Dry 1
Z from GA
Dried after 2 uses. How hard is it to make a fabric tip that doesn't dry out immediately :/
First time trying it and I love it 5
PurpleFlare from Pacoima, CA
My everyday eyeliner
Would Not Repurchase 1
Jenn from Arlington, VA
I bought a brand new one in store. Completely dried out and couldn't even get one use out of it.
