Rated 4.68 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Great formula and great neutral colors.
If you are considering buying these, I say go for it. These are smooth and buttery, easy to blend, and stay put very well (even without primer). I did not notice any fading until many hours later. I cannot speak for the entire color range, but I will tell you that I purchased Grind, Shakedown, Dame and Pokerface. Grind, Shakedown and Dame are gorgeous neutrals that have a beautiful metallic sheen. Pokerface has more 'shimmer' so to speak. I actually don't wear neutrals too often (I'm more of a 'color' fan or dark eye look fan), but I absolutely love these neutral colors every time I put them on. The only thing that I can see someone possibly taking issue with is that they are not 'super duper' pigmented; so if you would in fact rather have super rich pigmentation you should probably stick to Urban Decay. I personally love these neutral colors in this formulation offered by Tarte. The only reason that I have not purchased every single color is that many of the colors are warm toned. (If you like warm tones, get on the horn and buy these!!) I will say, though, that even being a person with a neutral-to-cool toned face, the neutral shades that I purchased are still wearable and flattering on me. Highly recommended.
Most Helpful Critical Review Kinda disappointed
I use only Tarte eyeshadows because I have sensitive eyelids and I thought I would try one of these. I was looking around online and thought the Dark Seas (navy blue) was really pretty so I ordered it and once I got it and tried out the next day, I really liked the silky texture, however, it wasn't really dark when I put it on and didn't want to blend out too well. after a few minutes, it started fading off and creasing really bad. I didn't think it looked that good on me. I tried using it with my other eyeshadows but I just couldn't make it work. I have been trying to figure it out but I just cant. Really disappointed, I think I will give it to someone that would look better in it.
Reviewed by 108 customers Wow
Rebecca from Sweet home, AL
I had never tried these shadows from tarte before. I want them all now! Formula is amazing and color payoff is gorgeous!
Beautiful METALLIC Shades! that break easily
OneCueT from OKC, OK
I started with the shades: Amethyst, Blue Seas, & Jade. I liked them so much I bought them all. The Revel shade is warm toned red meaning a orange red. Scarlet is a cool toned burgundy. All shades are packed with pigment.
Broken on arrival
Frequent online shopper from Mount Dora, FL
This is an online only order, and when I opened the product the eye shadow was broken. The glittery eye shadow was all over my floor and kitchen counter. What a mess! The color (clueless) is nice and what I expected, but it's not very well constructed. If you purchase this product, you can expect a sloppy mess when you open it.
don't buy if you expect it to be red!
T from Columbus,Ohio
I recently ordered this b/c to wanted a shimmery red shadow. but when I opened it it's this orangey color not even a hint of red. very dissatisfied!
Deeterbox from Myrtle Beach, sc
Deeterbox from Myrtle beach, sc
Looks good on fair skin too
Mom of 4 from Redlands, CA
I like the color. I was hoping for a little more intensity. It wasn't as vibrant as I thought it would be.
Only eyeshadow I use
Girl mom from Greenwood, AR
This is the only eyeshadow I wear anymore. It lasts all day.
I would buy again and again!
Speak from Ks
Purchased Pin Up. The color is amazing!
Denise from Uxbridge, MA
I have very sensitive skin and don't like to use products with a lot chemicals in them. The salesperson was very helpful and recommended a couple different brands. When she showed me Tart I was very apprehensive to try this. I'm used to a Cover Girl pallet with 3 different colors to apply. I'm so glad I took the chance. The shadow goes on very nice and I get my look in a lot less time.
LOOOOVE this shado
Sunny D from Knoxville, TN
I wear this shadow almost everyday. On the off chance I forget to remove my makeup the night before, I wake up and the shadow is still in place which speaks volumes for the long lasting color! I get compliments all the time on the shade (pokerface).
Stunt Doll from Tucson, Arizona
I got this in the color jade and it is so beautiful. Formula is silky and packs a punch in pigment. I like that you can pop out the colors and add it to a single shadow pallet.
Jag33 from St Louis, Mo
Really like this shadow. Use it to open & highlight my eyes.
Goes on well.......
Kay from Michigan
I received the shade Shake Down as a gift and I am so completely impressed. I swatched it once and was interested but left it on a shelf for three months while I continued using my favorite metallic shadows instead. Big mistake. This is the most pigmented metallic shadow I've ever used *without* needing setting spray. Love putting it over a soft neutral shadow to add something extra to my everyday look.
I liked this sooo much! Cute xD
Alice Taylor from Austin, TX
I really liked this. I got vintage and it's soo pretty. It's very smooth and there is a lot of product
Really nice formula can't vouch for the other colors but vintage is beautiful
Sooze from KY
Love it! It give me a "little sparkle"!!! Even a Grammy needs some sparkle!
Wish it was cheaper, but I love it!
Denise from Kansas
I love the shadow and use it daily. It's expendive to me for the size of the shadow.
Rachael Rae from Yakima, WA.
This was exactly what I needed.
Love at first sight
Missy from new jersey
The eyeshadow is great, it's creamy, and blends out really well, and its SO pigmented! I love it! Thank you tarte!
Nic from Albany, ny
I bought amethyst and this picture doesn't reflect the real color at all! Really pretty lilac or lavender shadow and the packaging is sturdy with a cute mirror. The shadow performance is great too
Best shadow singles ever
Hmarie from Lincoln Nebraska
I have a few colors of these and they're all wonderful. But my absolute, all time favorite is the pin up shade, it's an warm champagne that doubles as the most beautiful highlighter. I use this with every look I create, it's the perfect inner corner/brow bone shade. It works with cool and warm looks. It's so creamy and pigmented and blends seamlessly, very little fallout, I can't say eniugh good things about these shadows. It is one of the only high end shades I have ever had to repurchase regularly.
Robomama from Anchorage Alaska
I love how rich this shadow is.. almost too pigmented. A little goes a long way!
Perfect everyday color
Yogakel from Pittsburgh, Pa
Easy to apply. Doesn't crumble or flake everywhere.
I would buy again.
Carol from Big Bend WI
I apply on my lower eyelids after applying foundation &a lighter lid color.
Lizzie from Illinois
This is a good color to add as a finishing touch to your eye look. It adds that little bit of sparkle without going overboard.