Rated 4.2 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review This eyeliner has an...
This eyeliner has an incredible buttery formula that glides onto everything like a dream, has great pigment, and stays on for a decent amount of time. This eyeliner would be my new favorite, but I can't figure out how to get more product. There isn't something to twist at the bottom, and the pencil appears to be made out of plastic, so I doubt shaving it down would do much. I tried to look at the packaging for instructions but couldn't find any. Other than that, this product worked great for me.
Most Helpful Critical Review Great liner one the first few uses... then useless
Loved this eyeliner and was so excited to have found a new eyeliner that really did stay on and didn't smudge.... HOWEVER, once the tip got dull and had to be sharpened, it has never been the same. The tip falls apart and I still cannot get it sharpened enough for using again. This sucks because it's a brand new liner that I can't use- and I have go out and find another to takes its place. Revlon please remake this eyeliner with a better "vehicle" (pencil) that can be easily sharpened.
I gave 3 stars because when it works, it's actually a great liner, if you can get it to sharpen...
Reviewed by 851 customers Does not sharpen
hotfox82 from Peoria, Illinois
I love how great it works until you have to sharpen it. It is impossible to sharpen. Wish they could fix the problem. I do recommend this product until the problem gets fixed.
Best eye liner that I have ever used
Jan b from Australia
Great product, glides on beautifully, stays on all day and night and does not smudge.
I have brought 3 and each winder ends up not working after 6 applications, leaving heaps of product still in pencil unable to use
Haley from Kansas City, KS
Did a man make this eyeliner? Sigh. You can use it a handful (small handful) of times and then you're out of luck! Can't sharpen it. What a waste of money. Loved it the few times I was able to use it.
Michelle from Cincinnati
Its an amazing product that you don't get your money's worth. What is showing is all you get. No twist, no sharpening, and etc. Would continue to buy if i actually got more than two weeks worth of eyeliner because once you use it that long the tip is no longer at a point.
this stuff is amazing
suburbansyndicate from undisclosed
this stuff is amazing I'm not one for pencil liners but I really enjoyed this one it went on really smooth it stayed on for a long time and for the price you can't beat it
BKH from Birmingham AL
I was experiencing the same problem many had experienced with this product. After a few usages it needed sharpening and a regular sharpener wouldn't work. I remembered that I had an electric sharpener hidden away in the closet and thought I would try it. It WORKED! I don't know if the case on this pencil harmed my sharpener but at least I can use the liner again. Just wanted to share.
That wonderful eyeliner does
edgarydinagomez from undisclosed
That wonderful eyeliner does not run, does not water your eyes 100% recommended.
I love revlon cosmetics
LM makeup from Winnipeg Manitoba
Loved this at first but when it came up to sharpen it was impossible. So upset. Need to go find a new product.
a5jsburke from texaa
i bought this because all the stores were out of the revlon eye liner i use. i do like this eye liner, but when i tried to sharpen the pencil, the tip was destroyed and would not sharpen. i won't buy this one again.
Sharpens fine with a good sharpener
Nutmegger from CT
This is a really nice eyeliner with great staying power. It is true that the wood like plastic is hard but it is completely easy to sharpen with a good quality Eye pencil sharpener. I bought the brown color and it is gorgeous with my brown eyes.
Gw66 from Santa Fe, TX
Love how easy it applies but once it gets dull it is done for. Please re-do the pencil so that you can either sharpen it or twist up
One Use Only!
MaryMac from New Jersey
Once this eyeliner needs to be sharpened it's done! If it could be sharpened the liner would be great. At the very least create a sharpener specifically to sharpen it.
Nola from Oklahoma
I looked on this site to see if there was a way to sharpen this eyeliner. Was sad to see that no one had been able to do that successfully.
Won't sharpen, doesn't blend
No from undisclosed
I tried to sharpen this and that was my mistake. It's too soft and just makes a mess all over the place, breaks and wastes the product. If you let it hit the air for even 10 seconds on your eye, you can't blend it. Horrible. Never again.
Don't Waste Your Money
Hamptons903 from Illinois
This was great for two uses and then, as so many others have noted, I tried to sharpen it and it was completely destroyed. Super weird. It should be zero stars, but it looked good twice.
Shakedown from Walla walla
I have a heavy hooded eye lid this doesnt transfer to my upper lid all day it stays where I put it. Wont ever buy another brand. Its incredible I am still amazed everyday. If I could rate it a 10 star rating I would.
cyd from undisclosed
I bought this because I thought it might be a nice eyeliner that did not smudge. It was so difficult to get out of the package and once I did, the tip broke off as soon as I touched it to my lower lid. Then, it is impossible to sharpen. Worthless product. I have no idea if the actual eyeliner is any good, the packaging and lack of ability to be able to sharpen it, make it worthless. I wish I had kept the package.
Angel61 from Olive Branch, MS
I like the eyeliner but it's almost impossible to sharpen. I wasted half of the pencil trying to get a sharp point. Very disappointed and I won't buy this again. Do not recommend.
Emilia from Alaska
dose not dry down
I would and will buy this again!!!!!
Nancy from Western Washington
I was so surprised at how easy this application is. I expected it to be on the hard pencil side. But this is soft and glides on without jumping. I am going to try more colors now that I know the ease of application
I do like the look of...
danielle475 from undisclosed
I do like the look of Revlon So Fierce Vinyl eyeliner when it is first applied, it has a very bold, dark black satin look. However shortly after it does smudge & needs to be touched up often. It makes my eyes water and misses spots that it won't fill in. Also the pencil needs to be sharpened frequently. It doesn't sharpen with the Revlon sharpener either, it only works with the Loreal pencil sharpener. Do not waste your money on this.
It can't be sharpened
FMUP from Ohio
It's great when you first use it, but once it wears down it can't be sharpened! So basically you are paying a lot of money for a few uses.
Easy to apply and last
Bonnie from undisclosed
I love the product, but you cannot sharpen it ) : and if it is improved I will purchase it again. Also if it could be in a little lighter shade of brown.
Great liner HORRIBLE design
Deborah from Calaveras County CA
I bought this a week ago and the tip is already dull. Tried to sharpen it but the liner is too soft to get another tip. I wasted a good portion of it before I gave up. I read that someone put theirs in the freezer before sharpening and it helped a little. The only reason I gave it 2 stars instead of 1 is because the liner itself is wonderful. I would have loved to use it more than a week before it became useless!
Ksinsight from Upstate NY
It really does last for hours and hours