Product Reviews Rated 4.2 out of 5 stars
1691 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review I love these! Theses are by far my favorite eyeliner pencils. They're super soft, pigmented, don't crumble when I use them, and one they set, they SET. I have no eyelid transfer with them and they even do a pretty good job of staying put in my waterline, which is tricky. So far I have them in black, silver, both purples, turquoise, blue, both greens, and bronze and I honestly would like to collect all of them!
Most Helpful Critical Review Eh I bought this product sometime in the summertime and when I received them I was excited to use them. However when I tried to use them, they did not glide on smoothly and instead tugged on my eyelids. I also had to go over it multiple times to get the color that was advertised. Overall, I enjoyed the coloring but I would not purchase again, unless I knew the product would work as advertised.
Reviewed by 1691 customers Love how this goes on. Slides rt on! 5
angstl from St. Louis, MO
Great color. Soooo easy to apply. Will be buying additional colors.
My favorite waterproof eye pencil 5
PeggyO from Rockville MD
This purchase is the third NYX waterproof eye pencil that I've made this year. I wanted to try a different color. This purple is vibrant and looks amazing on my eyes. I love how the color stays and doesn't disappear. I look forward to finding more colors in this eye pencil.
excellent 5
angie from San Diego, CA
Excellent liner for the water line. love it. goes on very smooth.
THE best 5
Ashley from Chicago
Dare I say, holy grail?! I tried this pencil years ago when I was trying to find dupes for my expensive favorites... dead ringer for UD 24/7 Glide. I possibly like it even more! No issues sharpening. No issues crumbling. I get every millimeter of use! And I use heavy eyeliner 5 out of 7 days a week, at least!
Not waterproof 2
Fry from PA
I do love the color of this eyeliner however, it claims to be waterproof and it is not. I will continue to use it on my top lid just to use it until gone but will not buy it again. I purchased L'Oréal Infallible and that is truly waterproof.
Love It! (And how-to sharpen tip!) 5
Drea from Memphis, TN
Great color payoff in just one glide of the pencil across my lids, especially considering the price point.
And YES, you absolutely CAN sharpen this type of pencil! You just need to buy a cosmetic sharpener that works with both wood AND plastic pencils. Maybelline and Revlon make great ones. Get every penny's worth!!!
great! 4
v from atl
long lasting, waterproof and smudge proof! i use the white one for my waterline. however, there are some things i noticed. maybe my eyes are watery but it takes a few swipes for the color to show on my lower waterline. and by the end of the day it's smudged off. it shows up on my lash line though. also wish there was an easier way to sharpen it! other than that tho it's definitely waterproof and long lasting.
Everyone loves this "flourescent" color on my lower lid. 5
Urban Naturalist from Chicago, IL
I use it this vibrant, flourescent purple color on my lower lide and everyone loves it and comments on it. The pencil is creamy, goes on smoothly, and lasts a long time. An affordable makeup treat.
Color payoff is disappointing in this shade 3
Vikki from West Virginia
The color payoff was way less than I expected.
I will be buying this product Again 5
Scovie from California
Went on prefect & smooth.
Love lines 5
Soureview from Atlanta ga
I use it to line my upper and lower lids, otherwise, my eyes disappear
Waste of money 1
Kim from Ga
Can't sharpen!!!
LOVE these!! I own almost every color! 5
Salina from Gainesville, Fl
There isn't anything to say except what are you waiting for?
1st time to try it! I wore it yesterday stayed on all day! 5
Gigi #6 from Tupelo, Ms.
I wore this yesterday! Great product! It stayed on all day! Awesome price!
Not terrible 3
Star from Jacksonville NC
It glides on great, but doesn't last. When applied, it's very dark & dramatic. I just wish it actually stayed on.
Waterproof Maybe, But Not Smudge-Proof 3
T.Cat from KY
The intensity of the color is perfect- super dark. The claim that it is waterproof is questionable; I apply to the top lash line and I find it in the inner corners of my lower lash line. I was looking for something that stayed in place of application only- this could come with a smudger and be more satisfactory for that purpose.
Needs one minor tweak 4
Christie O. from Charlotte, NC
I love how this pencil glides on. My only issue with this product is that it is not a pencil that extends by rolling it up after a while of use. That means you have to buy these much more often, which is annoying.
Love this eyeliner. 5
Nancy B from Scottsdale
Been using this for years.
Better than any other I have tried 5
Angie from Chicago
I have tried SO MANY liners and this one glides one the smoothest, most consistent, and stays on when lining my wet line (or tight line) than all others I have tried. I use the black one the most but did buy a full kit of about 10 colors.
Inexpensive and effective 4
Reggae Rey from Cleveland,OH
Day and evening- Glam, classic
I will buy this again and again and again! 5
Rob from Fort Worth, TX
This is a great eyeliner at a great price. Love it!
Works great and love the color 5
rach from New York
I use this on my eyes and I love the color. Makes my eyes stand out.
Love 5
Mel from OR
I got this for my moms friend and she fell inlove with it
Pretty good 4
kayra123 from Baltimore, MD
easy to put on, nice vibrant color. good price
It won't sharpen 1
JennLR from California
I cannot sharpen it. The coverage is great but after the initial use I've been unable to use it due to it not sharpening.
