Product Reviews Rated 4.25 out of 5 stars
2244 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Stays put no running.I... Stays put no running.I can even use on my waterline with contacts!!.Glides on and great pigmentation.Plus the price is awesome.The Brown is a nice shade.Black too.LOVE! my search is over
Most Helpful Critical Review Long lasting but difficult to apply This is not my favorite liner but I still keep it in my makeup bag because it is long lasting and doesn't fade after wearing it all day. It is not creamy enough to easily apply to the top lid and the pigment isn't strong enough to stay on the waterline. Personally I like to use the Nyx matte liquid liner on my top lid and then I put it on the outer corner of my lower lashes and smudge it out. I think this liner works pretty well for a good smokey eye. I would say that this product is a good addition to your makeup collection but you might want to look elsewhere if you are just looking for a more versatile liner.
Reviewed by 2244 customers Would not buy again 2
Psyche from Va beach Va
Love the gunmetal gaze color but. NOT retractable..even using pliers. It will not turn..also did not last was gone after 4 hours wear..since I cannot turn retractor won't be able to use it for long…try to turn the tester before you buy..disappointed. Gave it 2 stars for awesome color of this pencil
Love these; have numerous colors 5
Dion from Newark
I have sensitive skin, including eyes. These are only one of two brands of eyeliners that don't irritate my eyes. I use them on my inner rims and on my lower lash line. Application is easy and the product is long-lasting. I've been using these for years and will continue to do so.
Love these; have numerous colors 5
Dion from Newark
I have sensitive skin, including eyes. These are only one of two brands of eyeliners that don't irritate my eyes. I use them on my inner rims and on my lower lash line. Application is easy and the product is long-lasting. I've been using these for years and will continue to do so.
I will buy again. 5
Kris from Myrtle Beach, SC
I think it's good the way it is.
Love the color!!! 5
Color mama from Logan, UT
I've been using this line of product for a while now and I highly suggest it if you want something affordable and quality color! It's soft and doesn't hurt your eye when applying.
Didn't work for me 1
Janna from San Bernardino
I really wanted to like this one, but it didn't work for me. Doesn't apply easily, it smudges and flakes and it irritated my waterline.
I would buy this product again. 5
Lucy from Michigan
I find this product easy to put on. It stays in place all day and the color is great.
COLOR REALLY POPS 5
K9Carr from Sacramento, CA
I have used the NYX Professional Eye liner pencils for years. My recent trip to Ulta I saw this purple and even though it is the mechanical and not the pencil I decided to try it and I really like it - I might be switching to the mechanical (less mess than sharpening an eye liner pencil). It goes on great, stays on great and this purple is way better than ANY purple I have purchased in the pencil! The color makes my eyes really pop!
I'm going to return it 2
Jes from Idaho
It went on really smooth but smudged off by the end of the day from my top eyelid so I had racoon eyes and no one told me.
I buy this product all the time 5
Chasity from Rochelle, IL
Product is great all around
Nyx eteliner 5
Gigi from Pgh. Pa
Great product for the price.
Should be given a try.
New daily essential 5
Jordyn does her face from Marietta, GA
Brings out the different hues in my brown eyes and eyelashes, also makes my eyes look larger and more inviting. I used to wear a different color but I pair this liner with a voluminous purple mascara as well and it can go dressy or casual, works for any occasion!
This product is a must have! 5
Tee from Chesapeake, VA
I wore this an an eyeliner along with an eye shadow and liquid eyeliner of the same hue and received multiple compliments. The eyeliner is very pigmented and goes on smooth. Will definitely purchase again.
Happy eyes 5
Happy Eyes from Milford Pa
Great product that's easy to use
Beautiful green liner but smears 3
Wendyf70 from Kirkland WA
Goes on easily but gel liners smear too much. Sadly tho since the color is nice.
Nice 5
Brookie657 from Maine
I love this brand and I have not yet got to try this but I have high hopes!
Good product for the price 4
Natasha from USA
I have this eyeliner in black and dark brown. It's a good quality liner at a very affordable price. It's a reasonably soft formula so you don't have to press very hard in order to draw a pigmented line, but it's not the most soft formula I've ever tried either. It's also acceptably long-lasting but not amazingly so. The component contains a good amount of product so it'll last you a few months even if you use it daily. Overall, a good drugstore eyeliner.
yes 5
mj from home
get it, i use it on my waterline and it's the best. makes my eyes pop and is very pigmented. very easy to apply !
I am picky and I like this eyeliner! 5
Wisty from Longview, Texas
I have had my share of navy eyeliners that "melt" off but this stays in place. Will buy again.
I like it alot 5
Kellie from las vegas
it glides on so nicely!!
Doesn't smudge.
I use it often.
Too dry!! 1
Paige from Humble
Way to dry and lasted no time at all!
Affordable, cruelty-free, & waterproof! 5
Hummingbird44 from Lakewood, CO
Have 3 colors in this eyeliner: grey, bronze, & brown. Like them all! Appreciate their gentleness & cruelty-free status. Wear well.
It is average 3
Saafa A from NC
It did not glide on smoothly the first couple of times. I found myself applying a lot of pressure. After a couple passes it looked wearable.
Amazing eyeliner!! 5
Morgan from Arizona
I used this product on the inner corner of my eye and blended it out and it looked amazing! it pairs well with a highlighter if you want your eyes to pop more and I also used it on my lower waterline. It elevated my eye look and made my brown eyes pop.
Definitely would not buy this again 2
Loving makeup from Tucson, AZ
I love the color but it breaks off into chunks when applying it. Smooth texture, I've tried the white as well but same chunks when applying.