Product Reviews Rated 4.26 out of 5 stars
314 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review I love felt tip liners! I adore felt tip liners, I've been using the Maybelline Stilleto liquid eyeliner for years but recently I've had problems with the formula in the pens. I bought this on a whim because the Ulta brand is BOGO 50% off. I even swatched it in the store on my hand and it lasted on my hand until the next day, even with me washing my hands. Removes easily with my micellar cleansing makeup remover, though. I like how dark the product applies, but if you mess up on your eyelid it is a pain to remove. If you don't mess up, though, that's a wonderful factor! I have a hard time applying a wing with this product because of the placement of the applicator where the felt tip comes out of, it gets in my way. I'm hoping I'll get the hang of not hitting that part to my eye, because I like this eyeliner and its tiny felt tip. Color pigment is great and its long lasting.
Most Helpful Critical Review Nice tip This product goes in very smoothe, doesn't dry matte tho. It stays glossy, I don't like that. Other wise the product is very easy to apply and has a great small felt tip , makes wing eyeliner perfect!
Reviewed by 314 customers Don't pass on this 5
CM from OR
Solid deep black color. Glide's without skipping. Helps with cat eyes or graphic liner looks. Truly love this eyeliner. Better than the original one. Buy this instead! Love it 😊
Precision perfection 5
Broken arm beauty savior from FL
Perfect for precision. Had a broken arm & application easy
Couldn't get it to work 1
Melanie from Ulta
I never really write reviews since everyone's experiences are so different, but I really enjoy reading them so thought I'd give my input. I could NOT get this to work, I shook it a lot but it still bled so bad! Even testing on my hand (in case it just didn't work over eyeshadow) and it spread out and flooded into my hand lines. I've never had an eyeliner do that before! I'm glad it was only 9 dollars, but I can't use mine so to the trash it goes.
Transferred Everywhere 1
#TeamCap from IL
Thank God I tried this on at night after getting home from work and didn't wear it out for the first time. It never truly dried down. I wore it for a few hours. It ended up transferring to my crease and upper lid, and when I touched the line with my finger, it transferred there too and the color wore off completely. My eyelids were bare and didn't have any product on them other than mascara and this liner. I think the natural oils on my eyelid broke this liner down. The felt tip was also inconsistent; at some points, a lot came out, while at others I had to go over it again to get the right amount of pigment. It's hands down the worst eyeliner I have ever used. I will be returning this.
Makes a nice thin line 5
u2debb from Baltimore, Md
The liner is thin and easy to use. Would like to have it water proof
burns my eyes 3
Lotus from Phx,AZ
I may be allergic to this which is new to me .. def. a new feeling when using eyeliner
I am 40 and this is a first in the burning eyes after using a product .... hate it . wish I could love it ...
Pretty decent liner 4
bmelko from Detroit, MI
I much prefer felt tip liners to the ones with the brushes since I don't have a very steady hand. This liner is decent, but I'll be looking for something better. The finish is too shiny for my taste and it doesn't have very good staying power in my experience. It's perfectly opaque when it's first applied and it's easy to apply because of the felt tip, but it doesn't hold up well for me. I wear it under my false lashes, so that could be partly why it doesn't work for me, so I gave it 4 stars instead of the 3 I wanted to give it since it might work better without the lashes.
Smudges all day 1
Jennifer from Milwaukee
Went on smooth, which was promising. But I had eyeliner all over my face hours after applying because I barely touched my eye. This made a huge mess to clean up and it doesn't come off well, considering it can't stay in one place. Be prepared to scrub your eyes for what seems like forever before bed.
Great product! 5
GoalDigger77 from Visalia
I love this eyeliner pen. Better than gel eyeliner and easier to control when applying than liquid liner. Plus, it lasts all day! Price is great. I will definitely purchase this item again and again.
Love it 5
Barb from Auburn, Maine
This is a great eyeliner. It goes on smoothly.
Really surprised me in a good way! 5
Jess from Boston, MA
Purchased this in late January- been using high eye eyeliners for years (tarte, benefit, IT cosmetics) was pleasantly surprised at the quality of this both in formula and packaging! I use eyeliner 5 days a week and still haven't needed to replace almost 3 months later. Works well for wings too! Easy to control whether I want a thin or dramatic liner
love the micro bendable tip 5
Robyn from NJ
I love the micro tip because I don't like a thick line. It is slightly bendable which helps for a smooth and easy application. You need steady hands though to get a good line. will definitely be my go-to from now on. I use after applying Ulta matte eye primer which I also love!
Get what ya pay for 3
Smithed from Baltimore
I give up on this eyeliner. When I wore it alone, making just a tiny wing, it spread into every line in my eyelid and outer corner. If I used it on my eyelid, after putting on shadow and primer, the area near the inner corner would smudge and block and look awful. But last night. Last night, with a full face of make up on, the color came out in a blob. As if I were holding a highlighter to a piece of paper and watching the paper suck up the wet ink. Over it.
eh 3
jess from n/a
it works but comes out spotty
I would buy this product again. Would like it in dark brown 4
JP from Mesa, AZ
Great micro tip.
Please make this micro tip in dark brown
Love this product 5
Haileyw331 from North Carolina
This product is excellent for easy application and a liner that is smudge proof. I love how it isn't easy to come off with water but it isn't water proof. Definitely would recommend!
love it!! 5
Juliet from co
so perfect and I love how dark it is
Great opacity and easy to use 4
Ashton from Maryland
This eyeliner is great for a quick wing or just a simple line.
Love it!! Had it for about 7 months before it ran out!😎 5
Libby long liner from Texas
Definitely recommend for first time felt tip users!
My favorite eyeliner 5
MaddyB from VA
This eyeliner is great. It lasts all day and does not smudge on me. I only use this on my top lid. I always apply the ulta matte eyeshadow primer (because eyelids get oily and will make makeup crease and move), so for anyone struggling with it smudging, try using a mattifying eyeshadow primer. I prefer the micro tipped ones. It really helps me get a good small wing and they're also more bendable at the tip than the classic liners. I own several of both types and change it up depending on my look. I have never had one dry up on me and I've been using these products for over a year.
Don't waste your money 1
Retail Momma from CA
I can't even get this micro eyeliner to apply. I needed something small for my lower lash line, but it was a huge disappointment.
New Favorite Eye Liner 5
KPi from Port Richey, FL
Love the black eye liner. Easy to apply. Looks good everytime!
You get what you pay for 1
Taylor from Iowa
Not long lasting at all. Don't waste your time, it smudged within the hour
Great 5
Smashly from Warren oh
Long lasting, does the job
my fav eyeliner 5
maya from bay area
fine point is great for eyeliner to get very sharp lines and once it dries out it's PERFECT for dipping into eyeshadow and creating different colorful winged liner looks