Product Reviews Rated 4.0 out of 5 stars
503 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review My Go-To Eyeliner I'm on my 5th pen so far and I have to say it's probably the best eyeliner I've used. I find that it's very easy to clean up if your wing doesn't come out perfect on the first try, the color is very pigmented, it glides smoothly, doesn't smear or rub off unless you literally rub your eye then of course it will leave a streak. Everyone always asks me what eyeliner I use or how I'm able to get my wing so sharp, and I tell them that I use this.
My 2 main cons with this is that if you use it a lot, it does tend to dry out within 2-3 months. Then, by that time, as you're applying, it will take a couple of tries before any product can come out. But I suppose that goes with most eyeliners that dry out.
Conclusion is that the pros definitely outweigh the cons. I prefer this over the Kat Von D or any other drugstore brand i've tried.
Most Helpful Critical Review Don't buy it! I have purchased a few of these. A few of them have lasted up to two weeks and the new one I purchased lasted for 4 applications. I have shaken the wand and tried to clean it but it still doesn't work. This is now one of my least favorite eyeliners. My Kat Von D lasted for months.
Reviewed by 503 customers Color isn't bold enough and it doesn't last 1
Bel from AR
I have been used at least 30 brands of eyeliners on the market, I have to say I'm so disappointed with this eyeliner. I thought L'Oreal all infallible line products should be pretty good, I love their foundation, powder lipsticks etc, but this liner fails. The color is not opaque and it's run off just after 2 hours on my eyelid and I don't have oil skin. Also the tip is really hash and not slim enough, not easy to glide on. I'll be back to my physician formula and kiss me eyeliners. Not recommend it at all.
Doesn't last 1
Cilla from California
I've purchased the brown one two times. Both times I opened it, they were dry. The black ones lasted about a week before they became dry as well
Stopped Working 1
Ashley from California
This product was super promising- great pigment, user friendly applicator, long lasting formula…until it stopped working. I got maybe 1-2 uses before I stopped being able to use it easily; it still works but I have to use it on the side of the applicator and can't do more than 1-2 swipes which is super annoying and not what anyone wants from a product. I'm really disappointed at how poor this has been functioning because it would've been an otherwise great product :(
Dries Out Super Fast 1
Mary from TX
This product is wonderful when it is brand new and for the first use but when I went to use this product for a second time it was already dried out and difficult to use and get a precise line. I would love this eyeliner if it didn't dry out so fast.
I really like this product. 5
Joann from TX
I've been using this product for some time. I really do like it. It does not smudge on me. A problem I had with other eyeliners. Not this one.
ran out of ink so fast 2
karomalina66 from Md
I don't know if I got a bad batch but the first time I used it, it went on great on eye until it stopped giving out ink like if it was all gone and I couldn't get to my other eye... well I worked with it. but it smudge and stayed on for hours!
NOT FOR ME 2
Minnn from Texas
this eyeliner has really great pigment and goes on nice however it will smudge like CRAZY. Don't wear this eyeliner if you have watery eyes or if you're going to be sweating because it will go all over the place. I bought it based on the reviews but it's definitely not 12 hour wear. Wet n wild has a better eyeliner and it's cheaper. I have the shade black, I'm not sure how the other colors work.
The BEST eyeliner I have found! 5
fritters from Texas
Love the smooth, silky formula. No dragging or pulling - just a smooth line every time.
Nice fine line 5
Grandma6 from Kingsport, TN
Goes on easy. Line is thin but you can correct your booboos.
Buy something else 2
Abby from Tx
Would not buy this again. The eyeliner skips when you apply it and when I try to go back and fix the patchiness it just rubs off the eyeliner that's already there. It doesn't stay on the lid in general. I've come home with half my wing missing every time. The eyeliner pen also dries out quickly. It might be because the caps fits very loosely and doesn't snap shut no matter how hard you press down.
One of the best liquid eyeliners I've ever purchased! 4
Dani from NC, USA
After straying to try out some others, this is now my go-to liquid eyeliner. I used to always wear Maybelline Stiletto in brown/black, but like every other product I love, it was discontinued, and so have been on the hunt for a new brown. I first had to buy it in a drugstore in a pinch since I'd forgotten my makeup on a weekend trip (and a girl has got to have her eyeliner, am I right?). The color is GORGEOUS, and I've been hooked ever since. I had always worn black eyeliner, but for an everyday look, brown was just a bit softer. I would call this one brown/black as it is quite dark and wouldn't be distinguishable from black to most people. I bought a different brown liquid eyeliner recently (why are they SO hard to find?!?!?!) and it was just a light, icky shade of brown, so this one is back to the top of my list. It goes on smooth (even in the very beginning, it's not too thick), and even near of the end of its life, it doesn't clump. The only reason I gave it 4 stars was because I felt like it ran out quickly (but that could have been my usage!). Regardless, even if it ran out twice as fast as a different brand, I would gladly purchase more of these!
Side note, I always draw a pretty good sized cat-eye, and this worked wonderfully to create the smooth curves. PLEASE DON'T EVER DISCONTINUE THIS!
Just not the best 3
Isabel W from Dover, DE
I've been using this liner for a couple months but I haven't really liked it. It's good for an hour or two but after that it smudges and transfers to the top of my lid when I do bold eyeliner looks. It also fades very quickly, even when setting it with black shadow. There are just a lot more better options than this product.
My Favorite Eyeliner 5
Christin57 from Missouri
This eyeliner clearly defines your eyes and lasts better than any other eyeliner I have tried. Easy-to-use applicator, as well.
Love this eyeliner, easy to apply. 5
Joey from PA
This eyeliner wears all day without smudging.
It's eh 1
rose from Menifee
It applies okay but, the tip dries out, and the cap feels loose and it also smudges. Which I hate when eyeliner smudges by just a slight touch, so I don't recommend but I do recommend the Maybelline hyper easy liquid pen. It applies smoothly and doesn't smudge.
favorite liquid liner 5
Ms Ann from Greenville NC
I like how you can make it look bold or natural depending how you hold it
Unreliable 2
mataLin from DC
It was fine for the first week but seemed to dry out and the tip began to fray quickly. Drags and skips a lot. If you can get it to apply correctly, it seems to have decent staying power for about 10-12 hours, wears out on the lids after that. Not a dupe for Stila Stay All Day liners though.
Felt tip frays and dries up 1
Carmen from United States
I love L'Oréal products but this liner was a hot mess. The cap gets loose after a couple uses and falls off. The felt tip frays after the liner is closed and the precise tip wears down until it is no longer "super slim". This product picks up any eyeshadow you're wearing and dries up. If you wipe the powder off on your hand you can get it going again but only for part of a swipe.
I DO LIKE THIS PRODUCT 5
BEBE from DANVILLE
IT IS EASY TO PUT ON
Waste of Money! 2
TMD2 from Hawaii
I love L'Oréal's Flash Cat Eyeliner so I thought I would give this one a try. It's awful!
Worst Eyeliner I've tried 1
Lin from Goodyear, AZ
This eyeliner is pretty expensive for a drugstore eyeliner especially considering how poorly it works. Would hardly call it slim. I must have got one of the drier ones being the color sometimes wouldn't even come off. It was very patchy and difficult to work with, I couldn't flick my eyeliner because either nothing would show up or it would leave a blob of color at the ends of my eyes.
Love! 5
Dawn from Stl
This eyeliner is superb! It goes on super thin or as thick as you like AND stays out all day. It's as good (if not better) than anything in a department store
not for double lidded eyes 1
liz from kentucky
super easy to apply but within minutes of wearing it it's already left a blackish line at the top of my eyelids. And yes I made sure the eyeliner was completely dry before opening my eyes completely.
Terrible! 1
Rawross from Tucson
Terrible! The product comes out unevenly... sometimes not at all and other times heavy. The brush is harder to control than other brush on eyeliners I have used. The cap feels loose and falls off. Waste of money.
MY GO TO LINER 3
Hoodedeyesarejustshy from Los Angeles
Let's make this clear. I haven't tried a TON of liquid eyeliners but have tried the best seller high end ones to tell you I would choose this one so far over anything. WHY 3 STARS? Keep in mind For the countless of years for me doing a wing liner I've never seem to perfect it, And always have to fix. With that said.
PROS:
-Great for liquid eyeliner beginners!
-Easy to fix mistakes with damp q-tip
-steady felt tip for precision
-very thin consistency to build up or touch up
-Does not flake like other liquid eyeliners
-Nice matte finish
-Lasts a good while (use a few times within the week can last me 4 months or longer)
-If not used for a while will not dry up.
CONS:
-smudge proof? Yes and no. (With hooded oily eyelids like me. When I pat my eyelid with translucent powder and more onto the eyeliner. I've gone out dancing for hours and have it not smudge on me. When I have not done this properly it does transfer and create that black line on the crease. BUT has NEVER smudged where it deforms the eyeliner where I've applied in anyway.
-felt tip can get shredded and dry a bit too soon. (I simply cut a tiny bit on the tip in a slant so the product can come through again)
There ya go.