Product Reviews Rated 4.37 out of 5 stars
27 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Best lipsticks!! These Buxom lipsticks are beautiful! I originally purchased the shade Goddess which is a nude so when I heard that they released 4 more nude shades I rushed over to get my hands on them. I ended up purchasing the shades Heartthrob and Fly Girl, both shades are perfect for me. Heartthrob is a similar shade to Goddess but it's a little lighter and Fly Girl is exactly as described, a peachy beige. The formula is smooth and creamy, and plumping in the sense that it fills in my fine lines. Don't expect any actually make my lips bigger plumping because it's not that at all but it does give a fullness to my lips that I absolutely love. There is a sweet minty smell along with a slight cooling sensation after applied which I quite like. Overall I will continue to purchase these as long as they keep making them.
Most Helpful Critical Review Pretty color but wouldn't buy again The color Supermodel is pretty and it feels creamy. I don't plan to wear everyday because it doesn't stay on long and I didn't see a real difference in my lips being plumped up. Keeping it because I hate doing returns but wouldn't buy again.
Reviewed by 27 customers New fav! 5
avery from california
i am not a lipstick wearer anymore because of masks, but this formula is worth having to reapply! i really enjoy the color range and have found it to be great with any sort of lip liner i use.
Excellent 5
RK from New York, NY
This does not disappoint. The formula is creamy, the coverage is great, my lips do actually appear plumped, and the shade I got (Supermodel) is perfectly rosy brown and effortlessly 90s. So many lipsticks dry out my lips, but this one keeps them hydrated.
New Favorite! 5
KB from Tampa
I first purchased this lipstick in the shade Fly Girl and loved the color and formula so much that I bought Goddess, Influencer, Heartthrob and Icon during the 21 days of beauty sale. Each color is beautiful and it's hard picking a favorite. I was pretty loyal to Charlotte Tilbury lipsticks but Buxom are my new favorites! I hope they keep expanding the line! Also, every product I've tried from Buxom this past year has been amazing! The blushes are so beautiful that I own all 6 colors, the bronzer is perfect, I love the highlighter in White Russian, and their liquid lipstick in Taupe it Off is my favorite liquid formula! I can't believe I'm now only discovering how great this brand is.
FLASHBACK to BETTER TIMES! 5
WinterStars from NY NY
90's inspired in deed! Very impressive, Absolutely love this collection! Might wind up getting all of them
Found my new fav! 5
Me! from Kansas
Love wearing nude shades and this did not disappoint!
yesssss 5
e from p
heartthrob is the nude of my dreams. thank you for this.
The best lipstick shade ever! 5
chalamet890 from USA
This lipstick is amazing and so beautiful on! I have medium/deep skin and the shade "angel" is so pretty on! It really does look like the 90s supermodels makeup looks which I love. Totally recommend! Pair it with a lipliner and it looks so gorgeous. It also applies really smoothly.
I was not a fan of the color 1
Jen from Boaz, Al
I didn't personally care for the color.
Best Nude Lipstick! 5
Bananna from Boston, MA
I love this lipstick so much. I wear it all the time since I got it, it feels so soothing as well, I'll even wear it like a lip moisturizer. It looks great and makes my lips look smooth instead of cracked and dry(like some lip colors do). The color I am wearing is "Hearthrob" and I absolutely LOVE it.
Great nudes 4
Sarah from US
I love bullet lipsticks, and this is almost perfect! It's creamy, opaque, and long-lasting. The only downside is the tingly effect (the "plumping" effect, I guess). It doesn't plump my lips, and it feels like toothpaste I forgot to rinse off. Kind of minty, so that's a plus ? Otherwise, this lipstick is a winner!
Great Lipstick! Love Buxom 5
Maryb from Sherman, Texas
Love Buxom products! The colors are beautiful. My skin is a medium olive. I purchased supermodel and love it! I wish it had more staying power but application is great!
Love 😍 5
Nerak from Sycamore, IL
Great full color that lasts and moisturizes
I've found the perfect nude for fair skin! 5
Kay from Texas
I've been trying to find the perfect lipstick for my skin tone and Heartthrob is a true nude! It goes on super creamy and is very pigmented. You only need a few swipes for full color. It smells like sweet candy too but not at all overpowering. The pros are: it felt tingly on the lips but honestly didn't plump my lips at all. I also wish there was more product for the price point but overall I'm really happy!
New favorite! 5
Shannon from Utah
Love this formula and color!
LOVE 5
hwilson from Novi MI
This is the perfect satin comfortable lipstick. It glides on smoothly but isn't too shiny or too matte. I really don't think it has any plumping benefits other than a strong minty feeling.
Irritated my lips 2
Mars from Texas
Loved the color but it irritated my lips so bad! My lips got extremely dry and the corner of my lips cracked after using this.
Love this lipstick! 5
SherryR from Belleville, IL
The shade Supermodel is a beautiful rose shade that is neutral. Long lasting and beautiful pigmentation. Plan to buy more colors.
Pretty color but wouldn't buy again 3
Psoto7 from Mcallen, Texas
The color Supermodel is pretty and it feels creamy. I don't plan to wear everyday because it doesn't stay on long and I didn't see a real difference in my lips being plumped up. Keeping it because I hate doing returns but wouldn't buy again.
I really like this lipstick 4
Vix from Cape May NJ
Buxom makes great lipsticks. This one is moisturizing and the nude shades are pretty.
I didn't notice any plumping.
Great lipstick 5
Cindy from Columbia, SC
Love the nude color & it conditions your lips
Medium Skin 5
Erin from Los Angels
If you're anything close to an NC40 this color is super flattering! It's exactly what I expected Velvet Teddy to look like the first time I tried it. Velvet teddy pulls super pink on me unlike this one which is perfect!
Best lipsticks!! 5
Makeuploverbyday from Pflugerville TX
These Buxom lipsticks are beautiful! I originally purchased the shade Goddess which is a nude so when I heard that they released 4 more nude shades I rushed over to get my hands on them. I ended up purchasing the shades Heartthrob and Fly Girl, both shades are perfect for me. Heartthrob is a similar shade to Goddess but it's a little lighter and Fly Girl is exactly as described, a peachy beige. The formula is smooth and creamy, and plumping in the sense that it fills in my fine lines. Don't expect any actually make my lips bigger plumping because it's not that at all but it does give a fullness to my lips that I absolutely love. There is a sweet minty smell along with a slight cooling sensation after applied which I quite like. Overall I will continue to purchase these as long as they keep making them.
Perfect Nude 5
Holly GoLightly from TX
This is the perfect nude for me! I love the consistency...it's nice and creamy and doesn't dry out my lips. It also has a pleasant scent that isn't overwhelming. The tingling sensation is much more subtle than with the glosses. I love this lipstick, and I normally hate lipsticks.
no I'm returning it...it tore up my lips 1
carla from Michigan
irritating to my lips
Amazing!!! 5
Amanda from Omaha, Nebraska
Gorgeous shade variety. Lovely selection of various nude shades. Applies very smoothly. The packaging is very nice and detailed. Very high quality and moisturizing. Long lasting as well. Great color pay off. I'd definitely buy this in other shades and recommend it to others!