Product Reviews Rated 3.16 out of 5 stars
73 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Great product! I like this eyeliner very easy to apply, it doen't make any mess;
Also it stay over 5 hours.
I really love it.
Thank you Ulta for carring this amazing product in your store!
100% recomended
Most Helpful Critical Review Lasts about 5 minutes Does not last. I was exited to try it, came home and put it on. Nice rich deep black, but like when I tried to go over it once, it kind of crumbled. Did a wing to test it, folded some laundry, looked in the mirror and it was smudged all down my eye. Terrible product. It doesn't claim to be waterproof or anything, but it does claim long lasting which is a bold faced lie.
Reviewed by 73 customers sheer and wipes off sooo easily! 2
amangogo from gilroy
my first few times using it was okay. The color is not very bold, super sheer but application is easy. Today however, the eyeliner completely melted off and left sloppy eyeliner prints right under my eyes.
Horrible dried the first use 1
Bri from Arizona
I hated it the first Eye i did was ok then the second it was dry i tried shaking it pressing it and nothing!
So sheer 2
Kilika from Ulta on brokaw in SJ, CA
The only thing I liked about it was the tip. It was really pointy, but other than that the color was so sheer and even if you put 3 coats it's still so sheer. :(
Love the color hate the application 3
Sdee from San Diego ca
The tip is too short. I love the color. I want more flow out of my felt tip pen. (I love the L'Oréal one)
the design is good, the color itself was a disappointment 3
desperada from Nebraska
when I bought this, I was super excited about the color and the fact it was a felt tip. I love LA girl eyeliners smooth application and the bold colors so I expected the same with the felt liner. It was definitely lacking compared to their other eyeliners. I have used it several times since purchase and each time I have to do literally 4 or 5 layers to even get remotely any pigment to really show. when it does However the color is gorgeous and metallic like advertised; it just takes patience to get that end result.
Pretty bad 2
Ellie from Wisconsin
It lasted a week and it dried out! Plus the sharp tip? Yeah that broke. Awful will not purchase ever again.
Worst Liquid Liner 2
mrgdr3 from San Diego, CA
The only good things about this liner are the price and the tip. It's easy to apply but it's not very pigmented and it doesn't last more than an hour - even with primed eyes + eyeshadow. I used it by itself (I get oily lids) and it was a hot mess. I do NOT recommend.
It was pretty good but I wouldn't buy again 3
Mer from State college pa
It was super easy to put on which was nice. It's got a good angle / firmness to the felt tip to get you a crisp line. The only issue is that the color is super pale & I had thought it was bolder.
Love this product & yes, I'd buy it again. 5
A ghost from Dallas, Texas
Love the color.
This product is not as pigmented. 2
Jellybear from Texas
I used this product as an eyeliner. I tried to over layer it to see the color and still no good.
Not a fan 1
Lyss from Nj
The liquid liner is just terrible. Doesn't glide on nicely and feels dry.
Perfect application every time 5
Eyetech from Florida
Tried this on a whim because of the price point. It goes on so smooth, it lasts all day and then comes off without too much harsh rubbing.
Lasts about 5 minutes 1
Miranda from Dayton OH
Does not last. I was exited to try it, came home and put it on. Nice rich deep black, but like when I tried to go over it once, it kind of crumbled. Did a wing to test it, folded some laundry, looked in the mirror and it was smudged all down my eye. Terrible product. It doesn't claim to be waterproof or anything, but it does claim long lasting which is a bold faced lie.
Save your money! Absolutely no pigment 1
Ashley from Wichita, KS
I like to give cheaper brands a chance but man this was terrible! No pigment at all!
not worth a dolla 3
rachel from Ocean Springs
I threw this away, it was not pigmented at all and leaky
I like it very much 5
Gabriele from Pittsburgh, PA
The color is perfect for my blue/green eyes. Handles very well with a very fine line. Dries quickly, stays on despite swimming/diving every 3 days.
Cheap but Just as Good 5
Carito from Reno, NV
It's cheaper than other name brand products but it works just as well. Stays one all day, doesn't smudge and easy to apply.
Really Bad 1
sstorm2 from Pittsburgh, PA
I've been using liquid liners for 15 years and this is the worst one I've ever used. It can't handle marking over eyeshadow it dries out and it's hard to get a smooth dark line. The color payout is poor. You need to go over it several times for it to show up, which is very difficult when doing a winged look. I went out and just bought NYX Epic Ink, night and day better.
Not worth it... 1
Emily from Virginia
You get what you pay for, but in all honesty, this product works like something that is priced at $0.99. Barely any color pay off; before you can even establish any sort of line, it dries out. You're better off with the Colourpop felt tip eyeliners, they actually preform very well and come in a larger selection of colors for around the same price point.
Don't waste your money 1
Becki from PA
I purchased blue and purple, as both colors are pretty they are so hard to apply because they are so dry. You basically get one use out of them.
Dark brown is actually black 1
aprilsauce from New Jersey
The tip is perfect for creating a fine line. I ordered the shade dark brown and it's actually black, which is not what I wanted. Making thicker lines thins out the product which makes it look watery and less pigmented. Would not purchase again.
Pretty good for the price 4
Me from Southern Pines, NC
This was okay... not quite as dark as I would've liked, but it did stay all day and didn't run or flake.
Love! 4
JBC91 from Dallas, TX
I love the 'gel' eyeliners that dry and do not smudge! A lot of brands only carry black or maybe brown. NYX had some colors but seems they discontinued them. I needed a new purple liner and this is great. Fine line is buildable while still damp. I hope it is not like other felt tip liners that dry out quickly.
amazing eyeliner 5
amazing eyeliner from Baltimore
this eyeliner lasts for over 24 hours without creasing or smudging. perfect for all occasions. I love this eyeliner!! goes in SO SMOOTHLY.
Perfect fine line!! 5
Shawnsqueenb from Orlando
Love this product. Nice thin line and lasts all day.