Product Reviews Rated 4.37 out of 5 stars
567 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review This Pencil LASTS! I can never find a nude pencil to stay on my water line. Usually, by the time I finish my make up, my water line's naked again. I was so impressed with the color, creamy formula and staying power of this product. I actually had some left to wash off at the end of the day. I'm preparing to order the brown one and the green. Can't give this one enough praise.
Most Helpful Critical Review Does not last all day I got this eye pencil because I was told that it was the best long lasting eyeliner for a lower price. The color is great and it is bold. I mainly wanted to use it for my waterline but I was disappointed when I looked in the mirror in the middle of the day and saw that it had smudged/disappeared. How is this waterproof if it runs and does not last? I guess you get what you pay for :(.
Reviewed by 567 customers Love it! Only eyeliner I can use on my waterline 5
Nina đź’‹ from Chicago
I've used high end and drugstore eyeliners but this one is the best for the price in my opinion. I keep seeing reviews about sharpening being hard but I use a regular eyeliner sharpener and it's never been a problem. It's wood at the base but has a coating on the outside. I highly recommend trying it out I've been using these for years . Mostly use it for my waterline. It's waterproof and stays put as long as you give it enough time to set, after that you can blink as much as you want lol
Great eye liner pencil! 5
Jbea from Cincinnati
I've been using liquid eyeliner for years because I couldn't find a pencil with staying power. This pencil glides on and stays put all day! And the price- fantastic buy!
Love this! 5
Lola from Ohio
I use this under my eyes to make them look bigger and it just gives my eyes a nicer look, since my eyes are more almond shape when I have a darker eyeshadow on my eyes tend to look smaller. It's so creamy and soft I love it
Essence 5
Maryam from 1
Absolutely amazing long lasting and it's like butter on your eyes you don't even feel it I have the nude and it's such a perfect colour!!!
Love this! 5
Lyd from New Hampton iowa
Only eyeliner I will ever use.
Amazing!! 5
sam from tn
this is one of my favorite liners. super pigmented and glides on so easily
Okay 3
Anna from Us
I got this for my waterline bc my regular eyeliner never stays on there. It stays better but still not that good. By a few hours it's just left on the very outside of my waterline
Amazing !! 5
Tiba from Las Vegas
Really long lasting and vibrant in the eye. It's suuper smooth and easy to apply. Personally, I had no sensitivity to it at all. It's a couple dollars I say give it a try.
Creamy, Long Lasting 5
Kelsey from Mi
These are pigmented, creamy, long lasting eyeliners. I won't buy anything more expensive because these are so, so good!
Loved this eyeliner 5
NatashahZZ from Washington
This is a fantastic affordable, long lasting, blendable eyeliner. I tried using a sharpener I already had and it didn't work. Went back and bought the Essence sharpener and it worked like a charm!
No go for my sensitive eyes 2
Eve from Milwaukee
I wanted to love this after searching for a nude eye liner to brighten my eyes with, instead I had a horrible reaction to it. Red, irritated, watery eyes, & runny nose. The color was perfect & stayed in place all day, just not a good product for me
Would not recommend 2
ulta fan from united states
First of all, I have no idea how to sharpen plastic. Second, it's not as long-wearing as it claims to be and slides off onto under eyes.
Not again 1
Trickytracy from Kcmo
2nd one that's broke like that. It's a good thing they are cheap. But if they work one time it doesn't t matter if they are free. I loved the one I had that didn't break immediately.
Works Okay!! 2
Mags from Flagstaff
I would give it a 5 if I knew how to sharpen it……MASSIVELY CONFUSED with this product.
Great for waterline and cut crease 5
Velvet from Cincinnati
Got the nude color and it looks great and lasts a while. Looks cute under a black winged look and makes cut crease easy. Product is creamy and color payoff is surprising
lasts fine 4
dirk from trexlertown
i use this in my waterline everyday and it lasts. only downside is sharpening it is a pain in the rear.
Long Lasting 5
Back Roads from Minnesota
I prefer eye liner pencils that need to be sharpened with a sharpener since I can control the sharpness and the liner doesn't seem to break as easily. My go to eyeliner pencil brand was around $20. When the brand I was buying discontinued the item I was using, I tried several other brands in that same price point. All of them didn't last and left me with black circles under my eyes. Then I discovered Essence Extreme Lasting. Wow, this is the best eye liner I have ever used! It sharpens easily, glides on smoothly and lasts until I take it off. The black midnight sky color is a beautiful color with just a touch of sparkle. I can't believe I can get all of this for such a low price!
Bring back the green! 5
Dani from PA
The Nighttime in the Jungle eyeliner was my all time favorite with my hazel eyes. I miss it so much! Bring it back Essence!
Nothing better for the value 5
Chelsy from Ohio
Glides on effortlessly. After a second or two to really try down it doesn't budge. Full pigment
Disappointed 1
san from Apple Vally Ca
yes if it wasn't broken so I could use it. Disappointed that Ulta would sell something that was not working.
Love this liner!!! I little tricky to sharpen. Luv the liner 5
Jillian from Scottsdale
Luv it!!!
Great liner and can't beat the price 5
Bre from California
I got this nude liner and one from Kylie Cosmetics and after comparing the two the one from Essence was just as good, if not better. Its long lasting and definitely waterproof. A little yellow in pigment but makes the eye look bright and awake. I have sensitive eyes, especially with liner in the waterline but it didn't cause any dryness.
Great color with no longevity 2
Step from Texas
Although this makes my brown eyes pop, it only does so for a short period. Reapplication is necessary if wanting the color to maintain its opacity. There is no smudging. Overall, it's a less than mediocre product that is good for those that don't mind their eyeliner fading.
Great product for the price 5
BRobinson from Mt Juliet, TN
I've used this product for a few days now and love it. The texture is creamy and it stays where I put it. I need eyeliner that doesn't move with my oily skin and this does the trick.
Affordable, Better Than Prestige 5
LorettaR from Kentucky
I use this to line waterline and top lid…such rich color, stays all say….super pleased!
