Rated 4.46 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Best Eye Pencil Around
I've been using the Double Wear for more than a year now. There are less costly eye liners, but they smudge and I wind up with "racoon eyes" at the end of the day. Estee Lauder's Doube Wear does not do this -- it has "staying power."
Most Helpful Critical Review Not Quite Right Eye Liner Pencil
I am sorry to say that I am disappointed in the new Double Wear Stay in Place Eye Liner Pencils. I have been purchasing Estee Lauder products for quite some time and this pencil has been changed somehow in the formula. It does not seem to glide on as smoothly and looks patchy when applied, necessitating going over it several times. I also would suggest that you get the Khaki color back in...it was the perfect color for women with Hazel colored eyes and no other cosmetic line has one...plenty of blacks and browns and trendy colors, but no true Khaki. I tried your Olive Lustre and it is too luminous for us more mature women...meaning it shows the lines and imperfections of the skin near the eye. Please get Khaki back in a flat color....you made a huge mistake in discontinuing it.
Reviewed by 780 customers Great Liner
DJ from Pittsburgh, PA
This was my first try of this liner and I love it. I am older and concerned about being gentle to my eye area. This liner goes on very smooth and easily and it stays on all day - really! I just went to the beach and it stayed on all day.
Staple to my makeup collection
Sxb990 from DuBois PA
I have been wearing estee liner for years. It's perfect for every occasion! No smear no smudge for me ! It is a true staple to my makeup collection! 15 plus years I have been wearing !
Good Lip Liner
Suzanne from Alabama
Very much like the Double Wear Lip Pencil, have used them for years. They do not feather, and wear for long periods of time. My only negative is having to purchase the sharpener, and it's difficult to get the point of the pencil back. But the pencil itself overrides that, have purchased multiple colors.
Best on the market
Carole from Boca Raton
I've tried other brands but prefer EL's. Its soft, I just have to get use to its ability to smudge without my intention of doing so.
Amy T from North Richland Hills, TX
This eyeliner stays in place all day!
really love it
JINGXING from Portland
I used the sample and really love it
The only one i use
Rocio from Kennesaw GA
Love it. Love the color. Not found anywhere else
Silver & Eye dropping!
Ellie from Cranston, RI
Double wear eye pencil is the only pencil for 50 and up! It goes on like silk and stays on ALL DAY! Don't go out without it!
Start making Coral again!!!!
KAS from Sarasota, Florida
You used to have the coral lipliner! Why do you no longer have it!!!!
Raye from Gulfport, MS
I was gifted a sample of this eyeliner and I love it so much I bought the full size here. brilliant formula, doesn't tug or pull, the color is deep and stays for a decent amount of time
Smudges and does not sharpen properly
Mary from denver, colorado
From what i can tell it is too soft. It will not sharpen to a point, it's hard to sharpen AND it leaves smudges under my eyes after a short time. I give it a 3 because i like the color.
Double wear lip liner
Mcan from Longview, WA
I love this liner! It's easy to use and stays in place without feathering my lip products!
Liner is a Disappointment
Mary from Stevensville
This liner is impossible to sharpen. It doesn't fit into an Estee Lauder Pencil Sharpener. Trying to sharpen it on a regular lead pencil sharpener leaves it with rough edges. Unusable! At this point it is useless.
WR from Menifee, CA
I have been using this pencil for years. Smooth application and smudging tip is perfect.
favorite eye pencil
Elena from Fernandina Beach, FL
This goes on smooth, stays on all day, and nice color. The only reason I rated a 4 instead of 5 is because when there was about a 1/3 of it remaining it was difficult to sharpen with the Estee Lauder sharpener. Not sure if it was the sharpener or the pencil. I re-ordered the liner because I like it a lot and bought a generic sharpener...so we'll see.
MotorcycleMommy from Fayetteville, Ga
Goes on smooth, lots of color. I own two and I'll probably get more!
Owllady from LOS Angeles
I own several of these lip liners in assorted shades...they do stay on even when my lipstick has worn away! easy to use, great colors...
It's very good
liaoshichen from PORTLAND
I love it
Smears all over
Tina from CA
I used to love the night diamond shade. Such a nice, soft black with a hint of sparkle. Something has changed with this however. It just smears all over my eyelid almost immediately after applying. Caught a glimpse in my rear view mirror and was horrified how awful it looked. Absolutely nothing long wearing about this product. I stopped using it and also noticed my eyes stopped feeling irritated and watery. I thought it was allergies but clearly it was from this eyeliner. I don't know what happened to it but I won't be using it anymore.
Not what it used to be
LiseyStar from Waltham, MA
About a decade ago these things were the bomb and truly "stayed in place." The brown color isn't bad but the black is more like a kohl pencil. Very messy and causes raccoon eyes. Even with the lightest touch you get too much product drawn on. Very difficult to manipulate.
Light Brown will be Nice
Lena from Edmond, OK
Brown is very popular color and this pencil has only COFFEE in brown shade category and it is VERY dark brown. Can the manufacturer add a lighter shade of brown? For people with light complexion it looks very dark, almost black.
Sorry just can't
Daynamarie from New Castle CO
I usually love Estee Lauder products. It was hard for me to spend this much money on an eye pencil.
I've been using liquid eyeliner for 25 years at least because I need waterproof , smudge proof, this was definitely not Smudgeproof, I love the color of the burgundy
Deme from Tbilisi,Georgia
I use this lip pencil in two cases, just to paint the lip and to apply lipstick easily.Does not move on the mask and is comfortable during Covid 19 :).
Best eye liner
Stacey from Linwood, MI
The texture of this eyeliner is so smooth and the color (burgundy suede) goes so well with my green eyes. It really makes them POP! It glides on so easily and blends beautifully. I can't believe I've been putting up with subpar liners. I definitely recommend it and will buy it again in more shades.
Tink from Mid mi
I have actually purchased about 5 of these. I recently had got purple, night diamond, cobalt, emerald, onyx, and burgendy suede which has become my new go to. I use to use bare minerals make up bit am making a switch to Estée Lauder on a friends recommendation. I fo hope it works out since Its not cheap. But so far I really do like it