Product Reviews Rated 3.0 out of 5 stars
17 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Love it I'm in love with this product as a go-to for quick make-up application or touch ups. It feels really refreshing going on and glides on smoothly. The only drawbacks are that it tends to crease over time, so I set it with a powder. It also doesn't work well with eyeliner; however, it's perfect for days when you just want a more natural look. I got the Perfect Harmony. I think it goes well with all skin tones.
Most Helpful Critical Review Stings your eyes, creases fast and has almost no color Skip this product! There is nothing good about it. The worst part is that the "cooling" effect will sting your eyes if it slides into the corners — and that is likely to happen because it creases FAST. It even creases a bit on top of primer (Benefit "Stay, Don't Stray). But there's no reason to even go to the trouble of applying it on top of primer because the "color" is nearly invisible. "Golden Days" looks like a pink shimmer in the stick, but it's really just the FAINTEST hint of gold shimmer once you put it on your eyes. It doesn't look like you're wearing eyeshadow at all.
Honestly, I don't know how this product made it past R&D. I never return cosmetics, but I'll probably return this one. I figure the more people who do that, the faster they'll pull the product so nobody else has to waste time and money on it.
Reviewed by 17 customers "Cooling" menthol makes my eyes water 1
Lala from Michigan
Unwearable- makes my eyes water terribly.
Colour seems spot on. 4
Nope from U.S.A.
Love the colour. Can't wait to use it. Glides on very nice in swatches.
I would by again 5
Ash from Wilmington nc
For Halloween costume
Great summer find! 5
Makeup minimalist from South Jersey
Love this as a quick "swipe-on/ blend with your finger" eye brightener or highlighter. The right amount of shimmer or light catcher without being frosty.
Pretty colors 2
LynneM from WA
The colors are very pretty, but this eyeshadow rubbed off on me right away.
Love it 4
JMB from SC
I'm in love with this product as a go-to for quick make-up application or touch ups. It feels really refreshing going on and glides on smoothly. The only drawbacks are that it tends to crease over time, so I set it with a powder. It also doesn't work well with eyeliner; however, it's perfect for days when you just want a more natural look. I got the Perfect Harmony. I think it goes well with all skin tones.
I would not buy this product again 1
Barbara from Tabernacle NJ
If I could return this item, I would. It's easy to apply but it cakes up quickly. Not worth the purchase.
Golden Days is Great 5
Sassyflapper from Arizona
I thought I'd try this product since it was on sale. I was pleasantly surprised. The color is a nice pink shimmer which gives a hint of cooling but does not irritate my eyes. I do hope Ulta continues to carry and even increase this line. I would recommend this product for women of all skin shades.
Will not buy again. 1
Piets2of4 from Tennessee
Burns eyes!
Purchased Perfect Harmony 1
Tab from Summersville, WV
It doesn't glide on smoothly and it does not blend well at all. The color is very shiny and a strange color pink on my olive skin tone. Wasn't flattering on me at all. I used my usual eye primer (Urban Decay) before applying and it creased and settled into my fines lines. Product melted within 4 hours of wear. Sorry to say I will be returning.
Terrible 1
JC from New Jersey
Doesn't have much color pay off. Creases and moved into the corner of my eye which made it burn and sting like crazy! My eyes burned and watered for like 5 minutes straight. Something that is meant for your eyes shouldn't have such bad effects if it accidentally gets in a little.
great value, great for blending 5
desperada from Nebraska
I love the color, and how well it blends with glitter, liquid eyeshadow and powder. I also love the price!
Love it and would buy it again. 5
db from IN
Love the way it looks and feels as an eyeshadow.
Stings your eyes, creases fast and has almost no color 1
SavvyShopperGal from Portland
Skip this product! There is nothing good about it. The worst part is that the "cooling" effect will sting your eyes if it slides into the corners — and that is likely to happen because it creases FAST. It even creases a bit on top of primer (Benefit "Stay, Don't Stray). But there's no reason to even go to the trouble of applying it on top of primer because the "color" is nearly invisible. "Golden Days" looks like a pink shimmer in the stick, but it's really just the FAINTEST hint of gold shimmer once you put it on your eyes. It doesn't look like you're wearing eyeshadow at all.
Honestly, I don't know how this product made it past R&D. I never return cosmetics, but I'll probably return this one. I figure the more people who do that, the faster they'll pull the product so nobody else has to waste time and money on it.
Do NOT use on or near your waterline 3
Heather from PA
Used on eyelids it's fine and looks rather nice.
I used on my waterline and it immediately felt as though I had put Vicks Vapor Rub into the my eyes!!! It was a full 5 minutes of tearing and rubbing before the feeling subsided. The tube does say "do not use in the immediate eye area" which I always think is strange when we are talking about a product marketed for the eyes. Unfortunately I didn't read that until after I used it. Bottom line... use with caution! Only on the eyelids.
Love, love it! 5
kisbell6 from AR
Such a pretty pastel color and works wonderfully as a base. Love the cooling effect.
could have been nice 2
eh from Illinois
smooth and creamy application reminiscent of the Laura mercier caviar sticks. light cooling sensation that would be very pleasant during allergy season or the peak of summer. Dry down takes forever and then it wipes down to nothing. tranfers like crazy. I gave 2 stars for nice application but that's where any compliments end. Go for the elf eyeshadow sticks, not only are they $3 cheaper, but they actually dry down and stay put.