Rated 3.31 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review I love the maybelline shadow pen
I only use shadow pens/crayons and I am so glad maybeline has a version now! I like the colors. It would be good to have some matte Creme colors without so much sparkle/metallic. I can't wear any that have red undertones or I look sick so some Additional color options would be great!
Most Helpful Critical Review Wand is too short.
I should have read the reviews first. I was surprised to see how short the wand was and dry the tip of the applicator was. According to your pictures on your website it looks like this wand has the foam applicator and a pen like shape on the other end. At any rate, I'll need to use a q-tip to get the rest of the product out. Next time, I'll just get shadow in the palette type container. Not impressed with this product.
Reviewed by 483 customers Maybelline missed this one
Sara D from San Antonio
I bought this not realizing it was a sponge applicator. Sponge application products notoriously dry out quickly, and this is no exception. It is lovely the first few times you use it, then a few days after you have to press so hard to get product transfer that it wipes up whatever you're applying it on top of. Throwing these away.
Tube is empty
OliviaGB from Seattle. WA
I thought I had bought a previously returned item since there was nothing in it when I got home to try it. I'm glad I read these reviews before exchanging it for another one. It's a shame because I love the concept and the applicator. Sadly, I will not purchase or recommend this product to anyone.
daphne23 from Chicago
No product in the tube. Dipping and twisting produces zero product. Needs a complete redesign!
Gay Howard from Sydney, Australia
I am very disappointed with this product, I brought 1 week ago & have used no more than 5 times & found it hard to get any further applications from the tube. Very disappointing.
I am returning this to store.
SusieQ from Painesville, Ohio
Terrible product. Was extremely disappointed. What a waste of money.
3 stars for the color
CCsells from Florida
1st one I bought I thought it was my fault that this product went dry...maybe I left the applicator (loosely) opened. So I bought another one (in fact 2 of them) , again same results! There is little to nothing in these tunes! I love the color #40 (Rally) but the amount you get is ridiculous for the price. Very disappointed.
want different colors
Luanne from wisconsin
could you make this eyestick in like a powder blue/grey/grey blue
Anna from Santa Ana
There's literally nothing in a tube. Not a good pigmentation, you have to scoop 20 times before you actually get enough (like on the ad picture)
Opened it to find it empty!
Kaitlyn2021 from Boston MA
I was so excited about this but when I got home and opened it the tube was empty! I am incredibly disappointed. There was literally nothing in the tube and the wand looked like it hadn't been touched by any product. Waste of money and I'm still upset about it.
My tube was empty??!!
McStein from Michigan
I paid a lot of money for nothing in the tube. I kept thinking it was user error somehow, but I couldn't get any on the wand to apply to my eyelid. Now reading the reviews I see I'm not the only one. Won't buy again.
You can get this product cheaper at another store
mildred from Georgia
Can get this product cheaper at another store
I will buy this product again and in different shades
Ms.Klaus from Tracy Ca
I use instead of eye liner but if using as eye shadow more product needed.
no product in tube
nothing from undisclosed
I agree with many on this product. I paid a lot of money for something that I can't even scrape color out of. I used a Qtip to see if there was any cream powder in the tube and it came back with very little on it! I certainly did not get my money's worth. I now use the applicator for a better cream product
Loving this eye shadow
makeupfan from mpls
Great color and staying power. Use it when I want a little extra color on my eyes.
Color Strike in "Hustle"
Nene from Montana
I like this eyeshadow quite a bit. I'm not good at applying eyeshadow so I have to use suble colors. I bought the color "Hustle" only because it was the only one ULTA had in the store. It's a great color on me and very easy to apply and blend so I'm very happy with it. I see a ton of reviews these days regarding no product in tube or old product when new. I've experienced this also but not with this particular product as others have. My thinking is that because production was shut down due to COVID, we're buying products that were made pre-covid and should have been thrown out rather than sold to the consumer. It's happening too often to be just a coincidence.
Thank you, Maybelline!
UltaPrincess from Phoenix, AZ
So happy to find this product. I'm at the age where I don't want to spend hours on my makeup. This is so easy to drop in my purse or pocket, blends so well and looks natural.
Runs out way too fast
Mandy from Idaho
The color was nice, but I was only able to use it twice before no more product came out on the applicator
Dry, nothing in the tube.
IHateThisProduct from NEW Mexico
I went to do a swatch test and felt like I just wasted half the tube. The initial swatch was splotchy due to the applicator having nearly nothing on it. Dipped it in the tube multiple times and still barely anything came out.. Waste of money.
Debeydeb from Chicago, IL
Absolutely love this. Excellent pigment, stays on, did transfer to my crease and was true to color. I would absolutely buy this again.
redhead from Panama City Fl
I love how quick and easy this is to apply. It glides on with an intensity of color. Can be easily blended or softened with a brush. I have found it is best after applying on one eye to screw the applicator back on and then apply product to the other eye. The only down side is that the product empties pretty quick which can be expensive. I do love it and have bought it a few times!
The product is awesome
A from Wa
I bought gold shade, it is really very good, I love it
Nothing in it!
Case from North Carolina
Nothing to even get out! Terrible!
Love this product!
Cathy from Henderson, NV
Loved this product so much I bought a second color after trying the first one. Super easy to use for someone who doesn't wear much makeup. Color stays on all day and looks very nice
Kathyp from Wadesville, IN
This is so easy to use...especially for a novice like me! I can blend and highlight easily.
Karli from Chicago, IL
The product was empty. I figured I was using it wrong. I tried shaking it and nothing would be on the applicator. I tried pressing it onto my skin and it would just tug it. Very disappointed