Product Reviews Rated 4.2 out of 5 stars
16981 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Okay, this color is... Okay, this color is amazing! I think it is absolutely perfect for fall since it is so dark. It has a beautiful metallic shine to it which gives your lips some depth. I had never used it before and was pleasantly surprised to see how long it lasted. I put it on around 3 and drank a whole bottle of water and a can of Dr Pepper, I ate, and the color was still on and hadn't smudged off at all. So it is definitely long wear which is awesome. I also liked the fact that it is a buildable color. One layer gives you a fairly natural look which is nice for everyday, if you add on a couple of more layers you get a dark sultry lip. Definitely wanna try this in other colors as well.
Most Helpful Critical Review Disappointed I bought pitch black but when I put it on the lipstick wouldn't stick that well and wound up being fairly light as I couldn't get enough on to be even and fully black. It also came off immediately when I put my lips together.
Reviewed by 16981 customers I would by the product again.. 4
Steph from NJ
It was recommended by a beauty influencer..The Toffee goes with all my earth tone lippys..Just be careful when twisting it, only inch out a little at a time or the crayon part will break off..
Favorite Lipstick color! 5
Amy from Palm Desert, CA
Love everything about this lipstick. The color is beautiful and it's very moisturizing.
Awful! 1
Debuce from Dallas
I would never buy these product again. I wanted a clear lipliner to keep my lipstick from bleeding. I try the first one and it is very cakey & crumbly. Needless to say...Does NOT go on smooth!
I tried the 2nd one and it was the same. Very disappointing.
SENSATIONAL 5
Paola from California
I love it
Great for detail 5
Beasknees from Kansas City
The pencil is very thin, which means you can line with precision. It's not creamy, which means it doesn't smear. I got the brick red. It goes well with red lipsticks. It looked more red than brick red, so it didn't go well with my more brownish red lip colors.
Loveeeee 5
Deanna from New York
Super pigmented & easy to apply! Love
My Favorite Lipstick 5
KathyL from Arizona
I love this lipstick. On The Mauve is the perfect shade for me. It glides on so smooth and feels great on. It doesn't dry out. I have a lot of different brands of lipstick but this is my go to in any situation.
Didn't like color to pale 1
Laura from VA
Thought color would be darker do not like.
i would buy again and again 5
kay from maryland
this color liner with there lip gloss in topaz is perfect
Love it. 5
MissyB84 from Escalon
I use this with Almay GoWild lipstick & it looks amazing! Definitely would recommend!
Creamy and Pigmented 5
Emma from New Jersey
This was so easy to put on and I'm astounded by how pigmented and creamy it is. It's good even by itself.
Came in to get concealer and found this 2 5
Jess from California
I went into Ulta on Monday to get a concealer but this shade Romantic Rose caught my eye so I bought it and tried it. It's so pretty and my friends complimented it a lot under my mask. Stayed on under my mask as well. New fan!
I would definitely buy again. 5
Sparky54 from Wilmington, DE
Goes on very smoothly. Great color. Long Lasting.
I will definitely buy again 5
Remi from Ca
Very satiny, good price and lasted all day
Love love love! 5
Holly from Southlake, tx
This is the first Maybelline lipstick I've ever been able to find the exact shade of when i go to repurchase months later! This is my daily, go-to lipstick even under a mask. Wears well with an easy application and good texture. It does rub off, but you get what you pay for. I've been very satisfied.
Creamy and Colorful 5
Dani from Los Angeles
This goes on very nicely with good color coverage. The pink coral is bright and bold, almost red.
Always but this brand for precise lip liner 5
Bzymom183 from Pa
Precise liner for lips good coverage keeps color in place
Coverage not as expected. Returned same week. 3
Denny from Lexington Kentucky
Pretty color, cool nude, but coverage and formulation not as good as my Lancome or Charlotte Tilbury brands.
I Definitively buy it again and I will get mor colors!!!!! 5
Jane from winter park
It is one of the most that I like in lipsticks. I have them among the most favorites. I love it
I Definitively buy it again and I will get mor colors!!!!! 5
Jane from winter park
This lipstick is very creamy and its colors are spectacular, the brown tones are my favorites but I will get other shades as they are long-lasting and my lips feel well hydrated.
cute and creamy!! 5
Brooke from Hernando, MS
got this in purely nude, the perfect nude shade! very creamy formula
Non irritating 4
Sunshine from Tennessee
Works for my lip color needs . Does not make my lips peel. For all ages . Yes I'd recommend this lipstick formula.
Very cute 5
Mommy of5 from Texas
Very smooth
Love Color Sensational Shaping Lip Liner 5
The Sculptor from Rochester, NY
Draws on smoothly. It will even stay outside your natural lip line if you want that look. it stays on all day and the neutrals enhance your 'look' without looking overly made up. I love this product and it is my favorite lip pencil/filler because of that staying power and creaminess that makes it easy to put on. Not waxy and hard like some.
Nice color 4
Ingrid from Palm Coast, FL
Turned out to be a nice color, but not what it looks like on the top or actual pencil. I was looking for something darker.
