Product Reviews Rated 4.43 out of 5 stars
157 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review The only remover I use/need. Okay yall I just want to let ya know that this is amazing. I have extremely sensitive skin to the point where all makeup remover burns me. I also have skin conditions such as Morphea that I have to be mindful of and also allergies.
Thing is I don't have to worry about that stuff with this magical towel thingy. I do lots of extreme makeup looks and use more eyeliner than is probably expectable and this takes it off so easily and with no irritation. Its taken off waterproof mascara and eyeliner, brow pomade, full clown makeup (dont ask), etc.
I only use this funky little towel now. Its the only thing that works for me that doesn't make my skin burn.
If you're gonna listen to any one of these comments, take it from the alt girl who cosplays with hella sensitive skin and get this.
You'll need to replace it every 6-7 months due to it getting worn and ratty trust me its so worth it. I've used these exclusively for about 4 years now.
Very sry for the long review. Moral of the story- GET THIS!!!
(also included some of the eye looks so yall know I aint kidding (and i want to show off lol))
Most Helpful Critical Review Impressed at First, Then Irritated Skin First, I was blown away at this wipe. It literally feels like magic because I have no idea how it can take off all-day wear foundation with JUST WATER. It took of mascara after a few wipes, though it does smear if you don't remove eyelid/under eye makeup first.
After a few uses I noticed that my skin kind of had a burning sensation after I would wash my face and dry it. I'm wondering if this cloth exfoliates a little tooo deeply when it takes my makeup off. My skin isn't typically sensitive at all. I've never had issues with any face products. I'm still trying to figure out if it's the cloth or something else in my routine that is causing this, but I figured I would write this review in case someone else experienced this as well.
I still recommend this product because it does what it claims, really well. But may have some unfortunate side effects.
Reviewed by 157 customers It leaves black fuzzies on your face 1
Ginger from CT
I originally got the pink one in a fabfitfun box and LOVED IT. Lost it so bought the black one thinking it would hide makeup on it better but it leaves fuzzies alll over your face. VERY disappointed and will return
I'll stick to my makeup wipes… 1
Kay from NJ
I saw this was on sale so I decided to finally try it out after reading and watching reviews. I just used it for the first time and I couldn't be less impressed.
Definitely too good to be true. It doesn't take off mascara easily at all, it left lint all over my face, and it drags across your face. I washed my face twice after using this because I felt like it didn't get everything off. This might be a better product for someone who doesn't wear a lot of makeup.
I'm shocked at how many good reviews there are because they definitely fooled me! I never usually leave reviews but this was awful. I'll stick to my makeup removing wipes and cleansing balms!
Definitely a time where brand makes a difference 5
ER from MN
I've used knock-off erasers and even the tiny travel-sized Makeup Eraser - and I've been unimpressed with the efficacy.
I bought this full-sized one during a sale and color me shocked when I was able to take off even the most stubborn eye makeup with absolute ease. This is definitely a time where paying for the name brand seems to be worth it. I love the size, I can use it multiple times before requiring a wash and I love that I haven't needed additional makeup remover for mascara removal at all. I do find my skin is dry after using and I attribute that to not needing cleanser and just using hot water.
Awesome!! 5
IngridD925 from Wisconsin
Love this product. It takes off makeup effortlessly. I pack the ERASER when traveling, just add water and clean with Ivory soap after every use.
U NEED THIS NOW!!! 5
Lips&Gloss from port Hueneme,CA
I waited waaaaaay too long to buy this. I spent too many years stressing out and spending too much money too long on regular makeup removers.Since I like to use as many as it takes to remove all my makeup before washing my face I'd end up using between 3 and 4 wipes each time then before I knew it was time when I'd need to buy more. Then thanks to YouTube and a video about the best reusable makeup removers I came across this product. immediately I wanted one. I'm glad I did...I feel like I now I'm helping the planet a little bit more than I'm already trying. Another annoying thing that use to happen was when I was trying out new products and I only had a little bit to wipe off I didn't have anything small enough and end up wasting some of my regular wipes...now that'll never happen again. Now whether I have a small bit of new máscara or a full face this cloth takes care of either one. Definitely wash this before using and for things waterproof use micellar water...works like a charm. I'm no math genius but this product definitely saves you money in the long run and you're helping the planet while you're doing it so it's a win win
Irritated skin badly 2
Mama Pitt from Seattle
I wanted to love this . It's so soft! BUT a few hours later my skin burned a bit and my face felt like sand paper. Sure enough, I was covered in tiny blemishes like a rash. FWIW, I do have fairly sensitive combo skin. And I did not rub very hard. So I still use the tiny ones for eye makeup with no problem. But the full face cleaning was just too much and I'm afraid to try again .
Worth every penny and then some! 5
Cassie with a Clean Face from Saint George, UT
This thing is seriously amazing. A little hot water takes off all my eye makeup like it's nothing! I re-wet it for each eye, then again for the rest of my face, then one last time for the exfoliating side. My skin is so soft and happy afterwards, and I don't accidentally get makeup remover in my eyes trying to get off bits of eyeliner! The instructions say to wash it in hot water, but I do all my laundry in cold water and it still works just fine.
this is amazing 5
Kelly from NY
This is amazing. It takes off my eye makeup so easily, which is perfect because most makeup removers irritate my eyes.
Leaves fuzzy things on your face 2
Yelly from Pomona
I have a love hate relationship with this one. It does the job but leaves a lot of fuzz behind I really wouldn't recommend it. I would much rather use the 7 day small ones the valentine pink ones. I find that these take longer to remove makeup from my face.
I want more of these! 5
Jenn from Oklahoma
I bought one and love it! When my daughter used it she loved it so I bought her one, and I plan to buy a couple more so I have one ready to use when the other is in the washing machine.
Does exactly what it says 5
blxndesxoxo from new york
It removes makeup with only water. This is my second eraser and i haven't been disappointed once. A really good product.
Amazing!! 5
Texaslady from Texas
Removes all makeup, including eye makeup, just as advertised!
Leaves fuzz in your eyes! 2
Emily from Michigan
I have washed this 3 times to try to get rid of excess fuzz, but no matter what it always leaves little pieces of fuzz in my eyes when I use it. Using it last night left SEVEN pieces of fuzz in my eyes! I am not even using it that intensely! I will be sticking to the reusable bamboo pads and micellar water.
Love it. Would buy it again 5
Angie from LV,NV
Cleans in one sweep. Even glitter
I want to buy another one! 5
Jen from Oklahoma
It gets all my makeup off where a regular washcloth wasn't doing the trick.
Awful! Doesn't take off makeup and leaves lint behind. 1
Azboymom19 from Tucson, AZ
Let me start this review by saying that I received a small sized sample of the pink makeup eraser, and I fell in love with it so much when I used it for my eyes that I went out and bought 2 more of these big black ones for my face and the Christmas set that they came out with. I haven't messed with the Christmas ones yet, but this black one all I'm gonna say is wow!! What a huge fail. I followed directions as instructed- before first use put in washer and dry then use with water. It did nothing for my face, this thing kept dragging and pulling on my skin, no matter which side I used lint kept getting left behind and it just wasn't doing what it claims it will do. I have already washed it twice and only end up with small lint pieces all over my face. It's a huge disappointment because I am out of my money for the one that I used. It ended up going in the trash can, I think the smaller size sample one worked amazing so when this one performed this awful it was a big shock. As I have stated I have yet to try the other ones, and I kind of don't want to so I can return them, but I know I was for sure out of money on the first one that ended up in the trash. I wouldn't purchase again.
I have bought this 3x...It's LOVE 5
JthemakeupQueen from Fort Walton beach, Fl
This is absolutely a makeup eraser. Takes makeup off with ease and I use warm water and after using 4 days I wash it with dr bonners soaps! They clean it very well
I would buy this product again 5
Missy from El Dorado. AR
I was skeptical at first, but it really works!
it does what it claims 4
iggiemomma from central PA
I was skeptical at first, when I purchased this but it does do what it claims. I still wash my face to make sure all the makeup is gone. It does leave a bit of eye liner and such but only because you have to tug so much at your face to try to remove it.. but all in all, it works decently.
Worthy Investment 5
Peachyt34 from Kansas
I seriously love this! I was skeptical at first, but after using it, wow. I really didn't think it was going to remove my makeup, but it does! It is so soft and gentle non tugging, even when you rub a little rougher than you should, it is so so soft you hardly feel it. Mascara is a little trickier to get off so I use a little micellar water but it really does a fantastic job! No more makeup wipes here!
Impressed at First, Then Irritated Skin 3
yuliyavnik from Portland, OR
First, I was blown away at this wipe. It literally feels like magic because I have no idea how it can take off all-day wear foundation with JUST WATER. It took of mascara after a few wipes, though it does smear if you don't remove eyelid/under eye makeup first.
After a few uses I noticed that my skin kind of had a burning sensation after I would wash my face and dry it. I'm wondering if this cloth exfoliates a little tooo deeply when it takes my makeup off. My skin isn't typically sensitive at all. I've never had issues with any face products. I'm still trying to figure out if it's the cloth or something else in my routine that is causing this, but I figured I would write this review in case someone else experienced this as well.
I still recommend this product because it does what it claims, really well. But may have some unfortunate side effects.
I am blown away! 5
Taylor from Manahawkin, NJ
I am seriously blown away that this thing works. I don't know how, but it's the best thing I've ever bought to remove my make up and it does a great job. I don't wear waterproof mascara so I can't say how it stands up to that too well, but it definitely works on my face and eye make up even with primer and setting spray. Love it.
WITCHCRAFT 5
Liz from Phoenix AZ
This thing blows my mind, I was very skeptical but it has removed all kind of product - stuff that lasts all day otherwise. The only thing I haven't tried yet is waterproof mascara but if that's the only thing it can't take down it's still a 10/10
Not for me 2
Simple mom from Lafayette, IN
This sounded too good to be true, and it was.
It feels like I was dragging my skin off my face. It did not take off any of my mascara. Maybe for someone else, it would be fantastic, but for me, no thank you.
Surprisingly good 4
hwilson from Novi MI
I really didn't think this would work but it does. It removes makeup really well and is soft and non irritating. Sometimes I do have to go back over with a little bit of remover if I'm wearing a ton of eyeliner or really stubborn mascara but overall I really enjoy the no mess aspect of it.