Product Reviews Rated 3.72 out of 5 stars
429 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review My new favorite my new one and only Thank you to Maybelline for making this product I am a nurse so I M in the face mask most of the day and night so the only thing visible is basically my eyebrows, and I got to make sure they look spectacular I'm not allowed to wear any other make up on the floor except for this, a.k.a. anything on my eyebrows would be fine but I've tried the most expensive eyebrow Products out there nobody has been able to beat this, good job Maybelline
Most Helpful Critical Review make a fine tip and im sold Ok so this would be EVERYTHING if I had full brows. Unfortunately the lord blessed me with skinny brows and while I love this color and formula, the applicator just doesnt really work for me :( it does have great pigmentation and coverage as well as blendability and overall dark color without being too warm or cool coloration. The problem is that I have very thin and skinny brows naturally and this does not fill them in precise enough to where I could make my myself look even decent to go into public... which is unfortunate because I do actually really like this formulation and how it makes my brows look if I give it some serious work but if they formulated this into a finer tip instead of being so blunt and fat and stubby I would be in heaven and purchase it over and over again. Bottom line I like the formula I like the color I like pretty much everything except for the actual tip and if you change that then I would rebuy.
Reviewed by 429 customers Please add Auburn shade!!!! 5
Ineedanauburn from Fort Worth Texas
I absolutely adore this product but can you please make it in an Auburn shade? I've tried several shades but they just won't work with my naturally red hair. Please please make an Auburn shade for us gingers!
Best brow product yet! 5
Meg from Oregon
I wasn't sure how this would work, but I wanted to try it. I haven't tried anything like it! Other pomades, pencils, and gels tend to clump or leave patches once brushes through. This gives me quick, full brows that brush up easily to soften the edges and never leaves naked patches. Also, the price is AMAZING. I am going to but 5 more!
Brow Extensions Crayon 2
VeraFaye from Mountain Home, AR
When I first bought this a month ago the color was good and it was easy to use. However, in no time at all it dried out and there was no color to apply. If the color would have stayed I would like it. I prefer the older cake brow product with the small brush in it. I don't care to buy a new brow applicator every month! Maybe the product was old, I don't know but I wasn't pleased.
I order 5 at a time!!! 5
Cat from Baltimore
I literally order 5 at a time of these to keep stocked up in case they ever discontinue this. This is the most amazing brow product I have ever found. I have extremely sparse brows and this product extremely easily gives me full, fluffy and natural-looking brows. I layer some brow fiber gel on top and it completes the look perfectly. I have tried what I feel like is every brow product out there and nothing compares to this. It's also so easily since it doesn't require a brush. It's helpful to have a spoolie on hand to brush through brows before but I don't have to touch up with this product and setting spray. Please never ever discontinue, this is my holy grail brow product and I am obsessed.
Too little product 1
we got sunshine from sarasota, FL
I really wanted to love this product. Unfortunately, there is not much product. I used this every morning and it only last a couple of weeks. Will not be buying again. Rip off.
Excellent product! 5
LadyJBluebird from White Marsh, MD
At 73, brows are even more important to one's appearance. The full, dark brows of my younger years were getting thin and - horrors!! - gray! (I'm happy w gray hair, but not brows…). This is the first product I've tried that really does the trick. Not insufficient pencil color or smeary creamy stuff; this crayon pomade clings to and thickens existing brow hairs and covers the gray one perfectly. Thank you, Maybelline!!
Totally upset 1
Marthomp63 from Fayetteville, AR
Got the brow extensions. Was excited to think there were real hair fibers. Total disappointment. Just another eyebrow pencil
Redheads forgotten again! 1
Jenners411 from undisclosed
This product looks so promising and I was excited to pick out my shade but once again, there isn't an auburn option. I'm very disappointed.
Perfect for redhead 5
Georgie from Texas
Worked so well for me- a redhead! Couldn't believe how much fuller & real my brows looked- really awesome product
No, didn't cut it at all 1
Liz from Va
It didn't work properly on my brows
I swear people can't read 5
Sarah from San Jose
I love this product. It makes filling in my brows so quick and easy. Maybe it's not the best for full brows or sparse brows but I'm somewhere in the middle and it make my brows look fantastic. Yes, it has hair fibers in it. That's what it's supposed to have. The people who gave it 1-star reviews because they were grossed out by hair need to go back to school because they clearly can't read. I hope maybelline will extend their shade range so more people could use this product.
Love this crayon 5
Wiggie from Connecticut
I really love this crayon – it looks very very natural but gives me color where I need it on my brows! Thank you Maybelline!
clumps 3
arghhh from indiana
product (including fibres) clumps, leaving brows looking spotty. spoolie just removes it, doesn't spread.
Not for thin eyebrows 2
DebiR from Glen Ellyn, IL
Doesn't work well if your eyebrows are sparse. The color looked nice on the eyebrows that I have but didn't cover over the bare spots.
Did not like this 1
Skate89 from Wisconsin wis
I have blonde eyebrows and I bought the 250 blonde pencil.I love the way it made my eyebrows look but when I went to go put the cap on I noticed black hairs in it I went go tweeze them out but I kept noticing more so I tweezed them and i kept seeing hairs. It grossed me out
Very easy application and long lasting! 5
Connie McC from Bristol, Rhode Island
I have always thought of Maybelline products as being marketed to younger woman. Then I saw an ad in a magazine for your Brow Extensions Crayon and decided to try it. I feel compelled to tell you know how much I adore the Brow Extensions Crayon! I have told many of my contemporaries about this great product! They have converted and love it too!
I would also suggest that you think of promoting this to a more mature audience, as brows thin as we age! Wearing this product makes me look and feel 15 years younger! Thank you!
Know what you're getting 5
Sarah from Savannah
This is a great product if you have sparse brows and want something super quick that does it all. This does not fill in the skin under your brows—it darkens and attaches fibers to your existing brow hairs. I can run it over the length of my brow a few times to make them visible and be done. It's perfect for low maintenance days or when I'm in a rush. Love it. Worth a try if you have sparse brows and can't leave the house without some filling, IMO.
There's is life after 70 for eyebrows! 5
Wandalou28 from Winston Salem, NC
My eyebrows have never been super thick and lush but as I have grown older they have become almost nonexistent. I have tried numerous eyebrow applications and they either did not look good or simply did not wear well. So I did not expect much when I picked this product up.
My first application of the product was not impressive but I could see a more natural look and decided to try a different approach. I soon learned that the secret to a successful application was to relax the brow while applying and to use short soft strokes in the same direction of the eyebrow hairs. So it appears that the success or failure of the product is more in the manner the consumer applies the brow makeup.
I am going to add a few photos. Two will be with one eyebrow done and the other untouched. You will see that my brows are pretty pathetic (without some help). Then you will see the brows with the brow extension on both brows and it is hard to believe the difference. There are actual fibers in this product which give the illusion of more brow hair.
If your brows are like mine you will find this is a fabulous product. But don't try drawing the brow on...short strokes are the secret. If your brows are nice and you just need a little tweak, then you are likely to love the product too. Just remember, it is all in the application of the product.
Bad Twist Applicator 2
Tamryn from Flushing, New York
Although the product itself is good, the twist applicator stopped working so I was not able to get the full use of this item.
Best brow product 5
makeuplover from CA
This is a great brow product. I have very light brows with some sparse areas. This fills them in and the fibers make it look like real hair. The color is perfect. I use blonde and it is a cool blonde not a warm blonde. It makes my brows look thick and beautiful when they really aren't that way naturally.
When it drys it actually stays on for a long time! 3
Kerly_cue from Michigan
My eyebrows were green in the morning, but it stayed on & didn't smudge! Has this color changed happened to anyone else? Started with brown lol
Good fill-in, Does Not Smudge 4
FLKat from FL
It fills in thin brows really nicely and it does not run or smudge with sweat. You need to use, lotion or soap to remove.
Love this product 5
Barb J from CA
I love this product. It gives me thick, bushy brows that I've always wanted. I have stopped using brow pencil and just use this. I use a combo of blonde and soft brown.
Not For Me 3
shoegal from Las Vegas
This might be easier to use if the "crayon" was a little more pointed. This would allow you to make hair like strokes where you are missing eyebrows. I have heard some people remark that you should continue to move the tip around around so that you get more of a point.
This is way too much work when there are other better products on the market.
Oh, wow! 5
Rudey from Ft. Lauderdale
Best brow pencil I've ever used! I have blonde, sparse brows. Most pencils are too dark or harsh looking. The pale blonde is perfect. A few swipes and done, perfectly natural. The fibers make a huge difference for sparse brows.
