Rated 4.34 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Perfect Length
The Honest Company Extreme Length Mascara + Lash Primer has been the best thing that I have tried. I am so excited because I was not aware that there was a mascara that can lengthen my eyelashes extremely beautiful. I tend to have a problem with showing off my eyelashes with other mascaras as they clump my eyelashes. The Honest Company Extreme Length Mascara+ Lash Primer really showed off. As someone who has to wear a mask on a daily basis. I need my eyes to stand out. This mascara has made people hand out compliments in regards to my eyelashes. In my honest opinion, this brand is affordable. I would repurchase this brand as the compliments towards my eyelashes has increased my self-esteem. I would recommend this product to those who are looking for length in their eyelashes. **I received this product for free in exchange for my honest opinion.
Most Helpful Critical Review It's okay
It's an okay product. The brush for the primer doesn't pick up a lot so it looks like there's nothing on my lashes and the mascara makes my lashes look like spider legs, which I personally am not a fan of. However, I also have short Asian lashes so it's hard for me to find a good mascara, but it was good to keep them curled up but not so much lengthening. I also just pop on falsies anyway because mascara alone doesn't do anything to my lashes. I wish it was better because I wanted to like it!
Reviewed by 88 customers i love this mascara
annabel from georgia
this is one of the best mascaras i've ever used. i normally go with drugstore mascaras but saw this one was on sale so i thought why not try it. oh wow it did not disappoint at all. the last primer helped elongate my lashes and made me look like i had long full lashes when my lashes without anything on are tragic. i will be using this forever, the end, period.
Extreme length where???
MABM from Charlotte
Dry formula. The spikes on the wand are nonexistent (how is it supposed to get in there)?? Disappointed. Will splurge on the Lancôme Booster primer and use with my lash princess bc this is a joke. Lol
So good I'm buying 2 more!
Emma from Ohio
this is a great mascara and primer. I've already noticed my lashes look better without anything and I definitely think it's thanks to the primer! also most mascaras give me raccoon eyes due to my oily lids and skin, this one doesn't!! great overall lengthening formula
Daisy from San Diego, CA
I was very excited about trying out this mascara. Unfortunately, that won't be happening due to the mascara being completely dried out on both ends. It is upsetting to spend nearly $20 on a product that I will have to return and I do not plan on taking the risk and ordering
a new one.
I like it!
Mom from Iowa
I have been using a waterproof mascara and wanted some thing that was better for my lashes. It works just as well and doesn't have the bad for me or the environment chemicals. I will buy this again.
My New Go-To
Sarah from Illinois
I bought this mascara not expecting much. I was interested in a mascara that doesn't have the same nasty chemicals in it, but I didn't have high hopes that I would like it. It is great. It doesn't dry out my eyes like so many other mascaras do and I really like that it doesn't flake. to me this formula is a little bit flexible and while it can smudge if you really rub your eyes, it doesn't just disintegrate like so many others do. I highly recommend giving this stuff a go!
I will buy this again and again!
Lesa-with_an_e from Philly
I was gifted this by a Vegan friend of mine. I didnt have great hopes as I was PERFECTLY fine with my last brand that started with a "L". The first time I tried it I was stunned. The primer made my lashes full and long! I got compliments on my long lashes. Blackest black. So it wears for me all day-no flaking. At night its not a struggle what-so-ever to take it off. I will buy this over and over.
Love this mascara
Makeuplover from Texas
I get compliments on my lashes when I use this mascara NEVER in my life had that ever happened before!!
love this mascara
nbz from ny
I love it. it does wonders for my lashes. just wish it didn't dry out so fast. by month 3 it's already a long hassle trying to get the most out of both sides.
Skip if you have allergies
Dawn p from Canton
I wanted to love this product as I have bad allergies and noticed other mascaras irritated my eyes. This one didn't bother me when I put it on but the second you eye even gets a little watery even from the wind you have a black mascara mess.
Not Worth It
SS from Sparks, NV
So with the amount of mixed reviews I decided to give this product a try. Let me just say I should've side with the negative reviews. The first try was alright and it just got worse each try after that. Super clumpy and dry. I tried using one side with a different product and it was just as bad.
Love this product
JMD from Michigan
Perfect for everyday wear!
Allie from WA
As a casual makeup wearer this is the perfect mascara for me. Easy, clean, cruelty free, and makes my lashes long and noticeable without looking done up. So happy I purchased
All dried out
Yellie from Ohio
My tube came sealed in the box but both the primer and the mascara sides were so dry I couldn't even wipe any off on the back of my hand. I don't know if this formula is just really dry or these tubes were on sale BECAUSE they were old and dried out. I won't be reodering this product. Very disappointed.
simsmj from Nebraska
I have been looking for a more "clean" ingredient list for my mascara. I've tried Pacifica which wasn't too bad and I've tried W3LL which was a no. I kept looking for a clean mascara that doesn't smudge and give me raccoon eyes by the end of the day even with an eye primer. This is the winner. I love the wand, I love how it separates my lashes, I love the staying power. No smudging!
Primer is great, mascara is pretty cool
Laina from Seattle, WA
The primer helps I think. My eyelashes are SHORT and THIN but the primer definitely gives them a boost before the mascara. Both primer and mascara are light. Sadly this mascara runs BAD when it's cold/wet out, and ur wearing a mask. Beware! I've learned my lesson
Savage Steph from Albuquerque NM
My previous favorite mascara was the Jordana best lash extreme volume (RIP)... I got this because I really like the Honest beauty cleanser, blush, and primer. This is great. The formula is a medium consistency and it's so easy to use and build. I didnt know how I felt about a two step mascara but it took less time for me to use than my other mascaras that are a thick and dry consistency. I will keep buying this.
no for me
Sara from Nashville, TN
makes my eyes itchy and it clumps up very easily
DarthPenguin from Coachella
I bought this because I love Jessica Alba and love the concept of clean/conscious beauty products out on the market. I always research ingredients to find the best possible product for me. With this mascara I had high hopes but upon application my lashes completely went straight. Granted I have hard to c url lashes but I have been able to find a fair share of mascaras that keep my curl. Not this one. It DID give me length but what was the point of my lashes wilted down. If you have hard to curl lashes like me, then this mascara is probably not for you.
Love this mascara
Cleanmakeuplover from Texas
Never In my life had I ever gotten a complement about my lashes (they're short and straight) UNTIL I found this mascara I will never be without it
Chels from Grand Rapids, MI
This mascara is amazing on my straight lashes. I curl then prime. After waiting the recommended 30 seconds, I apply the mascara and they look so good. I usually have to curl my lashes throughout the day, with this mascara, I don't have too!
Sanjana from NJ
If you curl your lashes beforehand, the combination of the primer and mascara is really good. It makes your eyelashes look long and it doesn't clump much, from my experience.
Great Mascara and Primer
Rosy from Austin, TX
The primer makes a good foundation for the lashes; therefore, once you use the mascara, the lashes look twice as long.
THE BEST MASCARA FOR SENSITIVE EYES!
Pickychick from Charleston, WV
I purchased this with high hopes due to failures with all previous mascaras! I have extreme sensitive eyes and had given up on wearing mascara for many years. I restarted the mascara hunt again about two years ago! This mascara doesn't bother my eyes at all - and it gives me incredible volume and length! It should be noted that I have naturally short, fine, light colored lashes. Absolutely the greatest find ever! I receive random complements from strangers on my eyes now! It's not waterproof, so be aware that it will run if you get it wet. However - It does make it easy to remove and I believe non-waterproof mascaras are more gentle on the eyelashes. I'd prefer it in a brown-black if it were available as black is a little harsh with my N15 coloring. I use a brownish- black eyeliner and this helps soften the look some.
Not that great
Cassie from Texas
I really wanted to love this mascara- clean products, nice wand, nice packaging and great reviews...but it didn't work for me. The formula was very wet, lashes would clump, no length or volume. I tried it a couple of times and it was always the same.