Product Reviews Rated 3.04 out of 5 stars
27 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Great Liner This stuff is kinda the best... I got the star and moon versions of this liner (so far) and honestly I bought it for the stamp because the price is still reasonable but that liner... woah... was not expecting an incredible liner... It's a thin to thick felt tip and it's so easy to glide over your skin. It's super black so no grey winged lines haha and it stays on really well. I actually messed with it all over my eyes and hand when I got it and needed some makeup remover before i went in public hahahha the stamps work very well too, super pigmented, don't require any effort...
Most Helpful Critical Review Cute but it can smear This is a decent cheap liner as long as you NEVER touch your eyes or tear up. Unfortunately, I do both. My eyes tend to trickle a little on the outer corners, which not only removes the liner, but can sometimes cause it to well up and run if I get a bigger tear - like if I sneeze. I also can't not touch my eyes during the day. The stamp is cute and I like to use it to put a little moon on my cheek or under my eyes if I'm dressing up for something fun or going to like a Ren faire or something, but that basically means I don't pull this out for anything else unless I can't find another eyeliner. While I prefer my 20 dollar liners (mainly Stila, but sometimes sketch marker from too faced) ESSENCE makes a $3 waterproof liner that is better (far from perfect, but way better) if youre looking to actually use the felt tip end of this duo.
Reviewed by 27 customers Dryyyy!!!! 1
Dry from No
Dry!!!!! Should have read the reviews
dried out 2
chelly from michigan
I should've read the reviews before ordering, the moon side was completely dried out. waste of money
Over the moon Stamp Liner Duo 3
Crystal from Fort Worth, Tx
Bought this for my Daughter and we only bought this for the moon but sadly it was dried out. Such a disappointing product since we didn't get to use it for what we bought it for.
Buying My Own 5
Lin from Florida
We used this stamp for my sister's wedding and it was great. We had to fill in just a little bit with a regular eyeliner pen, but it looked so cute. Used a setting spray and it did not run or smear.. was an outside wedding in heat/humidity. I'd recommend. I'll be being my own.
Stamp was a little dry but I can probably rehydrate it 4
irlGoddess from Portage, IN
Would buy again
Moon dried out! 1
Shaleea from Minnesota
I should have read the reviews! The moon side was dried out... Hopefully I can at least color it with the liner and still use the stamp... Otherwise it was a FRIGGEN waste of money! I already have enough liners
Dried out 3
Luna from Louisiana
As with many other reviewers, I was so excited to get this bit the moon stamp side was completely dried out. Liner side works fine but that isn't why I purchased this.
Came dried out 3
Cat from California
I ordered this online. The pen side is nice but the stamp side is completely dried out. The eyeliner itself is okay
If I could give 0 stars I would 1
Des from Am
I ordered the moon and the music symbol, both were dry when I got them and didn't even work. NOT WORTH THE MONEY DONT BUY SUPER DISAPPOINTING!!!!
Buy it for the stamp 5
LML from Northeastern Pennsylvania
Just a good fun product
I'm pretty disappointed! 2
AfflictedDesire from Kentucky
I was so excited to stamp little moons on my face. Well. I got ONE stamp out of it. One. Then it was done forever. I don't understand why because the product still comes out of the other end just fine.
Stamp side was dry upon arrival 1
Jan from San Diego CA
Very excited to try the stamp as is why I bought the liner
Only to find it dried out.
Let it sit on the stamp side for a couple of days hoping the ink would seep back to that side and it would be usable. I was disappointed
Love The Stamp 5
CinCiti from San Francisco
I recommend giving it some shakes every time you use it bc the stamp piece dries out but once you shake it the ink comes back. The eyeliner is like any other felt tip eyeliner. I would buy again.
Best Eyeliner 5
Jordi from Vermont
Will definitely buy again for the felt tip eyeliner. The formula is very high quality and the tip doesn't dry out. The stamp is good too!. Will be using this as my go-to winged liner
Cute but it can smear 2
A Pickle from Connecticut
This is a decent cheap liner as long as you NEVER touch your eyes or tear up. Unfortunately, I do both. My eyes tend to trickle a little on the outer corners, which not only removes the liner, but can sometimes cause it to well up and run if I get a bigger tear - like if I sneeze. I also can't not touch my eyes during the day. The stamp is cute and I like to use it to put a little moon on my cheek or under my eyes if I'm dressing up for something fun or going to like a Ren faire or something, but that basically means I don't pull this out for anything else unless I can't find another eyeliner. While I prefer my 20 dollar liners (mainly Stila, but sometimes sketch marker from too faced) ESSENCE makes a $3 waterproof liner that is better (far from perfect, but way better) if youre looking to actually use the felt tip end of this duo.
Warning 1
Concerngrl from South Carolina
Why is the warning label of this product causing cancer only for California? Shouldn't everyone be aware of that?
Meh. 2
Heather from Virginia
The eyeliner part works great but there isn't enough liquid to supply the moon stamp to use it. I had to use another liquid eyeliner to supply liquid to it in order to use it. Waste of money.
I was so excited, but... 1
Robin C from PA
While the liner part of the pen works just fine, the stamp was dried out. I let it sit for a few days with the stamp side down, and it still didn't work. I was very disappointed as really the main reason I bought it was for the stamp.
Was dried out when i purchased it 1
February from NYC
Purchased all the stamp liners, all of them were cute except this one, which was dried out straight from out the package. Bummed out, was excited to use it.
Nerp 3
Beth from Joplin
I purchased this based on a previous Review saying they have tried a Lot of eyeliners... this was running down my face after a few hours...
Had to return 2
Kelsey from NY
I was so excited to get this but unfortunately it was already dried out when I received it. Had to return it.
Could this be my new favorite?! 5
Ashley from Salisbury, MD
I've been wearing liquid eyeliner daily for the last 10 years. I've tried sooooo many. I tend to like a thin felt tip liner, but they usually always end up fraying with daily use. This one, however, is a little thicker, but can still create defined lines. i've been using it every day for 2 months and it's still going strong. No fraying. It stays put! Does not smudge on me whatsoever. The little moon stamp is a bonus. Though, that was the original reason I bought it. I'm putting more use to the other end. And I love it.
How have I not seen this before! 5
Juju from austin
Ok, I stumbled on the very last one of these at an Ulta near me, and HAD to have it. I love moons. And then I gave it a little test run when I got home, and the stamp side is very clean in the shape it puts on. I think if you have trouble applying this with clean lines, go easy on her. It seems very waterproof, and did actually take some scrubbing with makeup remover before it came off.
Works great 4
Dez from WA
It is a juicy stamp but it doesn't have staying power. Primer and finishing powder will be needed to seal and extend the effects of the stamp.
Fantastic! 5
Thorsgirl from Racine, WI
I love this eyeliner. It's so pigmented extreme black and long lasting. The moon was the reason I purchased it. I can't get enough of this eyeliner. Highly recommended. For this price, you can't beat it.
