Store & Pickup Availability
How to Use
Rated 3.9 out of 5 stars
I absolutely love this mascara!! Its honestly the only one I can wear. I've tried everything, all brands, all hypoallergenic brands, and even the other organics wear from physicians formula... my eyes can't handle them at all, they burn, get red, and my vision gets cloudy and I wake up in the morning with super crusty eyes and it sucks.
With this one, I'm able to wear it everyday with no problems at all, and my eyes feel great the next day. I have absolutely no complaints about this mascara besides the fact I can't find it anywhere in my city now since the rebrand... i just ordered 5 from the this website and I really hope they come in soon! I hate not wearing mascara and the other ones hurt my eyes too much... i honestly have no lashes at all!
Note: I have straight eyelashes that have a hard time holding a curl
I got this since it was organic. I found the color and texture to be fine. I'm not sure why but when initially applying it the product began to sting my eyes within 3ish hours of wear. It stopped happening after about a week so not sure what to make of that.
It definitely smudges, esp if you apply many coats to the lashes. Works better if you're a single coat kinda person. Did not hold the curl in my lashes super well nor did it really add any length or volume (just kinda defined what was already there)
For the price (for an organic mascara) it's okay. Definitely have used slightly more expensive organic products that do a better job.
Florida Lady from Riverview, FL
I have used this mascara on my sensitive eyes for years and love it. It applies well and doesn't clump. I have never had a reaction to this mascara as I have others that claim to be designed for sensitive eyes.
lauriej10 from undisclosed
I wanted a mascara that was cruelty free and I bought this. I loved the way it looks when applied, however, it flaked after a full day.
Kelly from Pennsylvania
There are so many non-toxic mascaras that are so expensive. This product is not only clean, but so affordable. This mascara is long-lasting, does not clump, and made my lashes seem longer, although since switching to non-toxic mascaras, I definitely notice my lashes are longer! If you have not tried non-toxic mascara before, you will find that clean mascaras are typically not waterproof. You shouldn't get smudging during the day, but when you wash your face, the mascara comes right off without that sticky, hard to remove residue tradutional mascara leaves. It makes makeup removing so easy. Will repurchase!
MR from Ohio
Good mascara, separates lashes okay, love the natural ingredients, like the volume, droops through out day of wearing a mask where warm breath can reach lashes.
Calimo from Midwest
Not happy with this at all. Used the old version all the time. This new formula flattened my lashes and burned my eyes.
christinag_34 from undisclosed
Drugstore for the win! This is one of the only drugstore mascaras I like, it's been a while since I've worn it, off to rebuy it.
Olivia from TN
This is the only mascara I have been able to find that does not bother my eyes by the end of the day! I will continue to buy this in the future. With any other mascaras in the past, I cannot wait to get home and wash it off at the end of the day, but not with this.
Celeste D. from undisclosed
I like wearing this mascara since it has natural ingredients. It helps my eyelashes look longer!
Mal MC from MC IA
I use this most days I work from home, it's a great little boost to my lashes. It's light, goes on super smooth, and is very natural looking. Love the clean ingredients. I've used a lot of organic mascara that clumps cracks or flakes easily and this is hands down the best I've tried. I get upset if I run out without a backup!
Mimi from Frisco, TX
This is the only mascara that has ever worked for me. I would not change it for anything.
IndyMom23 from Fort Wayne, IN
This is the first mascara I have tried from Physicians Formula, and it will probably be the last as well. It does not lengthen or volumize my lashes, and it smudges below the eyes within a few hours of application. It is not inexpensive, so I expected much more from it. All in all a huge disappointment!
Sol from undisclosed
Great eyeliner for the price. I have sensitive eyes and the mascara does not irritate my eyes. The mascara does not flake easily or smudge.
Ali Z from California
Expensive and doesn't work. The mascara does not work at all. It doesn't do anything for your lashes, it makes my lashes straight after I curl them and rubs off :( Just money gone to waste because I won't be using it.
Skc from San mateo
Really like product
annie35 from marshfield MA
i bought this mascara a little while ago and my lashes have never looked better. they are not clumpy and short but long and luscious. it's also a very nice color(black). and it lasts a long time and it's all natural/ organic so it doesn't dry out your lashes or rip them out.
Ris from Oklahoma
Best mascara I've ever tried and the only mascara my teen will use.
ekatharine from Ft Worth, TX
Sam from Denver, CO
This product is one of the only mascaras that doesnt bother my eyes. I can wear it all day and my eyes dont react at all. The only downside is it smudges pretty badly, but I can deal with that to not have dry and itchy eyes all day
:) from GA
This mascara is fantastic - it doesn't ever feel completely dry which doesn't bother me but should be noted before you buy. It makes my lashes look so full and beautiful and I am so pumped its clean! I adore this brand.
Wontawn from Ontario, Canada
Kay in Dallas from Dallas TX
Perfect mascara to apply after eyelash primer ! The formula and the wand bristles make for excellent application.I can easily pick up each lash to sweep the lash with color. I am a makeup fan and wear dramatic shadows, liners,so this macara really allows for defintion of each lash. I recently had eye surgery and was only confident to wear something with gentle after healing. Well Iam glad I did my homework to find this .Thank you!
V from Santa Cruz, CA
Great mascara! Not sure if PF discontinued the Organic Curl & Care I used to get, but I actually prefer Organic Wear Natural Origin. Also appreciate that it shipped with minimal packaging.
Morganacm from Little Rock
I tried this because my stockpile of the old organic wear mascara ran out and I can't find anymore. This mascara did not work for me, it was too heavy and caused my lashes to flatten out and uncurl. PLEASE bring back the old version!!!
kristen from Panama City Beach
I bought this mascara bc it's organic. This mascara is one of the most terrible mascaras I've ever tried, it wound up all under my eyes and even in my eyes within a matter of minutes! it doesn't last at all, takes forever to dry, feels very waxy and heavy, all in all it is awful.
MissMarieChic from undisclosed
For a while now I have noticed I cannot use regular mascara; literally to the point right after application my eyelash follicles would be irritated and my eyes turning red. I have used "hypoallergenic" mascaras but still had irritation and the ingredients were full of chemicals. This mascara does the job without causing irritation and the ingredients are way more natural. The price is affordable. There is a little fall out but most mascaras do that anyway unless they are waterproof.
This product dries a little quick so just apply a couple of coats without waiting too long. My eyelashes felt weightless it was so nice to experience and it didn't feel like I was wearing makeup.